3 ms·
you are fundamentally misunderstanding my argument: sometimes it is different. When it is different, it's usually because associated technologies has changed.
by dnautics 8y ago
you are fundamentally misunderstanding my argument: sometimes it is different. When it is different, it's usually because associated technologies has changed. For ML, it was GPUs and large amounts of data harvestable from the internet (arguably the second one more than the first). The evolutionary development in compilers is a strong argument that it MIGHT happen to end SpecEx. If it doesn't it's probably mostly due to technical debt and engineering inertia, difficulty convincing end users to adopt. There are definitely cases where non specex (vliw or otherwise) can outperform, I have seen it with my own eyes.
- ajross 8y ago> If it doesn't it's probably mostly due to technical debt and engineering inertia You jumped straight from "absence of proof must be proof of the opposite" into as bald a no true scotsmanism as I've seen recently. It's like fallacy central here.
- Dylan16807 8y agoAn argument of the form "many X failed, but a new X might not" is not a form of no true scotsman. It would only be no true scotsman if the claim was "X always wins, and Itanium wasn't X" But anyway I think they're making a fair argument. If something takes an enormous technical effort to switch to, and is similar in performance, nobody is going to put in that effort. This is emphatically not evidence that the idea "doesn't work". I believe if you could retroactively wipe out the last decade of improvement on x86 and Arm, and redirect all of that development effort to VLIW, the resulting chips and software would perform just fine by current standards.