3 ms·
>“Why should the laws of nature care about what I find beautiful?” I find this question to be missing the fundamental point of scientific endeavour. Nature obv
by Barrin92 8y ago
>“Why should the laws of nature care about what I find beautiful?”
I find this question to be missing the fundamental point of scientific endeavour. Nature obviously does not care about beauty, but scientists do because extracting meaning and order (laws) from observations and building models is the very essence of scientific insight.
The goal of science is not to replicate nature, it is to build a model of nature from which we can collect insights and make predictions, the model does not need to 'conform to' nature. That's not the point. If that were the case we could just dump the LHC data into a textbook. There is a great story writen by Borges called The Exactitude of Science where he creates the analogy of a large, but useless map:
"... In that Empire, the Art of Cartography attained such Perfection that the map of a single Province occupied the entirety of a City, and the map of the Empire, the entirety of a Province. In time, those Unconscionable Maps no longer satisfied, and the Cartographers Guilds struck a Map of the Empire whose size was that of the Empire, and which coincided point for point with it. The following Generations, who were not so fond of the Study of Cartography as their Forebears had been, saw that that vast map was Useless, and not without some Pitilessness was it, that they delivered it up to the Inclemencies of Sun and Winters. In the Deserts of the West, still today, there are Tattered Ruins of that Map, inhabited by Animals and Beggars; in all the Land there is no other Relic of the Disciplines of Geography."
- Certhas 8y agoI think you misunderstand the issue here. No one is arguing against reductionism, and equations, and extracting meaning. You have a different notion of beauty in mind than the one that is being criticized here. This is an overdue debate within the context of theoretical physics. No one wants to throw the process of deriving equations and models that explain data out. If anything Hossenfelder is the classicist here, rejecting ideas that want to go beyond empirical truth in order to salvage preconceived notions on what the laws of physics "should look like".
- nine_k 8y agoSo, science is a contraction mapping of reality onto its subset (some mathematical theories). For it to work, it should remove some redundancy, some predictable structure. Finding and describing this predictable structure is the essence of science. Lack of a predictable structure is lack of beauty: a stream of random numbers is both incompressible and aesthetically disappointing. This is why looking for signs of beauty is a good heuristics for finding that hidden structure. Same applies to engineering, BTW; the father of Soviet space program (Sputnik, first man in space) S. Korolev said: "An ugly aircraft will not fly".
- rxhernandez 8y agoThough, ugly software very much does run and can turn a profit despite it.
- Cyphase 8y agoSoftware doesn't have to obey the laws of physics in the same way; it just has to obey the laws of a dirty, messy, virtual environment created by humans. Obviously the physical world is below all the human-made layers, but it's far enough removed that I don't think that ugly yet functional software alone refutes the point nine_k (the GP) was making. Just a thought.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoSuch a map is far from useless - if you want to see any other area you don't have to travel there; you can "visit" all areas, you can duplicate any one area and experiment on how changes will affect it, etc.. It's only the bulk of the map that makes it impractical, we actually now have maps that are pretty close to that, we just found a way to make them less bulky. I think the end goal of science actually is very close to the 1:1 scale map in Borges' story [1] - we want to be able to say in any situation "if I take this scenario and run it forward then what are the outcomes". We can do this to some extent. We can predict paths of simple objects, we can predict how macroscopic systems will play out to some degree of accuracy. We can even predict the existence of particles and confirm the consistency of such predictions in later observations. Surely the goal is to make our predictions better, up to any limit the universe gives. We want to be able to perfectly simulate the world - we don't just want the 1:1 map, we want a 1x10^20:1 map with moving people, with weather, with every possible feature that we can measure so that instead of travelling to Ulaanbaatur and dropping a rocket motor from the troposphere we can do that in the "map", and measure the effects in the map and so know what the effects would be if that were to happen for real. We can't use the Universe as it's own map, we can't arbitrarily look at it at any scale, we can't run it back or duplicate it when we want to re-run experiments, we can't visit any part without travelling, etc. - so we seek to simulate it, through simplification because we can't currently simulate it any other way. As we uncover ever better models we learn to simulate limited sections or limited facets to a greater and greater degree. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Exactitude_in_Science https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Exactitude_in_Science
- Barrin92 8y agobut the predictability in this example comes from the function that maps one state of the map to the next through time, not from any visible or high-resolution feature in any particular snapshot of the map. You don't determine the function and the skeleton of the map by increasing its resolution, you obtain its functions by abstracting the unnecessary details away to figure out what the important objects and regularities are. If you want to figure out how the tube in London works you don't need a photorealistic, lifelike copy of the subway system, you need an abstraction of the network, its congestion, routes and so forth. Those are idealised mental models that are simplifying the real system, but they are much more useful to you than the real thing.