3 ms·
Why are the platforms this big? Why can’t a small community run its own software like it runs Wordpress, but for social apps and police itself? A village knew
by EGreg 8y ago
Why are the platforms this big? Why can’t a small community run its own software like it runs Wordpress, but for social apps and police itself?
A village knew whether someone was yelling obscenities. HN is a smaller community, with its own software.
I think the answer is that there is no good open source software for this.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI
- lopmotr 8y agoThat already happens but they're small communities so you don't have much awareness of those that you're not a member of. Anyone can join privately run forums with like-minded people and sensible moderation that they agree with. There's no problem to be solved. When you want small communities, you have forums, when you want lowest-common-denominator drivel, you have Facebook, and when you want to feel tribal warmth by sharing your political opinions with people who agree with you while also being protected from opinions you don't agree with, you have Twitter.
- pavel_lishin 8y ago> when you want lowest-common-denominator drivel, you have Facebook, and when you want to feel tribal warmth by sharing your political opinions with people who agree with you while also being protected from opinions you don't agree with, you have Twitter. That's not exactly fair; you can customize Twitter (to some degree, if you use a third party app) and Facebook (to an even smaller degree) to actually get content you care about. (e.g., there's no small forum I can join that'll get me Charles Stross's musings and a video game developer whose updates I like and a podcast's funny tweets.) RSS used to be great for that sort of thing, but it's been largely superceded by Twitter, etc.
- intended 8y agoThe answer is that most people are unaware of the history of the interent. Even in bygone eras there were LOTS of communities like this, and they too had to deal with these issues. Famously - Jewish communities would get targetted by Nazis, or Holocaust deniers. They would get DDOSed or worse. Spam, trolls and so on were always there. Many of the terms we use to describe this problem come from that era. In the end, you ALWAYS end up depending on moderation. Its not the software - its the wetware.