11 ms·
Lead: America's Real Criminal Element (2013)
- kolpa 8y ago(2016)
- dang 8y agoThe article is from 2013: https://web.archive.org/web/20130112132922/http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2013/01/lead-crime-link-gasoline https://web.archive.org/web/20130112132922/http://www.mother.... Not sure why they're playing games with its date like that.
- jdavis703 8y agoThis is a really ancedotal story with sample size N=1 so YMMV. I lived in a poorly maintained building constructed in the 1920s. I'm sure there was old lead paint that was just painted over. Also a couple of times per month the pipes would spew out brown water. During that time I was dealing with a lot of anger outbursts and anxiety attacks. Since I've moved (same city, same job, slightly higher rent), these things really haven't been a problem. Again it's hard to know what the exact reason is, but I do wonder if I was experiencing some version of heavy metal poisoning.
- vidanay 8y agoI don't think heavy metal poisoning goes away with a simple change of environment. You were probably just pissed off that you lived in a shitty apartment building.
- maxxxxx 8y agoAs far as I know it slowly goes down so the story may make sense.
- wallace_f 8y ago>"The most recent evidence from epidemiological and toxicological studies suggests that low levels of exposure can, over time, damage the heart, kidneys, and brain." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1797860/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1797860/
- maxxxxx 8y agoThe question is what happens when the exposure stops. Do things get better?
- kbos87 8y agoFrom what I’ve seen and heard the answer with lead is an unequivocal no - once lead exposure has occurred, the damage is done. It’s compounding and irreversible.
- wallace_f 8y agoTake a look at the link, it's relevant to your question. As mentioned there, your body stores lead in your bones, which leeches into your blood stream. Because there does not appear to be a minimum safe threshold of exposure, even small exposure can, over time, lead to problems as the lead is circulated through your body, as mentioned in the quote. Sorry it doesn't appear clear when taken out of context.
- R_haterade 8y agoOne of the things that makes lead (and all heavy metals) so dangerous is the body lacks a mechanism to effectively clear it. So if the only factor in aggression is the amount of lead in the body, then we would have to assume it takes time for the symptoms to subside as well.
- danburbridge 8y agotypically the problem with heavy metal poisoning (lead, arsenic, etc) is that the body has difficulty getting rid of it, so it accumulates. This can also be seen in big fish such as Tuna, which eat lots of small fish (which have consumed various heavy metals) and live for many years.
- sbov 8y agoAFAIK painted over old lead paint isn't a problem. If you sand it it is. For most of these old toxic things, where plausible, the best option is to just seal it and leave it alone.
- kbos87 8y agoYup. Plenty of houses have asbestos siding and lead paint - neither of which poses a significant danger to the average adult as long as it isn’t disturbed. (Asbestos siding is durable, fireproof, and holds paint well too!)
- vidanay 8y ago"Holds paint well" is completely wrong.....that shit soaks up about a gallon per 100 square ft! /s
- Theodores 8y agoI wish there were more anecdotes in the article. It would be good to know that lead was what gave some known rogues their head start in life. I am sure there are many other factors but if a Charles Manson or other notorious rogue had spent their formative years living under an interstate highway then that would be good to know. The guy who invented lead-in-petrol also invented CFCs. He also died quite horribly from some contraption he made to hoist himself out of bed. The downside to not having lead in petrol is that the raw material for the disturbing U.S. movies of the 70's has gone away, so if 'Dirty Harry' was made today then the rogues in it would not be as plausible.
- jcranmer 8y agoThe fact that it went away when you left the environment tends to strongly suggest that it wasn't heavy metal poisoning, which tends to have permanent effects.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI actually used to spend a lot of time on a chelation and alternative medicine forum. Chelation is the way heavy metals are drawn from the tissues when you have metal poisoning. You don't magically get better if you end up with heavy metal poisoning. Without treatment, it tends to remain in your tissues permanently. (However, life is chemistry and there are some foods that can promote the removal of metals, such as cilantro which is commonly found in Mexican fare.) My guess would be the old building had mold or fungus issues. If you are otherwise in good health and don't wind up with a bona-fide fungal infection, moving out of such a situation would go a long ways towards resolving your issues. http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1996-09-21/news/9609210090_1_fungus-books-hallucinogenic http://articles.chicagotribune.com/1996-09-21/news/960921009... https://www.neatorama.com/2012/10/15/Salem-Witch-Trials-The-Fungus-Theory/ https://www.neatorama.com/2012/10/15/Salem-Witch-Trials-The-...
- paulie_a 8y agoLead paint really isn't a big deal if it wasn't chipping away. And you weren't eating it. Lead paint isn't ideal but if just existed and was maintained in an older home you had little risk.
- ghaff 8y ago>I'm sure there was old lead paint that was just painted over. You've pretty much described every old house in the US.
- maxxxxx 8y agoIt's really hard to understand that the country is not setting up a nationwide program to get rid of lead paint and fixing the water supply. The payoff would be enormous.
- Analemma_ 8y agoEnormous, but diffuse. Governments, and especially democracies, and especially especially the United States have consistently failed miserably at tackling problems with diffuse benefits bit highly visible costs, even when the costs are much lower.
- wwweston 8y agoThe theory is too narrow here -- not only does this apply to governments, it applies to businesses. Or technical debt and sufficiently large software projects. Or individuals and lifestyle choices. Our reward structures aren't always lined up with optimal responses to current conditions.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wool_gather 8y agoGood point. And people with similar mindsets/POVs tend to be at the top of such large organizations. I think there's just a certain way of being in the world that makes some people inclined to a) want to be in charge, and b) downplay these kinds of diffuse, semi-intangibly-expensive problems. We need better ways of explaining problems to them.
- cameldrv 8y agoThere has been a tremendous amount of work and money and success on this. https://www.edf.org/health/interactive-chart-forty-years-sound-policy https://www.edf.org/health/interactive-chart-forty-years-sou...
- joncrane 8y ago
- nickpeterson 8y agoWell, seems lead in drinking water goes hand and hand with empires falling.
- merpnderp 8y agoSince evidence of lead water piping goes back at least to 200BCE, it looks more like lead water goes hand and hand with empires growing. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-4843640/Romans-using-poisonous-lead-pipes-200-years-earlier.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-4843640/Roman...
- R_haterade 8y agoGood times create weak men etc. etc.
- megaman22 8y agoIt's pretty nuts some of the toxic chemicals the Romans used. I seem to recall arsenic as a major component of beauty products, and lead compounds as artificial sweeteners.
- Gibbon1 8y agoThey used to use arsenic in wallpaper. If it got damp enough some types of mold would convert inorganic arsenic into volatile organic arsenic compounds and poison people. Just remembered an ex gf worked in a museum. She said they used to dust taxidermist specimens with arsenic powder to prevent pests and decay. So a lot of display items are problematic. Toxic, irreplaceable, and you can't just throw them out either.
- jonhendry18 8y agoThere's a 19th century book of poisonous wallpapers. Not many copies exist and they have to be stored carefully.
- 8y ago
- yasp 8y agoThought this was an interesting theory when initially proposed. How has it held up since then?
- jseliger 8y agoAn interesting question; here is one negative datum: https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/06/no-lead-homicide-connection-eastern-europe.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/06/no... I find it interesting that lead use also seems to follow the trajectory of drug usage / permissiveness in the '70s: https://jakeseliger.com/2018/06/15/grass-roots-the-rise-and-fall-and-rise-of-marijuana-in-america-emily-dufton https://jakeseliger.com/2018/06/15/grass-roots-the-rise-and-...
- iguy 8y agoDoes anyone know any good studies looking at this in different countries? For example, lots of communist countries had ridiculous levels of lead pollution. Does this show up in their crime & IQ stats, as articles like this suggest it should? They also (sometimes) took great effort to mix up the population, putting all social classes in the same building... which would help avoid one complaint here, that obviously people who could afford to do so chose not to live in the most polluted bits of American cities.
- lainga 8y agoBecause the spike in alcoholism after the Soviet Union collapsed might drown out lead-based signals in crime rates, you might try any of the former DDR, Czechia or Poland, especially in the "Black Triangle" around As which was heavily industralised.
- mozumder 8y agoI think this would be a good variable to analyze. A lot of third-world countries didn't have a large automobile infrastructure, and so they had lower lead levels, leading to smarter people with less crime. This could be the source of "smart Asian" stereotype. But, I don't know if atmospheric lead pollution is uniform globally or localized.
- Nasrudith 8y agoIt is very localized - areas by old highways have issues with higher lead concentration in soil. Which seems intuitive but CFCs are heavier than air yet can still wind up high enough to cause ozone layer issues via air currents
- Herodotus38 8y agoAnother source of lead pollution that I wasn't aware about until buying a house on former orchard land is that lead arsenate was used as an insecticide against the coddling moth for several decades. It is a large issue in Eastern Washington State where a lot of former orchard land has become schools, housing and parks.
- mrfusion 8y agoI’ve been trying tonfigure our if fruit and vegetables grown in lead polluted soil pick up lead or not. I haven’t been able to track down a good answer
- DoreenMichele 8y agohttps://www.soils.org/discover-soils/story/lead-contamination-garden-soils/ https://www.soils.org/discover-soils/story/lead-contaminatio...
- yungchin 8y ago> Enriching the soil with compost also helps increase fertility. As a result, the overall size of vegetables increases, diluting the amount of lead they contain. The effects of using compost can be striking. In the study, addition of compost cut the available concentration of lead by as much as one-half. This is a statement that's technically true, and at the same time practically wrong. If the context is that I'm going to be eating tomatoes from my garden, what's likely to happen is that if my yield doubles, my consumption doubles (unless I have a massive garden and can't eat everything I grow). So now I'm eating the same amount of lead, just in a bigger package!
- DoreenMichele 8y agoIt's actually quite common for people to have a high enough yield from their garden to be unable to consume it all themselves. They end up canning some of it, giving it away to friends and neighbors and even posting questions to forums asking for creative ways to dispose of the remaining surplus without just trashing it. Store bought food isn't actually "perfect." I limit my rice consumption in part because it contains arsenic.[1] Antibiotic resistant infections are a serious and growing threat. The CDC indicates that one in five such infections are "caused by germs from food and animals." This is from info they put out about antibiotic resistant infections and food safety. [2] There are lots and lots of articles out there about unsafe cookware. The ones that pop to the top are mostly from disreputable sources. I've tried to find one that doesn't sound too nutty. [3] I began avoiding aluminum cookware long before it was some kind of hot trend. I strongly favor glass bakeware and enamel cookware. It gets dismissed as nutty on forums like HN to talk about things like the dangers of teflon cookware, but if you are really seriously concerned about food safety (and metal poisoning in specific), you need to stop and think about the chemical impact on your food of the kind of cookware you use. We actively recommend that people cook with iron pots and pans to treat anemia.[4] So it's not like we are unaware that the materials your cookware are made of can imbue your food with metals. But we typically downplay the seriousness of using things like aluminum cookware and anyone who adheres too strictly to such a guideline or too loudly advocates such a guideline is dismissed as a nutter. I have a genetic disorder, a form of Cystic Fibrosis. I exchanged emails with a PhD biologist met through HN who kindly answered some of my questions. My belief is that my genetic disorder predisposes me to retain metals at a higher rate than normal. This guy said that given the function of the CFTR (the defective cell channel responsible for CF symptoms), that did not sound like crazy talk to him. So I am pretty careful about exposure to metals in food and other details of food chemistry while also trying to not just make myself absolutely nuts. My "professional opinion" -- as a former homemaker and person who never completed my BS in Environmental Resource Management :) -- is that if you have contaminated soil in your yard and you want to garden, then you should pursue a "square foot" gardening style approach and create fresh elevated beds from imported clean soils and compost for whatever small plants you desire to grow. A desire to grow fruit trees is not conducive to that approach and most homeowners will not have the means to remove all contaminated soils on their property and replace them for purposes of planting trees. At that point, you can try to remediate the soil to some degree or give up on having food producing trees or have soil testing and make a judgement call. There are no 100% safe foods on the planet. Over the years I've read a lot of things about what is in our food that really turned my stomach and made me lose my appetite. Then I developed some best practices to try to limit the damage, and I put my blinders on and I try to not think about those details too much while actually eating. [1] https://www.consumerreports.org/cro/magazine/2015/01/how-much-arsenic-is-in-your-rice/index.htm https://www.consumerreports.org/cro/magazine/2015/01/how-muc... [2] https://www.cdc.gov/foodsafety/challenges/from-farm-to-table.html https://www.cdc.gov/foodsafety/challenges/from-farm-to-table... https://www.cdc.gov/features/antibiotic-resistance-food/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/features/antibiotic-resistance-food/inde... https://www.cdc.gov/foodsafety/challenges/antibiotic-resistance.html https://www.cdc.gov/foodsafety/challenges/antibiotic-resista... [3] http://aspenintegrativemedicine.com/how-safe-is-your-cookware/ http://aspenintegrativemedicine.com/how-safe-is-your-cookwar... [4] https://universityhealthnews.com/daily/energy/use-cast-iron-cookware-as-an-iron-deficiency-treatment/ https://universityhealthnews.com/daily/energy/use-cast-iron-...
- axaxs 8y agoI feel this is just a case of correlation != causation. I remember once someone, perhaps here, posted something that would randomly link things together based on loose trends, oftentime to ridiculous results. There are a -lot- of societal changes in those years. If lead were the sole culprit, crime would have dropped off a cliff.
- refurb 8y agoAgreed. Not sure why this is the favorite pet theory on HN. It’s interesting, but very little data to actually support the connection.
- DFHippie 8y agoIt's popular largely because of the convincing data. Read the article, or any of the many other articles by Kevin Drum on the subject.
- refurb 8y agoIt's largely popular because because people gravitate towards simply explanations. It makes them feel good. Is there directional data to suggest a connection? Sure. But there have been plenty of theories like this that have turned out to be complete bunk.
- workinthehead 8y agoCould be worse. One of Reddit's favorite pet theories is that one's skull shape reliably indicates their "race".
- Elrac 8y agoDid you read the article?
- axaxs 8y agoYou can disagree with me, downvote me, and tell me why i'm wrong, but please don't make comments like this. It's rude and against guidelines. Please don't insinuate that someone hasn't read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that."
- dang 8y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5006368 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5006368.
- perpetualcrayon 8y agoFor all of those who are so amazed at the current state of technology in the world, it's articles like these that help bring us back to Earth. It was less than 100 years ago that we thought it was a good idea to (1) put lead in paint, (2) put asbestos in building materials, (3) put x-ray machines in shoe stores so people could casually look at their feet (learned this from a relative). We are only a few generations away from some literal dark age shit.
- scarecrowbob 8y agoWell, the fun thing is to look at what we do know and wonder what horrible stuff people will see that should have been more obvious to us in the present day.
- deelowe 8y agoI think coal burning power plants are the next big one. There's been some studies that have come out lately which link coal plants to tons of modern ailments.
- jaggederest 8y agoDiesel engines also. Black carbon smoke in all its forms is toxic to life, in general.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoModern Diesel engines don’t smoke. And black Diesel is mostly just muck and not pollution in the way you think it is, clear diesel exhaust has the NOX in it. Sorry, but it seems you don’t actually know anything about diesels.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoIf we have data, let's go with the data. If all we have is opinions, let's go with mine. Diesel exhaust is a Group 1 carcinogen, which causes lung cancer and has a positive association with bladder cancer.[2][3][4][5][6] It contains several substances that are also listed individually as human carcinogens by the IARC. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_exhaust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_exhaust
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSimilar sort of idea wrt "A sound mind in a sound body" being the best antidote to crime: Vitamins for convicts could save taxpayers' money https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16140867 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16140867
- joe_the_user 8y agoBlaming lead for the increase in crime certainly has an appeal. Any claim like that is going to be controversial - pinning causes and effect this closely is a bit like large-scale anecdotal evidence - you're never going to repeat the multitude of causes and effects to went into the twenty years from 1980 to 2000. A different approach I find compelling involves those who look at different time scales. Especially, violent crime has been declining since colonial times in the US and around the globe - with specific exceptions. While the overall downward trend needs explanation, any moment where crime is declining is normal and the moments of upturn seem to be what needs explanation. And the explanation here is often the aftermath of war, soldiers who've learned to kill coming home. Of course this isn't to claim lead pollution is in any way acceptable but whether it lead to violent crime is a fuzzy question. http://blogs.berkeley.edu/2010/06/16/a-crime-puzzle-violent-crime-declines-in-america/ http://blogs.berkeley.edu/2010/06/16/a-crime-puzzle-violent-...
- mc32 8y ago>And the explanation here is often the aftermath of war, soldiers who've learned to kill coming home. I don't think the stats bear that out. Veterans may suffer PTSD and other ailments, but I don't think they contribute disproportionally to US crime statistics. Brazil hasn't been at war recently, but they have high crime rate.
- girvo 8y ago> Brazil hasn't been at war recently I wonder if drug trafficking and the global drug war counts? I mean it's in some ways even more violent, but I guess then I'm mixing up cause and effect... interesting to think about.
- kimdotcom 8y agoViolence begets violence?
- watwut 8y agoThey do commit more crimes then average population. And some of that is due to untreated PTSD and due to too little help in adjusting to civilian life.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoThe aqueducts feeding water to Ancient Rome were lined with lead, which apparently had a poisoning effect. Was the famous Roman Mob affected by this same thing?
- NegativeLatency 8y agoThe water was pretty hard (lots of dissolved minerals) and it formed a protective non reactive layer over the lead. The same thing happened in Flynt, but the city cheaped out on the pH control chemicals, the protective layer was dissolved, and eventually the pipes with lead in them started leaching.
- Gibbon1 8y agoThree things I've read. Romans complained in writings about the use of lead acetate in wine. They also used lead cook pots to reduce grape juice to Defrutum. And the Romans used to smelt lead in Italy and banned the practice eventually. I've never seen a description of a Roman lead smelting operation but I can imagine. On the other hand I haven't seen anyone trying look for lead poisoning in Roman era bones. Just looked found this. http://www.poweredbyosteons.org/2012/01/lead-poisoning-in-rome-skeletal.html http://www.poweredbyosteons.org/2012/01/lead-poisoning-in-ro...
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoGreat link (I resubmitted just now for wider audience).
- pkaye 8y agoWas lead used in other countries around the world? Did they see a similar drop in crime when it was banned?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- OscarCunningham 8y agoIraq stopped using leaded petrol in 2011. The lead/crime hypothesis postulates a 22 year time-lag. So if Iraq becomes a lot more peaceful in 2033 you'll know what's up. Incidentally, the list of countries where leaded petrol is still used, or was banned most recently, is basically a list of countries where bad things happen: "Algeria, Iraq, Yemen, Myanmar, North Korea, and Afghanistan". But the causality probably goes the other way; leaded petrol is cheaper.
- tonyg 8y agoThe author of this piece just recently published an update, also in Mother Jones: "An Updated Lead-Crime Roundup for 2018", Kevin Drum, Mother Jones, 1 Feb 2018. https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2018/02/an-updated-lead-crime-roundup-for-2018/ https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2018/02/an-updated-le...
- sokoloff 8y agoFrom that article: "Unfortunately, the number of murders is relatively small compared to the universe of violent crime, which makes it statistically challenging to analyze." I don't find that especially unfortunate.
- aaron695 8y agoIf this was true why are we still repetitively linking back to this article from 5 years ago. https://hn.algolia.com/?query=%09Lead:%20America%27s%20Real%20Criminal%20Element&sort=byPopularity&prefix&page=0&dateRange=all&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?query=%09Lead:%20America%27s%20Real%...
- c4mden 8y agoRelated article from a few years back that I've found myself referencing in many discussions since: https://www.damninteresting.com/the-ethyl-poisoned-earth/ https://www.damninteresting.com/the-ethyl-poisoned-earth/