2 ms·
Such a map is far from useless - if you want to see any other area you don't have to travel there; you can "visit" all areas, you can duplicate any one area and
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
Such a map is far from useless - if you want to see any other area you don't have to travel there; you can "visit" all areas, you can duplicate any one area and experiment on how changes will affect it, etc.. It's only the bulk of the map that makes it impractical, we actually now have maps that are pretty close to that, we just found a way to make them less bulky.
I think the end goal of science actually is very close to the 1:1 scale map in Borges' story [1] - we want to be able to say in any situation "if I take this scenario and run it forward then what are the outcomes".
We can do this to some extent. We can predict paths of simple objects, we can predict how macroscopic systems will play out to some degree of accuracy. We can even predict the existence of particles and confirm the consistency of such predictions in later observations.
Surely the goal is to make our predictions better, up to any limit the universe gives. We want to be able to perfectly simulate the world - we don't just want the 1:1 map, we want a 1x10^20:1 map with moving people, with weather, with every possible feature that we can measure so that instead of travelling to Ulaanbaatur and dropping a rocket motor from the troposphere we can do that in the "map", and measure the effects in the map and so know what the effects would be if that were to happen for real.
We can't use the Universe as it's own map, we can't arbitrarily look at it at any scale, we can't run it back or duplicate it when we want to re-run experiments, we can't visit any part without travelling, etc. - so we seek to simulate it, through simplification because we can't currently simulate it any other way. As we uncover ever better models we learn to simulate limited sections or limited facets to a greater and greater degree.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Exactitude_in_Science https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Exactitude_in_Science
- Barrin92 8y agobut the predictability in this example comes from the function that maps one state of the map to the next through time, not from any visible or high-resolution feature in any particular snapshot of the map. You don't determine the function and the skeleton of the map by increasing its resolution, you obtain its functions by abstracting the unnecessary details away to figure out what the important objects and regularities are. If you want to figure out how the tube in London works you don't need a photorealistic, lifelike copy of the subway system, you need an abstraction of the network, its congestion, routes and so forth. Those are idealised mental models that are simplifying the real system, but they are much more useful to you than the real thing.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoAssuming you want to know how the tube works, as a passenger, independently of other systems, then yes. But if you're building a grand unified model of how London works then not only do you want to be able to abstract certain facets, you also want to be able to combine the models those abstractions create with data points to build a more complex systemic model. You want to look at where the stations are in relation to others, how the different transport networks link, what happens when a tube-train stops - how does the effect ripple through the system and alter what time a particular Pret-a-manger have to restock the sandwiches. At that point the abstraction in to a simplified system that only describes the tube is useless you need to combine the abstractions to model the entire system - and you may be able to get there, except your model missed out sunspot activity and a bus-driver turned the wrong way because their GPS was marginally out and the Pret-a-manger manager missed the start of the shift and now you have to eat Cheese instead of Mexican chicken. In short you want your abstraction to be able to construct a model that is as close as necessary for the purpose to the "photorealistic, lifelike copy" of whatever it is you're seeking to predict. If you only wish to predict how many stops you'll need to stay on the tube for then a simple tube map suffices. If you want to predict airflow through the tube system and how it affects heat exchange then a more complex model will be needed, with different abstractions (preserving length of tunnels for example). If you want to predict everything that it's possible to predict ... [Disclaimer I've no idea what Pret's menu is.]