3 ms·
Hypothesis 0 - all adult swans have largely white plummage. Expectation - all observed swans "are white". Observation - some swans "are black". >"Not
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
Hypothesis 0 - all adult swans have largely white plummage.
Expectation - all observed swans "are white".
Observation - some swans "are black".
>"Nothing is falsified by the failure of an experiment to observe the expected." //
The experiment failed to observe the expected. The hypothesis was falsified.
Hypothesis 1 - all swans are white or black.
---
Even with something like "we expected to find a Top quark at ~100GeV and found nothing" then the experiment has falsified that there is Top that would appear in such an experimental framework. We usual project that result beyond it's technical bounds, to say there is no top below that limit, is that what you're trying to get at?
If you mean experiments aren't perfect then I don't see how that truism is useful. There have been a couple of potentially massive results in recent years that have fallen to poor experimental process.
- sgt101 8y agoWhen a particle is observed at some energy the theories that predict that no such particle can exist are invalidated. It fault of the experiment to see something is just that, the experiment has failed. The causality of the failure is unknown, also if you do make the observation then the causality of the observation if unknown; Newton's observations and all the observations made by people who believed in a Newtonian universe were not unobserved when relating came along. I believe that the probabilistic approach to observation and observe to rule out approach in HEP now is a big error.