8 ms·
In a world of digital nomads, we will all be made homeless
- everdev 8y ago> WeWork is slowly expanding into a new venture called WeLive, up and running in New York and Washington DC, set to open for business in Seattle, and also planned for Tel Aviv. If accommodation is proving hard to find, you need company, and your life as a freelance means you have no permanent workplace where you can meet like-minded people, here is a solution: a range of tiny studio flats and slightly bigger dwellings, built around communal areas, kitchens and laundrettes – in the same building as WeWork office space. Sounds great as long as it's affordable. I've often wanted to stay a few months in a new location to feel more immersed than a two week vacation, but not ready to sign a 3 month lease on a furnished apartment. Sounds like this would fill the gap between hotels and renting.
- mwwilson 8y agoIt'll be interesting to see where things end up in 15-30 years. One of the most attractive parts of 'digital nomadism' to me is that it doesn't require one to be a nomad. I could just as easily freelance from the small Kansas town I grew up in as from a van somewhere in SF. From the perspective of having children and wanting them to experience actual physical community I see the trend towards remote work and freelancing as a boon. Instead of having to live in suburbia and commute to work everyday there's actually a viable path to living in a small community where cost of living is low and getting to actually spend time with my family. My kids can experience the independence of riding their bikes to the playground, I can be a part of their education and model something other than disappearing for 10 hours at time M-F and being tired all weekend. Of course the trend could continue towards the majority moving as close to their regional hub as possible and spending their every waking moment glued to a screen, but I suspect that there will be at least a large minority of us who choose to embrace the possibilities that open up when one is not tied to a metropolis for work. Home ownership and physical community being two of those possibilities.
- nisten 8y agoSoftware will absorb new humans as just another object, and map them into some form of homelessness, because that's the most efficient use of us. Personally I'd feel happier if I grew up on a community surrounded by people that I knew and cared for, instead of being routed around like a tinder hookup, endlessly bidding for cheaper container storage. I think that's something worth sacrificing a little bit of algorithmic efficiency for.
- HumanDrivenDev 8y agoThe article seemed a bit confused and meandering to me. The side spiel about modern life requiring most of us to up sticks and put off starting a family is the more interesting part, but not really expanded upon.
- asfasgasg 8y ago"Stop liking what I don't like," in twenty inches? Listen, some people want a short commute. There's nothing bad about Google building housing near its campus. It's good for the environment, good for health, good for the city, good for employees. Hell, it's even good for family, which the author seems hung up on. You know what you're not doing while driving home from work for forty five minutes? I would accept an arbitrarily short commute to work. If there were reasonably priced dwellings in the building I work at, I would live there. More time to play with my kid, cook dinner, or whatever else. And then he goes on to complain about affordable urban housing. Well, is it sinister to live near work, or isn't it? I agree that WeLive's prices are very high for someone who intends to stay put. But . . . that's not what they're for? Should we get rid of hotels too?
- Bjorkbat 8y agoI would argue that at the least it's a little absurd that we're resorting to corporate housing and "work-dorms" for lack of a better term when we could just simply shift more work to small and mid-size cities. Get your short commute, live in an actual house. I mean, it's kind of silly to imagine a small cluster of Google employees in a metro of approximately 200,000 people, but at some point it has to sound less silly than some of the proposed ways of fitting more people into a metro with 3x-5x rent prices.
- AstralStorm 8y agoThere is but one risk which USA has seen in the past. When the company owns your living space, there is even stronger pressure on you to stay there, be productive and accept lower wages. When it also owns your food source, the threat is even greater. The result would be replacement of wages with "benefits" such as living. Technical indentured servitude also known as soft slavery. Technically you could move, except you cannot ever possibly afford to. Additional stress would be put on people not in this arrangement as they would potentially have to spend more money to get at the same level. (Albeit there could be less pressure in the housing market.) The next step in this slippery slope would be inheritance. Since company owns everything, your kids inherit little. Either that, or they inherit a position... Welcome to actual indentured servitude again. Company branded kids straight out of a few known dystopias. Mostly because moving is a special kind of hell, especially with kids. Communities cannot form either way. Some people like it, they're a minority though as far as I know.
- 6_45 8y agoI listened to an interview of Zillow CEO today. Housing prices are on fire, above the pre-recession peak of early 2000s, but it's not because of a bubble. It's because of a housing shortage. The high-mid and high end of the market has been getting lots of new construction but the low end doesn't because lack of demand (less buyers esp with post recession lending practices) and because of high land prices. Also, rent is very high now and this prevents people from saving up for a down payment on a house. Have you ever asked yourself why there isn't a wall Mart or Starbucks of housing? Why are all houses not owned and rented out by a small group of wealthy entities? Just like every other market, it should trend toward consolidation right? Perhaps it just hasnt been given enough time. Anyway, I think we will see these high prices continue for a long time and demand for cheaper housing, combined with new sat internet, driverless cars and other things, will grow and eventually spill over into a massive flood of cheap housing outside city hotspots. Wework is massively overvalued, is engaging in borderline fraudulent bonds with high interest rates. Nobody wants their creepy day care centers or to live in their foxconn dorms and I predict that a good many of their bonds will go into default.
- Animats 8y agoWhy are all houses not owned and rented out by a small group of wealthy entities? Just like every other market, it should trend toward consolidation right? It's happened. In many small and medium sized cities, there's one dominant landlord.[1] So far, nobody is big enough to do this to a major city. Blackstone may be getting close. "Blackstone is now 'the largest owner of real estate in the world'"[2]. [1] https://righttothecity.org/cause/rise-of-the-corporate-landlord/ https://righttothecity.org/cause/rise-of-the-corporate-landl... [2] http://www.businessinsider.com/blackstone-is-largest-owner-of-real-estate-2015-11 http://www.businessinsider.com/blackstone-is-largest-owner-o...
- ALee 8y agoThis recent study informs exactly what the Zillow CEO is saying: http://www.jchs.harvard.edu/state-nations-housing-2018 http://www.jchs.harvard.edu/state-nations-housing-2018
- rob-olmos 8y agoIt would be nice if US health insurance was a bit more roam-friendly as well. Becoming out-of-network with a $14k deductible just for moving to another state is a bit annoying. Last time I got new insurance outside of open enrollment (via a special exception for moving) it took a few months after moving to process & approve the exception. Having to transfer medical records is another aspect.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- zerostar07 8y agoHumans have enjoyed living next to their workplace (their fields) for millenia and enjoyed it. The industrial era is the uncomfortable abberation, not the other way around.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- stakhanov 8y ago+1 on that. And company housing is anything but a new idea either. During the post-WW2 reindustrialization of Europe, it was the norm when a big industrial company set up shop somewhere that they would build huge housing estates for their employees right on campus and even facilities like allotment gardens in rural areas, so people can have a garden at the weekend and stuff like that. And this is making a comeback. Munich, for example, is having such an overheated housing market that it's becoming extremely difficult for companies based here to take in new employees from outside, so they've starting getting into the business of providing company housing.
- jahewson 8y agoIndeed, some mill owners in 1850s Britain built (good) housing and sometimes entire villages for their workers.
- paganel 8y agoThe same happened in former Austro-Hungary. The bad thing was when said owners decided that they should impose their moral precepts on their workers: "it's bad having fun and drinking till late at night on Sundays because no-one will come to work sober on Mondays, so let's punish those workers who are seen as encouraging this behavior". It was also not fun for the workers/tenants being forced to buy all their food stuff from the owners' shops, who in fact had imposed a monopoly in feeding their workers. That's pretty close to servitude, if you ask me.
- EADGBE 8y agoThis was also common in Slave America, too.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWhose utopia is this, when people have to sever emotional links and leave where they grew up to find dependable work? Oh, how rich. As if this is new. More of that American ideal (aka delusion) that a 1950s style lifestyle is The Natural Order Of Things. It's not. It's very much an anomaly. It's a terrible article that very much throws the baby out with the bathwater. As someone who likes moving around and did so a lot as a military wife, the sneering tone of the article that frames anyone who moves a lot as some kind of victim who has been denied a real life really does not go over well with me. There are, no doubt, genuine criticisms to made of the current trend towards jobs with long hours and no benefits and the like. This has really nothing to do with the trend towards digital nomads. Further, some of what he criticizes likely falls under the heading of "Excess student loans are ruining the lives of modern Americans" rather than the heading of being a digital nomad per se. There is a real need for genuinely affordable housing. But if you are a single parent, working from home -- the way most of humanity basically did for thousands of years -- is a boon, not a problem. It allows you to take care of family and also make some money. I just have nothing good to say about this article. I'm also personally offended at the use of the term homeless in the title to basically mean something like rootless or without a real sense of belonging. It is a really inflammatory and misleading title.
- notahacker 8y agoIn this case it's a British 1930s ideal, and a very specific Guardian obsession with arguing every new middle class lifestyle they don't understand is the consequence of labour and housing market pressures and A Bad Thing For Everyone. Wealthy young digital workers aren't paying premium prices for shiny work/live accommodation in Bali because they're been deprived of opportunities for housing and employment in Slough, they're doing it because the lifestyle appeals to them and they're amongst the few wealthy enough and flexibly-employed enough to be free to do so.
- bootsz 8y ago> More of that American ideal (aka delusion) that a 1950s style lifestyle is The Natural Order Of Things. It's not. It's very much an anomaly. Yeah in the US it seems just about everything gets compared to the post-war years like it's some kind of baseline. Seems like a recipe for perpetual disappointment.
- sumanthvepa 8y agoThough not a nomad, (in that I have a solid home base I travel out of,) as a freelance consultant I'm usually away from home base for 20 or more days a month. My form of 'nomadism' isn't working in big well known cities: NY, London, Paris etc.. I mostly work out of nondescript client offices in smaller cities in South/South East Asia and Eastern Europe. Working out of a coffee shop is not usually an option. The biggest problem I have is getting healthy food and exercise. They just aren't good healthy places to eat in many developing countries. Wonder how digital nomads handle this issue.
- trevyn 8y agoBuy vegetables and walk a lot.
- systemtest 8y agoSoylent and an exercise bike.
- collyw 8y ago> They just aren't good healthy places to eat in many developing countries. This has been quite the opposite of my experience.
- bwang29 8y agoIf owning a home becomes the new anomaly and living/working on roam is the new norm, would fixed housing eventually be devalued for the main population?
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoCertainly, with an asterisk. That asterisk is that your thoughts are urban-centric. Right now there is a vast amount of very cheap land available in the US. So desperate are some areas for people and development, that you can even get free land if you promise to build (or park) a home on it. There are even multi acre lots given out by the government at places like Cuyahoga Valley National Park [1] for next to nothing. You can't get much cheaper than this. When people talk about the rise in housing prices, it's invariably speaking of not only the most populated, but also the most economically prosperous and desirable areas in the country. And in these places - no, housing and land prices will likely only continue to increase as demand is unlikely to waver anytime in the foreseeable future, yet supply is strictly limited - even when expanded. [1] - https://www.nationalgeographic.com/people-and-culture/food/the-plate/2015/07/13/uncle-sam-wants-you-to-live-and-farm-on-a-national-park/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/people-and-culture/food/t...
- jhare 8y agoDifferent strokes. I became sober months ago after years and years of heavy drinking. I don't do much else but sleep for a few hours at a time, program some hours, go back to sleep. My work is remote enough and meetings are sparse enough to get away with it and I maintain relative privacy still. Hopefully the complaint of the author is VALID and he'll be left complaining to no one but the support ticket system and blog someone else wrote, douchebag.
- sologoub 8y agoThis is an alphabet soup of fads and terms put in a political blender to make a barely coherent point. All seems to boil down to frustration with the job market trends. Main thesis seems to be “millions of people have to leave where they grew up to find even halfway dependable work;“ Ok, the entire premise of the “digital nomad” is that work can be done from anywhere. The exact opposite of what is being argued here - if the work can be done from anywhere, then you can compete for that work from the comfort of your familiar settings. Or if you so choose, from anywhere in the world. That’s digital nomadism, not herding people into ever smaller spaces to make things more efficient. A huge part of today’s digital work can be done from any well equipped home office or even a bench with a good internet connection and a power supply reserve. The fact that we MAKE remote work difficult is our own doing (me included) and will require a culture change that is well on its’ way.
- peteretep 8y ago> This is an alphabet soup of fads and terms put in a political blender to make a barely coherent point It's in the Opinion section in the Guardian; this shouldn't be a huge surprise. I hate how news sites -- and the Guardian are particularly guilty of this -- mix opinion and news in very similarly styled layouts. The Guardian seemed to have started this with "Comment is Free" back in the day. The Guardian is very authoritative for news, and often pretty worthless for columnists / opinion pieces. I appreciate the Economist having started 1843 Magazine, which appears to be a specific counter to that. It's promoted by their social media outlets, and yet it's clearly a separate brand.
- thraway180306 8y agoWow, citing The Economist as neutral news, that's something. Probably about you.
- peteretep 8y agoI'd be at least vaguely curious to know in which direction you think it's biased.
- Kiro 8y ago> it is surely no way to spend any sizable share of your adult life Why not? We are many people who don't want to start a family, ever.
- krsdcbl 8y agoI do see the concerns, and I guess it can paint a troublesome picture of an "always working" community. But let me ask you: has it been any different for many, many of the freelancers out there, without the help of WeWork and such? Blaming an affluence of commodities generally only found in well paid big corporate jobs, or short commutes for the danger of never really stopping to work as a freelancer is at best ignoring the work reality of many, if not most, as it is already now. The reality (even if its just the starting years) more often is: you get out of bed and over to your desk, and everything around you is work and distraction at the same time. Beeing able to jump into a place of likeminded people with a certain level of comfort & leisure and being able to afford infrastructure and ressources generally inaccessible to a one-human-show is invaluable, and working amongst peers will do A LOT to keep you from burning out in the first place. To stick to a schedule and stop working at the end of the day is something you'll have to learn no matter the environment!
- Myrmornis 8y agoThere’s a lot of criticism of the article in this thread. I’m surprised — I know several couples who have had trouble finding a place they call ”home” and deciding when and how to move towards starting a family, and the article is correct that certain aspects of modern work culture are relevant. I’m talking about university educated middle classes. The article is not very convincing in its clams to be addressing problems of anybody who’s not university educated middle class.
- Nasrudith 8y agoFrom what I have heard about economically depressed areas that may also be because moving in itself is a small luxury. There is a need for a lack of obligations like caring for ailing family and either enough capital for a move which won't cause you to wind up homeless or ability to work a job where local labor is scarce or decommoditized enough to justify covering moving expenses in importing workers and evaluating nonlocal candidates. This isn't just skill - it also can include things like willingness to work in uprootive work like the military, long haul trucking, or offshore oil rigs.
- jfz 8y agoJust don't try to build corporate housing in Brazil... https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/fordlandia/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/fordlandia/
- jdhn 8y agoOr if you do, resist the urge to impose your Puritan values on your employees while making an attempt to understand the local culture/environment.
- LukasRos 8y agoUnfortunately, the author mixes the sometimes related but otherwise distinct concepts of company housing, remote work, flexible work, freelancing, expats/working migrants, and digital nomadism. Therefore it doesn't really say much of substance about any of them.
- wkoszek 8y agoPersonally I think it's a terrible idea to work at Google, live at Google, have your Google-only relationships, have your Google kids to talk to only Google kids, and stay on the campus all the time. It's a little awkward to know I walk around the SV streets and there are people who think otherwise.