6 ms·
There is still enough contrast as to be readable, but the contrast isn’t as harsh as black vs. white. Still readable, yes, but I find the black more readable.
by scott_s 16y ago
There is still enough contrast as to be readable, but the contrast isn’t as harsh as black vs. white.
Still readable, yes, but I find the black more readable. Taking webpage design cues from schools of painting is a fine strategy as long as you remember that webpages have a different goal from paintings. This implies that everytime you transfer something from a school of painting to webdesign, you have to ask yourself "Does this principle undermine the purpose of a webpage?"
- nroach 16y agoOn my monitor, the black text was more readable as well. The brown text required perceptible effort to read. I agree with scott_s. If you goal is to deliver information, the black text is superior.
- acqq 16y agoMost of the texts with "gray on white" are very hard to read on my monitor. I know that on bad LCD monitors gray is easier to read, but not everybody has bad monitors. So generally regarding light gray texts, one more example of "everybody has what I have." Regarding the article: a lot of painters used black too. Even more printers. Don't you think that the books would be printed with gray or colored ink if that would be more readable? I'm sure enough experiments have shown that it just isn't. The arguments are very suspicious.
- chc 16y agoBut by the same token, if gray is easier on some people's monitors, using high-contrast text is also an example of "everybody has what I have."
- acqq 16y agoThe major question is then: should the text be adjusted for the people who read or for the people who don't. I believe that super-high contrast and too bright screens are more common among the people who watch videos and photos or play games more than read the texts on the screen.
- alsomike 16y agoMaybe you will find this interesting: graphic designers have lots of rules about the proper use of typography when laying out a document, like correct kerning, use of old-style numerals, ligatures, etc. The reason for following those rules has to do with the same principles of harmony and naturalness in this blog post, but when researchers tested the impact of "good" typography vs. "bad" typography, they found no differences in performance measures like reading comprehension or reading speed. They did find differences on other measures - in the good typography condition, participants underestimated the amount of time they had spent reading (a measure of engagement with the task) compared to participants in the "bad typography" condition. But the most interesting finding was when they tested creative cognition - on that test, the "good typography" participants scored much better than the "bad typography" participants. This might explain why we designers insist on good typography (and other design principles). Creativity is a big part of our job, and we want to avoid things that might impair the performance of our creative cognition. But for people in other, "left-brained" professions, enhancing creativity is less important and engaging people is less important, so it makes sense that they would see design rules as irrelevant extra work of little value. Designers rush to judgment when they see "bad" design because it almost literally hurts their brain. But, maybe the person who designed it or the audience for it doesn't have that kind of brain - and that's OK.
- scott_s 16y agoI think high contrast text is good typography. But for people in other, "left-brained" professions, enhancing creativity is less important and engaging people is less important, so it makes sense that they would see design rules as irrelevant extra work of little value. If you assume my work requires no creativity, or that I think design rules are irrelevant, then you are mistaken. I don't like design for the sake of design. I do like design that looks good and enhances a things intended purpose.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoYou think it is, why? And what evidence do you have to prove it?
- billswift 16y agoThe best thing to do with text on a monitor is to keep the text black but make the background less bright. I actually prefer bright yellow on a CRT since that seriously reduces the glare while still being as easily readable as black on white paper. On an LCD where glare isn't a problem, almost anything warm pastel is good; you lose contrast more with cooler colors.
- radley 16y agoThe black actually is more readable. The problem is that the author over-compensated to make his point and selected a dark neutral (#5-6) instead of a neutral dark (#3-4). The simple answer is #0 black doesn't anti-alias very well and distracts the reader. Almost anything #2 and darker will look the same (for text), especially on cheap PC monitors. #3 range works best for print-like black and #4 will hint of off-print black. #5 is the beginning of "over-designed" fuzziness.