3 ms·
You just named 0.1% of the revenue of the tech industry. Closed: Google search. Windows. Office. Facebook. Cisco. Intel. Amazon AWS. Amazon retail. Most Adobe
by adventured 8y ago
You just named 0.1% of the revenue of the tech industry.
Closed:
Google search. Windows. Office. Facebook. Cisco. Intel. Amazon AWS. Amazon retail. Most Adobe products. Most Oracle products. iOS and most of what Apple does. Salesforce. Workday. Most of what nVidia does. Most of what Qualcomm, Texas Instruments, and pretty much every other chip maker does. Most of what Samsung does. The core software of: PayPal, Square, Stripe, Visa, Mastercard, et al. The list keeps going.
Most of what every major tech company does is closed off.
The tools are largely open source. The actual pieces of the companies that generate revenue are not. They love open source, when it isn't about their revenue generation.
Ask Facebook to show us all of their source code.
Nearly the entire tech industry is built on massive, closed products.
Google search by itself generates more operating income every year than every public open source company combined, by a factor of ten. Ask Google to show you all the source code to search.
- zeth___ 8y agoThat we no longer pay rents to the owners of the kernel is a huge victory for everyone. That you mistake market failures for successes is a rather sad reflection on the state of the soul of most technologists. The commodification of services that used to be cutting edge happens all the time, and if not for artificial patents would happen even faster.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TimJYoung 8y agoPay rents ? Do you think the Linux kernel just magically appears out of thin air ? If not, then someone is paying for the kernel development. If it isn't you, then that organization(s) or person(s) may have goals that are completely antithetical to your goals.
- zeth___ 8y agoOr I develop part of the kernel for something I need for my day job, send it up stream to make my life easier the next time I to use it and someone accepts it for the same reason. You then need someone to pay what is essentially an administrator to keep track of the changes. The reason why a company would do that is because of the name recognition advantage they get from this. "Oh you need someone to tune your Linux performance for your super computer cluster, we have the guy who it's named after on staff."
- TimJYoung 8y agoYes, that does indeed happen, and is an example of where you're paying with your time. My point is that if you're not paying with your time, and most people are not, then someone else is paying for it. The rent doesn't go away, it's just getting covered by someone else.
- slrz 8y agoIt's paid for by all the entities paying Linux developer's salaries as well as everyone else that contributes with their free time. Those companies probably build that cost into the price they take for their products, just as they would do with licensing costs for proprietary software. But it's not a wash. The difference is that with Linux all those contributors not only get a usage license for an OS but they also get all the control over it. You're a startup with some new kind of device or service? Good luck getting $PROPRIETARY_SOFTWARE ported to it if you're not HP/Dell/etc. and can guarantee sales in the millions. Heck, even HP didn't manage to convince Oracle and Microsoft to continue their IA64 support, despite major dollars being involved. Where I work, one of two reasons for saying "we can't do that" is when hitting the limitations of nature (obviously). The only other one is when proprietary software is involved, commonly encountered with e.g. networking gear or server/BMC firmware. While we don't get to not obey the laws of nature, the other one just sucks. It should be us doing the tradeoff between the benefits of doing something and the amount of work required to make it happen. It shouldn't be up to some 3rd-party vendor which is unlikely to consider us important enough to quickly implement a feature we want or heck, even fix a bug without having to wait $LONGTIME. With free software, that's exactly how it is. If you want control over your own fortune, you don't get that with proprietary software.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoIt would be a lot more than 0.1% if infrastructure software was closed source. Imagine if you had to pay Oracle $100k per server for your database.