3 ms·
We don't even have an enumerated right to privacy! The right to privacy is made explicit in many places, especially judicial precedent. It just isn't explicitl
by joe_the_user 16y ago
We don't even have an enumerated right to privacy!
The right to privacy is made explicit in many places, especially judicial precedent. It just isn't explicitly stated in the constitution.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griswold_v._Connecticut http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griswold_v._Connecticut
"While the opinion in Lawrence was framed in terms of the right to liberty, Kennedy described the 'right to privacy' found in Griswold as the 'most pertinent beginning point' in the evolution of the concepts embodied in Lawrence..."
That would qualify as "enumerated" to me.
- tptacek 16y agoLet's avoid a rathole, stipulate that privacy is a Constitutional objective recognized by the Supreme Court, and re-focus on the fact that you clearly don't have a right to be free from wire taps.
- joe_the_user 16y agoWell... in the process of investigating and punishing people, the justice system pretty much inherently must negate many otherwise recognized rights. You do have the right to be free of wiretaps - except in the course of a court-ordered investigation. You have a right to not be a slave - except when you violate the law and the state forces you to work, etc.. This is why its important to limit the purview of government, why even if we allow prosecutors to spy on people, we might not want them to easily spy on people, etc.
- tptacek 16y agoWe don't want them easily spying on people, but we might not want it to be virtually impossible for them to spy on people by default. I use the word "might" because I myself am not sure. But I definitely see the dilemma they face, and my reaction to it is not knee-jerk.
- jackvalentine 16y agoThe level of difficulty the government has in spying on people should be inflicted through the judiciary - obtaining a warrant and the like with appropriate punishments for setting aside this process. I have not looked deeply in to this though, so apart from that point I have no position on this proposal.