5 ms·
I don't think people want IRC for the lack of functionality. I think they miss IRC because they see in Slack a real threat to decentralization, privacy and open
by csomar 8y ago
I don't think people want IRC for the lack of functionality. I think they miss IRC because they see in Slack a real threat to decentralization, privacy and openness.
I don't use IRC. But I'd never use Slack either in a project I maintain/lead. We need a better alternative.
- barbs 8y agoMatrix?
- ixf 8y agoCertainly a huge improvement over Slack in that it's federated. It's not quite there yet, but certainly usable today - it needs to mature a little yet.
- rasengan 8y agoAlso, slack is like a dumbed down version of IRC. As an example, on IRC you could run an auction or a 10000 person university lecture because there is a +m channel mode (moderation). +m quiets all users in the channel and only allows you to speak if you receive the channel-user mode +v (voice) or have +o (operator status). Some ircds also have a +h etc. You can setup bots like “RaiseYourHand” for people who want to ask questions and need temporary voice (+v). Try that on slack, telegram, signal, etc. Its impossible. IRC was ACTUALLY built for collaboration and communication. Slack was built to make money. The difference in goals causes a different outcome.
- neoromantique 8y agoWhile I get where you're coming at, but it is indeed possible in Telegram, not sure regarding Slack.
- detuur 8y agoActually, Discord does this pretty well. I honestly consider it a 21st century successor to IRC. The unfortunate fact is that Discord is still a closed system, with not even the ability to run your own instance, instead with the owners insisting on a cloud-run infrastructure. Just imagine how much better Discord, Slack, et al. could be if you could host your own instances with your own rules and with your own extensions.
- krageon 8y agoIf it is closed (and nominally 'free' for the average user), you have to assume everything you say and do is being mined and sold to the highest bidder. How can something like that be the successor to anything?
- coatmatter 8y ago> I don't think people want IRC for the lack of functionality. I do, and I think it's a good constraint (better than the 140/280 char Tweet restriction). No excessive notifications by default, no impatient people (at least largely not because they don't tend to hang around anyway). The pace is more predictable and consistent, and it's easier than ever to have a 24/7 detached client/bouncer. For some years, fancier services like Facebook robbed creativity and time from me but lately I've returned to a more simple flow that isn't affected by Eternal September. IRC has a certain barrier of entry, so that tends to keep a lot of the low quality noise away (where it remains on other platforms such as Discord and YouTube). I recognise that Slack and Discord have their own objectives, but IRC covers its own niche well.
- Fnoord 8y agoIRC is centralised as well, but the protocol is documented. So it is possible to apply encryption on top of it within your client with a plugin or whatever. I'm not sure if that's possible with Slack? Look at it from this angle: would you want a for-profit entity to have access to your internal debates about development? Including the potential security implications? Things like these are a goldmine of data, and a time bomb waiting to explode.