4 ms·
I think regardless of the laws that the government passes, people will still be able to use secure crypto. Look at the war on drugs -- anyone that wants drugs
by jrockway 16y ago
I think regardless of the laws that the government passes, people will still be able to use secure crypto. Look at the war on drugs -- anyone that wants drugs can easily get them, they just cost more than they would otherwise, and the taxpayers have to pay billions of dollars a year to provide free room and board for anyone that keeps too many drugs in one place.
If you are committing treason, or something, the price of going to prison for using PGP is much less than the death sentence you'd get if you sent the messages in the clear.
I also don't see laws against crypto (and steganography) really being effective. A law is one thing, convicting people for violating them is another.
Think about what a tough time the government has in bringing cases against criminals. It's 50/50 as to whether or not they can convince a jury to convict when they have a security videotape of the accused gunning someone down. "And here we see the defendant discharging his handgun into Ms. Smith."
Do you really think they're going to be able to get convictions for people alleged to be hiding encrypted data in normal streams? "It's clear from the noise pattern in this image that there is a hidden bitstream in the low-order bits. This means that anyone exchanging this image is probably forwarding on encrypted terrorist communications. We can't actually prove this beyond a reasonable doubt... it is possible that they used a buggy version of Photoshop when they were resizing it for their lolcat blog. But probably terrorism!!"
I am not losing much sleep over this.
- makmanalp 16y agoIf you posses drugs, you're following illegal conduct, and you can be fined or imprisoned. Similarly, if we end up with a government OK'd list of crypto schemes, those of us who use strong crypto legitimately will be criminals. Also, in the UK, you can get charged for not handing over encryption keys.
- jrockway 16y agoIf you posses drugs, you're following illegal conduct, and you can be fined or imprisoned. Similarly, if we end up with a government OK'd list of crypto schemes, those of us who use strong crypto legitimately will be criminals. Well, yeah. But you have a right to be tried by a jury of your peers... who probably won't understand crypto. (The "drugs are bad... except coffee and cigarettes and high fructose corn syrup" propaganda caught on pretty well, so you are probably stuck there. But there is no "strong cryptography is bad" rhetoric out there, and it will be hard to argue for -- the opposite is "the government is trying to steal your credit card number".) Anyway, the whole point of the Constitution was to allow people to do things that the government didn't want them to do. Using strong cryptography is the modern way to for one to "be secure in their persons, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures". Finally, it seems that this round of laws is directed at service providers that store encrypted messages; the government wants you to be able to read everything passing through your network. Of course, you do not control the P2P network that your movies and phone calls pass through, so this law has limited effect. Even then, if end users provide their own encryption, that's out of the scope of this law. The government cannot read every packet that passes over the Internet.
- poet 16y agoBut there is no "strong cryptography is bad" rhetoric out there... How about Tor being used for CP? That's a pretty prevalent and well known argument. Any competent lawyer is going to be able to spin the same argument for strong crypto.
- jrockway 16y agoAnd competent lawyer on the other side is going to say, "online banking". I mean, guns are still legal right, despite the fact that people murder each other with them.
- poet 16y agoI agree with you on a logical level, I just don't think that's how it plays out in the average voter's/politician's mind. The logical leap between guns and Tor just isn't made in practice.
- jrockway 16y agoI feel that this is an issue for the courts rather than the representatives, and the courts are less influenced by Joe Gun-nut than the elected officials he directly elects. So while surely there will be some new law censoring the Internets, the courts will probably strike it down. (I mean, are we really going to send people to prison for not upgrading their ssh servers? I doubt it.)
- niels_olson 16y agoI just want to be clear: you're not arguing about the merits, just that you shouldn't care? Is that an efficient use of time?
- makmanalp 16y agoI agree with the sentiment here, but it should just be not illegal. It's sort of like how in China and Iran or Turkey (my home country) certain web sites are banned but people find ways to get around that anyway. Is that how it should be? The banning should not be there in the first place.
- joe_the_user 16y agoUnlike drugs, crypto is something you can make in your own home with freely available materials... at least until they outlaw debuggers... (inserting obligatory right-to-read reference).