3 ms·
Why not mention the state? You should contact your state representative (not member of Congress) and state senator (not US Senator) and let them know that you
by pc86 8y ago
Why not mention the state?
You should contact your state representative (not member of Congress) and state senator (not US Senator) and let them know that you were denied a well-paying job because of the onerous standards your state has for remote work. They might be inclined to change it.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoIt's unlikely a state is going to unwind their taxing and funding model for a few remote jobs (nor should they). EDIT: OP mentions the state in question is Florida, which has no personal income tax, but does have a state sales tax (disclaimer: I am also a resident of Florida); I believe a recent court decision on the HN front page [+] makes that a moot point (the business will have to collect those sales taxes regardless of nexus), which leads me to believe their decision not to hire OP was a bit short sighted. [+] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17365366 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17365366 | https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-06-21/states-can-require-internet-tax-collection-supreme-court-rules-jiomtl5c https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-06-21/states-ca... (Online Retailers Can Be Forced to Collect Tax, High Court Rules)
- Klathmon 8y agoI actually thought I did (it's Florida by the way)... I want to be clear, that I don't blame the state in the slightest. I honestly feel that companies should have to pay taxes where they operate regardless of how many employees live there, but what sucks is that a lot of states have difficult tax codes, esoteric and difficult ways of sending taxes in, have varying laws that make it extremely hard to follow the law unless you are a lawyer familiar with that area, and often won't help you if you need it. I also don't really blame the company. I still feel like I would have been more than worth the extra hassle, but they aren't sure. And if they can avoid having to pay taxes in that state by not hiring me, and that can provide them a material benefit, then I'd probably do the same as them if I were in their position.
- djschnei 8y agoBlame the state! A complicated, unwieldy tax code is their/our fault. They created an untenable system that got in the way of you entering into a mutually beneficial contract with another individual(s). It is 100% their fault.
- Klathmon 8y agoBut it may not have been my state in particular, but the fact that they are all different. Even the easiest tax system in the world won't make up for the fact that they need to record and charge for tax in that state, then send that money back to the state. Short of not having sales tax, there really isn't a way that they can simplify it. And again, unless you are a lawyer that knows the tax laws in that area, you won't know how good or bad the local tax system is until you go to try and enter it.
- T2_t2 8y agoWhy not centralise it? Imagine a single account# that employees were paid to, where everything was taken care of? Lets say one earns $120K, an employer pays $10K a month to that number, and everything is taken care of, and the employee is responsible for the outcomes, e.g. if you move, you are responsible for changing your state of residence. It is weird - and I say this as an Australian - that an employer can be on the hook for employee's moving. it would be much easier if this was managed centrally.
- T2_t2 8y agoAmerica has it rough there. Australia (with a MUCH lower population) has only federal income tax, and a clear delineation of what taxes each level of government can charge.
- ajross 8y ago> I also don't really blame the company. You should. Or conversely, you can look at this as having dodged a bullet. On paper, they were willing to commit to multiple years of a presumptively-six-figure salary to you (seriously: an employment agreement is a big financial deal, even if it's legally "at will" -- there's a lot of money on the table) but pulled out because of some fear of bureaucracy and (maybe) a tax increase? That tells me that the commitment they were thinking of putting on paper wasn't worth, heh, the paper. That's not a loyal employer, basically. If they're willing to cut corners with the State of Florida they'll do it with their own employees too.