5 ms·
That thing looks like a maintenance nightmare.
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
That thing looks like a maintenance nightmare.
- adventured 8y agoYou're thinking of the present. It's first stage tech. From here you'd keep iterating - learning, improving, trying various approaches.
- pimlottc 8y agoSure, but it seems almost certain to have more mechanical issues over time than a traditional wheel that doesn't have so many, er, moving parts.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoI'm hardly an expert, but I believe caterpillar treads have been in regular use for over a century and still take loads of maintenance compared to wheels. However effective it may ultimately be, it seems unlikely that this team will solve that particular problem.
- vvanders 8y agoYup, quickest way to eat into your bank account is to "save" money buying a 20k hour+ old excavator.
- DenisM 8y agoYou’re not kidding. Maybe the track version is meant to be used only rarely, when the vehicle is truly stuck. So you’re either wasting time digging yourself out with a shovel and saving on maintenance, or you switch to tracks to get out of the ditch and then perform maintenance right after you get back to the base. So long as maintenance is not deferred it seems preferable to do the latter.
- walshemj 8y agoProbably for special purpose vehicles not as a replacement for wheels on Humvees / Landy's
- jonhendry18 8y agoThis. Humvees are probably just what's readily available as a test platform. If such a wheel/track is ever used for real, it might be on something very different, and not on the front lines. And possibly larger or smaller than this.
- Someone 8y agoI would think this will need way more maintenance than a regular wheel/tyre combination even if only used in the ‘round’ configuration. I also worry about what a hand grenade or small IED will do to this contraption, compared to what it will do to a conventional tyre. Even if it is as strong, it likely still will increase mean time between repairs, as, when one breaks down, it’s more likely that one will have a regular tyre at hand than that one has one of these.
- banku_brougham 8y agoAnd how often do humvees get stuck anyway? I like the product, but it’s obviously wasteful. During the Iraq insurgency what was wanted was armor plating. Literally just 1/4” slabs of steel. This is of a piece with the F-35.
- Swizec 8y agoHumvees get stuck a lot! The US donated (I’m sure with wink wink strings attached) to us, Slovenia, some years ago and it was quickly found that they are too large and cumbersome for our foresty mountanous terrain. They’d get stuck all the time on tiny roads or between trees. I think these days they’re used for paraded to show we have them but day to day the military keeps using their trusti Puchs from who knows when. Tiny and manouverable.
- qaq 8y agoUS is not fighting in areas where getting stuck between trees is a big issue.
- chiph 8y agoExcept maybe the western European nations like Germany. But it may be that Germany has had USAEUR there long enough so that they have cut wider roads in their forests for military vehicles. I was stationed there when they were introduced to the theater in the 80's and they didn't have any significant problems.
- gpm 8y agoGiven how much money the US spends on its military I'd expect them to be prepared to fight just about anywhere. Certainly in "foresty mountanous terrain" since that isn't particularly rare. Exists inside of the US. Exists on both borders of the US. Etc. Producing a military optimized for "blowing up unsophisticated enemies in desserts" seems like a very shorted sighted way to spend the military budget. (None of the above should be taken as me defending spending so much on the military as a whole, just on the allocation of the budget within the military to all sorts of terrain when taking the size of the current budget as a given).