6 ms·
While it's not exactly the same thing but Facebook needs to tighten up their rules. I got in a squabble with someone who wanted my FB identity. Even though I
by rmason 8y ago
While it's not exactly the same thing but Facebook needs to tighten up their rules. I got in a squabble with someone who wanted my FB identity.
Even though I didn't follow him he filled out a form online and had me declared deceased. It took me close to a week, with the intervention of a friend who worked at Facebook, to get my account back.
How can someone who you don't even follow back be allowed to do something like this to someone? I had to prove that I was alive, complete with photos of me with my drivers license.
But why is a complete stranger without any proof whatsoever able to have me declared dead? Facebook needs to rethink these rules. Seems to me in this case the guys widow should be the one who has final say over his account.
- alex_duf 8y agoI can see why the opposite might be valid, if you recently lost someone the last thing you want is argue with Facebook that yes, that loved one is indeed dead. Probably needs some better rules but that part needs to be as painless as possible
- rmason 8y agoI can offer Facebook two choices to verify death if a third party alleges it. Either provide the death certificate or the name of the funeral home. If Facebook was smart they'd make it super simple for the funeral directors to provide this information directly to them. I lost my dad late last year and had to answer a number of questions for the funeral director. All the funeral director would have to do is ask if the deceased had any social media accounts and do you want me to contact them on your behalf?
- mrsteveman1 8y ago> All the funeral director would have to do is ask if the deceased had any social media accounts and do you want me to contact them on your behalf? This would make a great plot for a novel, a disgruntled funeral director starts "killing" people digitally by marking various accounts permanently deactivated after death. And thanks to advances in genetic engineering, even showing up in person isn't enough to prove they're who they claim to be anymore, so they can't drive, work, buy anything, or communicate with anyone.
- girvo 8y agoI dig this, and want to have a crack at a short story for it. Do you mind?
- DocTomoe 8y agoFor that case, though, there is a very valid way to verify the status of the deceased: The death certificate.
- wrs 8y agoIndeed, at least in the US, it’s expected that you’ll need several copies of the death certificate to handle bank accounts, etc. I doesn’t seem like a burdensome requirement to ask for one.
- bradleyankrom 8y agoWhy not err on the side of caution and leave the profile alone until someone, with adequate documentation and at a time of their choosing, contacts FB about converting or deleting the profile? I don't think leaving it up does any harm.
- notahacker 8y agoI had a friend die in sufficiently unfortunate circumstances to attract media attention. It was definitely a good thing that Facebook deactivated his account very quickly upon request (I doubt the person who asked for it to be deactivated had access to the death certificate at the time) before journalists used it as a source of photographs and people to ask for quotes.
- mpclark 8y agoYears ago I took it upon myself to cancel a record of the month club membership belonging to a work colleague who died suddenly. They would not do a thing without a copy of the death certificate, so I had to tell them that all I could do then was recommend they keep sending the records and they'd have to eventually try suing him for payment.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoLastPass seems to have a decent system (thankfully I haven't needed to test it yet): 1) I set an "emergency heir" contact 2) They can request access at any time 3) I'm sent an email notifying me of the request 4) If I don't deny the request in X amount of time (custom, I think), they are granted complete access to my account Granted there's a potential for abuse; but that's somewhat mitigated by only allowing 1-2 people to make the request and if someone already has access to my email they can cause all sorts of other trouble without having me declared digitally dead. It shouldn't be hard for Facebook to implement something similar.
- jacquesm 8y agoThat's exploitable. Hack the heirs email, wait until you are on a holiday, hit them with a request for access. You won't respond in time because you're climbing Mount Everest or diving in the Marianas Trench (the heir might really be a heir in either of those scenarios) and then access will be granted.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoAll systems are exploitable given enough time and effort. At that point they may as well just"hack" the actual account owners email. In cases like that you'd set set the time window to be longer than you expect to be off the grid. Granted it is a slightly larger attack surface but it relies on 1) knowing the heir (wife, parent, child, friend) 2) gaining access to their email 3) Relying on the original owner having an inadequate time window 4) the owner going somewhere they are completely cut off from the world. It could happen, but that's a vanishingly small opportunity.
- wepple 8y agoYou’re going up Everest? Cool, change X to 40 days.
- xirdstl 8y agoNo, you'd have to hack the heir's LastPass account. Also, as others have mentioned (including the parent), the length of time is customizable as well.
- megy 8y agoWhy? Why is the priority to shut down an account? That should not be what is important.
- Waterluvian 8y agoDeclaring you deceased, even to a corporation, sounds like a serious crime.
- acchow 8y agoYou can also go to usps.com and declare someone has moved and have all their mail sent to somewhere else (probably don't pick your own address if you don't want to get caught).
- pmyteh 8y agoI don't know about the USPS's implementation, but the UK's Royal Mail not only collects ID for this service, but sends an unredirectable letter to your old address saying 'we're starting a redirect, contact us if this is odd'. So it is possible to do sanely. Like Facebook, I suppose - require a scanned death certificate?
- nfRfqX5n 8y agoUSPS sends the same letter and requires you to answer several questions before doing it
- pzxc 8y agoNo they don't. My roommate moved out a few months ago, I watched him fill out the mail forwarding form (with his name and my/our address). Not only did no confirmation letter show up in my mailbox -- in fact I stopped getting my own mail for several days and when I confronted the USPS worker, he said, "Oh, I thought your apartment was vacant now." I got pretty mad and he just shrugged, not even an apology. I had to get my car's title reissued from the DMV (I had just bought it off my roommate as he was leaving), and also had a paycheck disappear (was working 1099 remotely and paid monthly via check) because both things were coming in the mail that week and disappeared never to be seen again. (Luckily the guy I was subcontracting from paid for his own stop payment and reissued the check)
- Izkata 8y agoYeah, when I moved a few years ago I also got no confirmation. So after the move, I sent a letter to my old address, with no return address, to see if it got redirected. (Although my letter did, I'm pretty sure my first Ventra card was lost in the mail anyway. With the insanity of the switch it got delayed a couple months, and ended up getting sent out right about when I moved)
- quadrangle 8y ago> widow To be picky, I recall the article saying "partner" in that they were not legally married… not that it takes anything away from your points otherwise.
- reaperducer 8y agoI've noticed in the last few years that many Europeans use the word "partner" even if they're married. It seems to be part of the Euro version of being over politically correct.
- driverdan 8y agoHow is it "over politically correct" to use the word partner?
- Symbiote 8y agos/politically correct/respectful/ usually works well, and shows that people using the term intend disrespect. But in this case, I think we are just maintaining privacy. You don't need to know whether I'm married or not, or the gender of the person.
- jexah 8y agoI use the term "partner" because I'm in a civil partnership. Same legalities as being married but without the terminology and ceremony, not to be politically correct, respectful, or to maintain privacy. So it depends on where you're from, partner could be the legally correct term as opposed to just meaning "significant other"
- sofaofthedamned 8y agoNot politically correct at all. I'm marrying my partner next month, she'll still be my partner. The 'wife' bit will be for formal conversations. Much as my son is actually my son despite him being from another father, i'd rather not dick around with clarifications when it's no concern of anybody else what our legal status is when compared to our actual relationship.
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoThe easy way to fix this is to contact Facebook and declare Mark Zuckerberg deceased, no?
- donatj 8y agoAnd yet my friend who actually died, and whom I've sent them multiple obituaries profile is still up like usual some 5 years later.