3 ms·
> This type of comment implies you think the world is static. I'm not saying that this good, but what makes you so sure market and social forces won't produce a
by adventured 8y ago
> This type of comment implies you think the world is static. I'm not saying that this good, but what makes you so sure market and social forces won't produce a better model?
They already are: multiple low or modest cost, high speed satellite providers are targeting the US market for deployment in the next four or five years.
The dumber Comcast and AT&T are about the situation, the more money SpaceX is going to make on Starlink. Amusingly, Comcast is probably going to help get us to Mars.
Regardless of the rampant cynicism about competition (plenty of which is warranted), the low earth orbit competition is coming fast. Nothing can stop it at this point.
- amazon_not 8y ago> They already are: multiple low or modest cost, high speed satellite providers are targeting the US market for deployment in the next four or five years. Hoping satellite will solve your bandwidth problems is wishful thinking of the worst sort. There simply isn't enough spectrum, and thus bandwidth, to go around. Can't beat physics.
- adventured 8y agoSo your premise is multiple companies, with ultimately a decade of preparation, regulatory effort, and build-out, are set to spend billions of dollars on a non-market. All because they just didn't understand physics can't be beat. Oh sure, amazon_not, I'll take your word for it. Since when does SpaceX know what they're doing.
- amazon_not 8y agoI'm not saying there won't be A market. I'm saying there won't be THE market you are hoping for. Satellite has it's uses, but replacing terrestrial broadband networks isn't one. The satellite industry is littered with roadkill, bankruptcies and wasted billions. It's not the first time somebody would be wrong.