2 ms·
Though YouTube claims that unlisted content can’t be accessed through an Internet search, this isn’t quite true. Of course. If someone shares the link elsewher
by userbinator 8y ago
Though YouTube claims that unlisted content can’t be accessed through an Internet search, this isn’t quite true.
Of course. If someone shares the link elsewhere and that page gets indexed and crawled by a search engine, then it will obviously become accessible that way.
Thanks to one YouTube flaw, unlisted videos become visible when placed in a playlist.
Is that a flaw or "by design"? I could see this being useful for those who want to only organise videos into playlists without having them "loose".
It seems the whole point of this feature is to prevent the videos from being accessible from inside YouTube itself; whatever happens elsewhere is none of their business, so it could be argued that it is working as intended.
- Tehnix 8y agoIt would be incredibly naive to think that google does no checks on the sites they list in their searches. For one, they own Youtube and can directly look up if the video is private, and secondly, aren’t there handling of this in stuff like robots.txt?... Edit: are we Reddit now, and downvotes are a sign of disagrement?
- whatshisface 8y ago>For one, they one Youtube and can directly look up if the video is private, If Google was found to be treating their own properties differently, there would be an outcry that you couldn't believe.
- lftl 8y agoGoogle supports the robots meta tag: https://developers.google.com/search/reference/robots_meta_tag https://developers.google.com/search/reference/robots_meta_t... They could easily add a noindex meta tag to unlisted YT videos and then have Google Search treat it like any other site.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoYou could still find the unlisted videos on a page that links to them (such as a playlist). Google couldn't delist pages that merely link to noindex content, in general, without allowing everyone who can control noindex tags being able to delist any page that allows UGC with links. Imagine if Google say "if it links to a non-public YT video we'll delist it", that's just a weapon to get pages that take UGC delisted.
- microwavecamera 8y agoKey word there is found. Look at Facebook and the whole Cambridge Analytica debacle. The outcry happens after the fact, after they're caught. Assuming the worst is no different than assuming the best.
- zeusk 8y ago> aren’t there handling of this in stuff like robots.txt?... robots.txt only describes where a bot should go and where it shouldn't go, but nothing about what it should do with the content it discovers.
- detaro 8y agorobots meta-tags would be the place though.
- kerng 8y agoI never use Google to search, so I get to see all the private unlisted stuff? No, that would be a big fail on Google's side.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]