5 ms·
Creating billions of dollars’ worth of value with a ridiculous perpetual-motion fake-dollar-printing machine is a real innovation. Creating money by printing i
by joe_the_user 8y ago
Creating billions of dollars’ worth of value with a ridiculous perpetual-motion fake-dollar-printing machine is a real innovation.
Creating money by printing is not a new thing. Making people believe that the money you've created with whatever hocus-pocus is real and that investment X will just spew money indefinitely is not at all a new thing. It is one very standard old thing.
That by itself doesn't prove bitcoin is this. But in analyzing investment that's rocketing up in value, one should remember that what Hyman Minsky called "speculative finance", ie, bubbles, should not be excluded or treated as "something really weird". "Are X many people really that foolish?" Well, how often has this happened before? There is an answer to that question.
- achompas 8y ago> Making people believe that the money you've created with whatever hocus-pocus is real and that investment X will just spew money indefinitely is not at all a new thing. Across so many people, and at BTC's market cap though? I think that's unprecedented. Penny stocks or pyramid schemes, sure, but they never affect this many people or hit 12-digit valuations. (By the way, fiat money doesn't count as an example because it is backed by a variety of government support structures (which are very much not hocus-pocus) and it does not appreciate in value indefinitely relative to the cost of goods.)
- lazyasciiart 8y agoAlmost everything that happens today is unprecedented in 'affecting this many people'. It's probably more informative to ask whether it is affecting a larger percentage of people exposed to it than previous examples- and I don't know the answer to that, but I suspect it isn't.
- copenja 8y agoThat's an interesting question. Bernie Madoff’s Ponzi scheme is estimated to have lost clients $65 billion. The Bitcoin market cap is nearly double at $107 billion. But Bernie Madoff's $65 billion is all real dollars paid into the scheme. Bitcoin market cap doesn't track the amount of the money that has been paid into the current Bitcoin market. It simply estimates the current market price, then multiplies that number by the total of number of Bitcoins. So the amount currently paid into the current Bitcoin market is going to be much, much lower. Experts estimate that nearly 30% of current bitcoins are 'lost' forever in non-recoverable wallets. Also, the gal who bought 1000 bitcoin at 5 dollars hasn't re-paid another $6 million into the system. But, if Bitcoin crashed to zero today, would you also need to account for dollars lost by investors who built mining stations and gear? I guess we will never know. But, I think it is fair to say that the Madoff scheme is in the same ballpark of Bitcoin.
- bduerst 8y agoThe apples:apples comparison would be a total of amount of currency converted into Bitcoin.
- nostrademons 8y ago24h trading volume for BTC/USD (excluding BTC/USDT and all non-USD fiat currencies) is over $500M [1], and has been at that rate or higher since last December. That's over $90B in real money that has exchanged hands for Bitcoin. It's not quite the same as the Madoff Ponzi scheme, because in that, all the money went into Madoff's firm, and relatively little came out as redemptions. In a trading market, every dollar that comes in from a buyer goes out to a seller (minus exchange fees, which reportedly have netted Coinbase close to $1B this year, again supporting a >$100B trade volume). They can then be used to purchase more crypto later, and show up in the volume statistics again. But this alone indicates that Bitcoin may be a bit more resilient than Madoff's ponzi scheme; when multiple people get rich off it, there's much less of a single point of failure for the scheme to collapse. [1] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/bitcoin/#markets https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/bitcoin/#markets
- headsoup 8y agoThat would assume that it is 'different' money changing hands would it not? I.e. that %500M and $90B is unique dollars being transacted and not just promises being passed back and forth.
- nostrademons 8y agoIt does, and that's an assumption that probably doesn't hold. Most things in the economy work that way though - the total supply of hard currency in the economy is only $3.6T, so when you speak of the $18T US GDP or the $20T US national debt or the $524T value of the derivatives market, it necessarily accounts for the same dollar changing hands multiple times. That's what makes it a currency, that it can circulate and change hands while holding its value.
- 8y ago
- arisAlexis 8y agousdt is a usd peg system with no fake money. did you ever read the technical details?
- zik 8y agoBut it's claimed that it's not really a peg system at all - that Tether were fraudulently created while claiming they were pegged.
- arisAlexis 8y agoyes and because someone wrote about it then it's true right? I can't think of anybody wanting to spread FUD to profit from shorting...for the life of me, really. Who is the manipulator in this case?
- rrcaptain 8y agoExcept Tether hasn't actually proved they have the cash they claim. So why should we take their word that they're a peg system when they haven't proved it?
- sfifs 8y agoThe problem is they have never demonstrated they actually have the money. It's very simple really to ask your bank to provide a certified and digitally signed account statement. This routinely happens in audits. Tether has never showed this. So the accusation is that its operation is basically fraud.
- xapata 8y ago> unprecedented Mortgage crisis? Sure, Bitcoin is different. But it's kinda the same...
- anthony_barker 8y agoI am not a bitcoin maximalist. But Bitcoin is a new kind of money that no one can take from you. Better than gold, cash or anything that came before in certain circumstances. That said other tokens have similar characteristics..
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- RachelF 8y agoIndeed, a cynic would say Bitfinex were just copying the Fed's QE. Creating tether out of nothing to buy bitcoin is similar to the Fed creating dollars by QE to prop up asset prices.
- joe_the_user 8y agoIndeed, though states have boots and guns on the ground to a last resort backup the value of their currency (including protecting against competition). So I'd pick "Fed-coin" as the last one to go down.
- DennisP 8y agoI've been reading up lately on how fiat money systems work, and it doesn't seem to me that boots and guns really help. Certainly there have been countries with plenty of soldiers who failed to maintain the value of their currency. You have to pay taxes in the local currency, but if the currency crashes you just have to pay a higher nominal amount of taxes. You can outlaw competing currencies, but you can only do that in your own country, and it doesn't necessarily keep your official currency from going down the toilet.
- roenxi 8y agoIt can help. I'd argue that the US-Saudi deal [1] was in part facilitated by the US being able to offer the Saudi regime military supplies and protection. The military is arguably not the dominant factor, but that is a very debatable point. It is certainly a factor. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2016-05-30/the-untold-story-behind-saudi-arabia-s-41-year-u-s-debt-secret https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2016-05-30/the-untol...
- chepaslaaa 8y agoThe US' military might is the only reason why all oil is traded in USD and the main reason why the USD holds value.
- 8y ago