4 ms·
Medical analogies for financial markets are pretty tenuous, but I find myself in agreement. A big issue from my perspective is that everyone is ringing their h
by dasil003 16y ago
Medical analogies for financial markets are pretty tenuous, but I find myself in agreement. A big issue from my perspective is that everyone is ringing their hands about home values and trying to prop up the deflating bubble. As someone with aspirations to own a home, this is infuriating. I can't afford a home, and neither could all the people who bought them. They need to let the prices fall to where people can actually afford them instead of trying to save the speculative value which we already know was based on hot air.
- walkon 16y agoThat was (and is) the ironic thing about all the government sponsored home ownership programs and legislation. They pumped up demand at an unreasonable rate, causing ever increasing prices, which made it harder to afford a house, which prompted further government stimulation...an endless loop, at least until the fiat charade ends.
- anigbrowl 16y agoSo why didn't the banks try to throttle the supply? It's funny, I don't recall any CEOs complaining about the economy being driven off a cliff in the runup to the bust. On the contrary, I was astonished at their readiness to give money away. Don't you recall the endless stream of refinancing commercials on TV? shows like 'flip that house'? The way everyone and their dog suddenly seemed eager to have a realtor's license? The guy at my local pizza shop had his realtor business cards on the counter next to the delivery menus. Edit: I see the truth is uncomfortable for some people. But the fact is that government promotion of home ownership is one thing, and instant approval of jumbo loans with 0% down are quite another. I got burned in a property boom when I was about 20 and this time I decided to stay out of the market.
- matwood 16y agoThe second option, and the one the gov. appears to be attempting, is to keep home prices steady and eventually let inflation catch up. This stinks for people who want to buy because they have to wait, but looks good for the gov. in charge. I'm with you and think they should just let prices fall. I can't find the video right now, but at one point President Bush was asked why he wasn't doing anything to prop up home prices. He responded that it's giving people who were priced out the opportunity to buy so he didn't see the need to do anything. His statement was early on in the recession and eventually he was pressed to do something though.
- anigbrowl 16y agoThe government hasn't been propping up prices, and the homebuyer's tax credit expired last April. If you talk to people in the real estate biz (I too have been looking for a house), you'll find that banks have about twice as many properties sitting empty as they do out in the market, and they are trickling them out because if they put them all on the market at once prices would crater (which would incidentally trigger another wave of repossessions). According to the banks, this is the tgovernment's fault, because the government is not throwing any money at them to invest in the future value of homes: http://www.housingwire.com/2010/09/27/bofa-analysts-call-for-ppip-2-0-to-reduce-shadow-inventory http://www.housingwire.com/2010/09/27/bofa-analysts-call-for... If it's the government propping up house prices, kidly explain why prices are stable when there are ~300,000 homes in various stages of foreclosure: http://www.realtytrac.com/content/press-releases/foreclosure-activity-increases-4-percent-in-august-6041 http://www.realtytrac.com/content/press-releases/foreclosure... Seriously, what information are you basing these conclusions on?
- matwood 16y agoIf you talk to people in the real estate biz (I too have been looking for a house), you'll find that banks have about twice as many properties sitting empty as they do out in the market, and they are trickling them out because if they put them all on the market at once prices would crater (which would incidentally trigger another wave of repossessions). That right there should tell you that prices are still artificially high. In this case banks are controlling the market to hold them up. By the way, putting them all on the market would not necessarily lead to another wave of foreclosures. If it's the government propping up house prices, kidly explain why prices are stable when there are ~300,000 homes in various stages of foreclosure: Foreclosures are primarily driven by the owners ability to make their mortgage payment. Current house prices have little to do with that ability. A lower price could prevent the owner from being able to sell, but that assumes there would have been buyers at the higher price. Seriously, what information are you basing these conclusions on? Prices have come down, but the government has done it's best to hold interest rates artificially low so that people could refi and possibly get out of the idiotic loans they took on. These low rates have also helped those with money buy houses at the still over priced prices thus propping them up. There are also government sponsored loan modifications that help to keep people in homes that they can't afford. House prices are 'sticky' on the way down by nature, but the government has helped make them stickier through all the help they have been giving. Historically house prices have been set by the average income of a given area (and in general prices raised along with inflation like salaries)[1]. This is because people buy a house based on the monthly payment that they can afford. Low interest rates lead to higher priced homes and and vice versa (as an aside the best time to buy a house would be when irates are sky high and likely to fall because the absolute price of the house would have to be lower for anyone to afford it), but what stays roughly the same is the payment. What happened during the bubble is that money was so cheap that house prices ran way out in front of most peoples ability to afford a house without taking on a crazy loan. Even in areas where prices have fallen, if you compare prices to average income you'll see that many houses are still way beyond the average persons ability to afford them. In addition to the supply situation you mentioned, if you also add in that many people have been permanently put out of the market with banks now requiring down payments, better credit scores, and conventional loans the demand side of the equation has also fallen (and may never return to those levels). [1] Like most rules there are exceptions, in particular location. An area where many rich people buy second homes for vacation purposes may not reflect house price as a function of average salary for the area. Common sense will tell you if you're in one of those neighborhoods versus one where the people living there work nearby.