7 ms·
>> The popular gorilla, known for her extraordinary mastery of sign language, has passed away at the age of 46. About the "extraordinary mastery of sign langua
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> The popular gorilla, known for her extraordinary mastery of sign language, has passed away at the age of 46.
About the "extraordinary mastery of sign language", wikipedia has this to say:
As with other great ape language experiments, the extent to which Koko mastered and demonstrated language through the use of these signs is disputed.[4][5] But it is generally accepted that she did not use syntax or grammar, and that her use of language did not exceed that of a young human child.
(...)
Following Patterson's initial publications in 1978, a series of critical evaluations of her reports of signing behavior in great apes argued that video evidence suggested that Koko was simply being prompted by their trainers' unconscious cues to display specific signs, in what is commonly called the Clever Hans effect
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koko_(gorilla) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koko_(gorilla)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ben509 8y agoI want to credit this to Steven Pinker but I'm not certain... He had a great metaphor for this phenomenon of people perceiving human linguistic capabilities in animals: imagine if some elephant scientists were looking at various species' noses, they'd be saying, "look at how they can wiggle their nose! That's just astounding! And this one can balance a ball on his nose! It's uncanny how elephant he is!" The point being that our ability for language is biologically a very unique facility, even if it can sometimes sound like more ordinary non-linguistic communication. And it's not uncommon in nature for a species to have a very highly evolved capability, at the same time, it takes evolution to make that happen. No amount of stretching, for instance, is going to give you a giraffe's neck.
- BalinKing 8y agoSteven Pinker definitely talks about Koko in The Language Instinct... IIRC, let's just say he doesn't have the highest opinion of the experiment ;-)
- ThemalSpan 8y agoFirst, let me clearly state that I agree that the "science" surrounding Koko was not great, and that her language abilities are consistently overstated. However, as someone who has met Koko I can also tell you that there is something there. She did not have a human mastery of sign language, but was capable of communicating new and unique ideas. It was remarkable to witness. She was a genuine friend to those who knew her well. As with most things the truth is somewhere in the middle, right?
- bojan 8y ago> As with most things the truth is somewhere in the middle, right? Personally I really hate this assertion. The truth doesn't care if it is in the middle or not.
- ansible 8y agoYes, the truth can be somewhere else entirely. And it doesn't have to fall along some neat axis made up by humans.
- arbitrage 8y agoYou know it's a metaphor, right?
- Numberwang 8y agoA metaphor for shit thinking that people interpret as profound. A deepity.
- vibrato 8y agoYea nothing profound about the eightfold path... /s
- drb91 8y agoWell, that’s what you get for interpreting idioms literally.
- coldtea 8y agoThat said, one would presume there would be no shortage of jealous rival researchers ready to say any BS as a critique for any study. It happens in way more rigorous domains, much less in the question of whether an animal can learn some basic communication. The jury is still out there as far as I'm concerned.
- yanslookup 8y agobasic communication is not language. The jury is not out, I'm not going to repeat the facts but it is pretty clear to ANY linguist that Koko and all of the animal kingdom do not have language. CHOMSKY: That’s about like saying that Olympic high jumpers fly better than young birds who’ve just come out of the egg — or than most chickens. These are not serious comparisons. For whatever reason, the study of human higher mental faculties is pervaded by a curious form of irrationality, foreign to the sciences.
- coldtea 8y ago>basic communication is not language. That's an statement based on arbitrary (and vague) definitions of the (already vague) words "communication" and "language". It also presupposes what it should try to prove: that Koko was only capable of "basic communication". (Not to mention the quality of our general understanding of language, which is primitive in itself, as is our understanding of how we, and even more so how animals, think). >CHOMSKY: That’s about like saying that Olympic high jumpers fly better than young birds who’ve just come out of the egg — or than most chickens. These are not serious comparisons. For whatever reason, the study of human higher mental faculties is pervaded by a curious form of irrationality, foreign to the sciences. Well, Chomsky wouldn't be the best example against irrationality. He has his closely held beliefs he touts whether they pan out or not. And I'm not even taking about his politics, rather his concept of brains "hardwire" grammar center...
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> That said, one would presume there would be no shortage of jealous rival researchers ready to say any BS as a critique for any study. Well, science is a debate- and not necessarily a nice one. There will always be rivals, waiting in the wings to skewer your arguments. The ideas that end up being adopted by the majority are the ones best supported by their originators, either with evidence or whatever else happens to be handy.
- csomar 8y agoYoung human child? That’s pretty impressive. Did scientists try to breed intelligent monkies like breeding dogs?
- opportune 8y agoNo but they absolutely should. On a slightly tangential note I think there should be a handful of programs focused on domestication of species similar to the Soviet experiments in the domestication of foxes. We could learn a lot more about domestication and in a few hundred years have new pets! I doubt it would even be that expensive on a yearly basis to attempt to domesticate eg lemurs (who are great candidates due to their social/pack behavior in many species, similar to dogs)
- ollieshmollie 8y agoSaw a nice video on the dispute of apes' mastery of sign language over at NPR: https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/07/25/538580495/what-are-the-planet-s-real-talking-chimps-and-gorillas-saying https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/07/25/5385804...