21 ms·
Things I Learned in the Gulag
- Fins 8y agoKolyma Stories is probably the best book about the reality of communism.
- allthing 8y agoI would also highly recommend "Gulag" by Anne Applebaum. She covers the entire history of the Gulag in great detail from the Revolution to the fall of the Soviet Empire.
- jpatokal 8y agoKolyma Stories and Solzhenitsyn's Gulag Archipelago are an incredible pair. For Solzhenitsyn, the Gulag is deeply personal and his rage seeps through every page. Shalamov is the complete opposite, and his book is an inhumanly dispassionate sequence of vignettes of camp life. Some of the mental images stick with you for life, like the zek (camp inmate) who broke into the camp larder, barricaded the door from the inside, and feasted by gnawing on raw, frozen bacon. He was still smiling when they broke in, dragged him out, beat him and threw him into the isolation cells, because at least his belly was full...
- foobiekr 8y agoGulag Archipelago looks daunting. It's an insane amount of material. Must one read all three volumes?
- kinsomo 8y agoI read a ~400 page abridged version, but I do feel I missed out.
- cwyers 8y agoI've read the original three volume version, which I got from a library. I own the abridged. You do miss a lot, but you can still get a lot out of the single-volume version.
- romanhn 8y agoI listened to an unabridged audiobook version - 67 hours of laughingly bad, home-made narration in Russian. Even then, it was easily one of the most riveting books I have come across.
- archagon 8y agoWas it this one, by chance? https://rutracker.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=4011302 https://rutracker.org/forum/viewtopic.php?t=4011302 I thought the reading was superb, even though the quality was a bit scratchy.
- romanhn 8y agoNo, it was the Ignatiy Lapkin version (linked from that page). That guy was something else.
- pvg 8y agoYou don't have to. Big chunks of it can be difficult to follow without the historical context Solzhenitsyn assumes the reader has - that you'd have to get elsewhere. More importantly though, you don't really have to read it in order, you can poke around the ToC and find stuff that doesn't require knowledge of the details of the early show trials, etc. You can hop over to the chapter on arrests or escape attempts and see how it goes.
- jfk13 8y agoFor a less intimidating introduction, you might like to try One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich.
- dragandj 8y agoOne Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich is a good book, but nothing like the Gulag Archipelago. Ivan Denisovich was officially supported by the USSR in a brief period after Stalin's death, as a book that talks about the imprisonment, but waters it down so much as to make it not-so-terrible. Gulag Archipelago is much more interesting, and also much more eye-opening.
- Fins 8y agoThe problem with* Gulag* is that (in Russian) it is quite badly written, unlike Shalamov's stories which real literature even before editors got to them. History-wise, there are better sources, too.
- archagon 8y agoStrongly disagree. Reading for the first time in Russian and finding that it flows wonderfully. Solzhenitsyn has a unique tone of voice: at once conversational, ironic, sadly humorous, and full of pathos. His imagery can be breathtaking, e.g. when he's talking about the different rivers of prisoners flowing in and out of the gulag system. When referencing his own life, his sense of narrative pacing is superb. And when it comes to matters of the soul, he has a way with words that few others can touch. Indeed, there's a number of what I would consider "best of all time" quotes in the first few chapters alone. If only it were all so simple! If only there were evil people somewhere insidiously committing evil deeds, and it were necessary only to separate them from the rest of us and destroy them. But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being. And who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart? During the life of any heart this line keeps changing place; sometimes it is squeezed one way by exuberant evil and sometimes it shifts to allow enough space for good to flourish. One and the same human being is, at various ages, under various circumstances, a totally different human being. At times he is close to being a devil, at times to sainthood. But his name doesn't change, and to that name we ascribe the whole lot, good and evil. (I wrote down: "names are leaky abstractions.") It's true that there's some dry and boring material, but I can hardly blame the author for that: he's the last living source for so many of these stories. I can picture him sitting at his typewriter, trying in vain to resurrect the final, fading memories of the countless missing people who touched his life—nameless and nearly faceless, probably buried in some unmarked grave—while waiting for the KGB to burst in any minute and destroy his decade of work. How much more painful must the process of editing be when the things you cut are fragments of human lives that might as well have never existed once they leave the page? Unfortunately, there's now a contingent of the Russian population that denounces Solzhenitsyn for reasons of pure nationalism. It makes me so sad when I see Solzhenitsyn mentioned in the Runet, because it's almost always extremely vitriolic...
- jpatokal 8y agoI found it quite accessible and have read it end to end twice. It's not a Russian heavy literature doorstop a la War & Peace, but an encyclopedic one-man survey of every aspect of the camps, roughly in chronological order: first the the history of labor camps in Russia, then the journey of a typical inmate (arrest, interrogation, trial, transit, arrival, life and death in the camps for prisoners and guards alike, freedom [1]), then the slow winding down of the system. [1] In some sense, at least; see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/101st_kilometre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/101st_kilometre
- dragandj 8y agoIt's long, but very interesting. It's much better to read it whole, than some abridged version.
- fractallyte 8y agoThe Gulag Archipelago is available here: https://archive.org/details/TheGulagArchipelago-Threevolumes https://archive.org/details/TheGulagArchipelago-Threevolumes
- pvg 8y agoI'm not making some 'it wasn't real communism, man!' defense but those books are about the reality of prison life under the peak of (communist) totalitarian repression. There was a lot more to the reality. Even the Soviets eventually figured out that level of murderous control was an entirely unnecessary waste of human life and the communism communismed on for decades.
- cwyers 8y agoThat's not entirely accurate. They did figure out that Stalin's level of repression was unnecessary, or at least they lacked the conviction to carry it out. But in "The Gulag Archipelago" by Solzhenitsyn, he documents how much of the apparatus continued forward into Khrushchev's regime. He details the town of Novocherkassk, where workers went on strike in June of 1962. Tanks and troops were dispatched. The strikers were fired upon. The wounded were rounded up, and the families of the wounded and the dead were shipped off to Siberia. He talks about other incidents. He talks about how the religious were still treated the same as under Stalin. Life after (or even before) Stalin was not free from such abuses.
- pvg 8y agoKolyma Stories is probably the best book about the reality of communism. Is what I'm replying to. It's a very narrow slice of a much bigger thing. Life after (or even before) Stalin was not free from such abuses. I'm not sure why you think I said anything of the sort. As to 'figured out', no, of course they didn't have a sudden epiphany while taking a shower one morning. The paranoid nutcase that ruled them died. The thing that I was getting at, really, is that there is a fairly common but mistaken notion that the Soviet system was all about overt repression; that it depended, throughout its entire lifespan on the direct and immediate threat of deadly state violence. It didn't and that's, in many ways, a more interesting and disturbing thing to consider. This isn't a particularly original or new thought - if you've run across, say, Masha Gessen's recent writing, it's often reiterated (as a kind of starting point) there as well.
- Fins 8y ago
- anticodon 8y agoIt's a one-sided and highly exaggerated view.
- pvg 8y agoIt's pretty hard to cover whatever the other side is when you're stuck in a prison camp. Not sure in what way it's 'exaggerated', though. The worse stuff, nobody was left to write about.
- anticodon 8y agoParent comment was saying that these are the books to read if you want to know life under communist rule. I wanted to say that it's not true. This kind of literature describe only a small part of a life. Not everybody was living in a prison camp in USSR, not even a majority of the population. This kind of literature was funded and promoted by the West because it supports the western society discourse. Person who judges life in USSR by these kind of books will have a very skewed opinion.
- pvg 8y agoThis kind of literature was funded and promoted by the West because it supports the western society discourse. I think the parent comment is reductive in a the-opposite-of-insightful way but no, that literature was not "funded and promoted by the West because it supports the western society discourse."
- cwyers 8y ago> This kind of literature was funded and promoted by the West because it supports the western society discourse. I mean, I'd agree that the material is a thin slice of the society, but come on. These are real personal narratives of people who lived through these experiences. The implication that "the West" is why these books exist, not just why we're able to read them, is absurd.
- jhbadger 8y ago
- d0mine 8y agoonly as much as Abu Ghraib represents capitalism and democracy.
- AlexB138 8y agoI would suggest that Abu Ghraib represented Imperialism more than Capitalism or Democracy. But I would also say it's a false comparison. There's a massive difference in frequency and scale.
- rich-and-poor 8y ago7. I saw that the only group of people able to preserve a minimum of humanity in conditions of starvation and abuse were the religious believers, the sectarians (almost all of them), and most priests. 29. Russians’ uncontrollable urge to denounce and complain. A warning for those who loudly denounce Western society as a great tyrannical patriarchy, who wish to replace the old culture. Be wary of complaining, denouncing, secular men and women.
- courtf 8y agoEh, kind of a stretch. Religion is not a purely Western invention, and you're reading what you want to in #29.
- rich-and-poor 8y agoI admit it is not a precise argument, but eradicating religion & denouncing your nation's culture as a tyrannical, oppressive force were the two major ingredients for the revolution that led to the slaughter of 60 million Russians. The two motivations that led to the communist revolution are alive and well in our present culture.
- mikeash 8y agoWheat and gunpowder were also major ingredients in the revolution. The fact that the revolution was anti-religion tells us nothing about the wisdom of being anti-religion, any more than the Crusades tell us about the wisdom of being religious.
- deepsun 8y ago> The extreme fragility of human culture, civilization. A man becomes a beast in three weeks, given heavy labor, cold, hunger, and beatings. I remember hearing that from some Czech artist -- he said it was very surprising to see that all the civilized culture we have can be wiped out in just two weeks. What's so bad in stealing, lying, raping, murdering for food? He learned to respect that fragile balance of culture we built over animal human nature.
- taneq 8y ago“There are only nine meals between mankind and anarchy” - Alfred Henry Lewis
- quickthrower2 8y agoIf you have a 3 year old: "There is only 1/2 a meal between mankind and anarchy"
- Jaruzel 8y agoAfter reading the article, I needed that laugh. Thanks! :)
- trashtester 8y agoI have a 4-year-old and a 2-year-old. 1/2 a meal or even a meal is just a situation that requires actual parenting. But the shift from the norm (the stress) is enough to give a faint idea about what a serious situation hunger can be. Experiencing actual starvation, especially in your children, potentially even deaths of family members by starvation, now that is real hell. Such experiences change people permanently. If a population experiences this, it is very commonly followed by war within their lifetimes. Without the hunger caused by hyperinflation in Germany in the early 20's, I serioulsy doubt that they would have followed Hitler. It may even be that Hitler would never have become the monster he was without that period.
- vackosar 8y agoI wonder if some parts of the brain shutdown when you are lacking sleep and are hungry. UPDATE: There is a study: http://www.mc3cb.com/pdf_articles_interest_physiology/2012_4_10_Stress_Shut_%20Down_Brain.pdf http://www.mc3cb.com/pdf_articles_interest_physiology/2012_4...
- symlock 8y ago> 22. I saw that women are more decent and self-sacrificing than men The majority of men love themselves while women love others. Men will sacrifice for themselves. Women will sacrifice for others. Why? Is it global culture teaching a woman from birth her life is about others? A husband and kids? While teaching men that their value is in their work, their job, their income, their power?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- courtf 8y agoThe way it's worded it mostly just sounds like men were generally more cowardly. Of course there could be a variety of pressures that might account for the anecdote, such as women not being given the opportunity to refuse.
- djschnei 8y agoIf I had to make an admittedly uneducated guess, I bet females being more self-sacrificing than men can be seen across species. It would only make sense that the sex generally responsible for child-rearing would be the sex most likely to self-sacrifice. I know nowadays, especially in the tech scene, it is frowned upon to suggest intrinsic differences between the sexes and to imply those differences can affect behavior at a statistical level, but with this fascinating historical context, it's an interesting thought.
- silveroriole 8y agoFunny, if anything I’d say it would make more sense for females to be LESS self-sacrificing across species. Surely evolutionarily it is more important that females get enough resources to survive; males should self-sacrifice to enable that. And of course there are also lots of stereotypes about women being selfish, wilful, demanding etc. Not sure the one about them being self-sacrificing is any more true than that.
- n4r9 8y ago
- imbokodo 8y agoA good book on prison lessons is Soledad Brother by George Jackson, a black man who was imprisoned in Soledad Prison, California, USA. He was killed by a guard at San Quentin in 1971.
- jackfoxy 8y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Jackson_(activist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Jackson_(activist)
- MichaelMoser123 8y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xxpq1-eqcuo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xxpq1-eqcuo Clouds by Galich. brings up this song for me Here is a translation of the lyrics: http://americanradioworks.publicradio.org/features/stalin/d2.html http://americanradioworks.publicradio.org/features/stalin/d2... The clouds float by, the clouds, Without hurrying, like in a film. I'm eating chicken tabaka, And I've sunk a load of cognac. The clouds float off to Abakan [a Gulag area]. Unhurried they float. They're warm, I bet, those clouds, But I've been frozen through forever! Like a horseshoe I froze into the sleigh tracks, Into the ice I was chipping with my pick! After all, not for nothing I blew away 20 years in those camps. I still have that snow crust before my eyes! I still have the din of frisking in my ears! Hey, bring me a pineapple And another 200 g. of cognac! The clouds float by, the clouds, Floating to Kolyma [a work camp] that dear old place, And they don't need a lawyer, An amnesty's neither here nor there. Me too, I live a first-rate life! Twenty years I swapped for one day! And I sit in this bar like a lord, I've even got some teeth left! The clouds float off to the east, They've no pension, no worries. Me, on the fourth, I get a money order, And another on the 23rd. And on those days, just like me. Half the country sits in the bars! And in our memory off to those places Float the clouds, the clouds. Translation taken from Smith, Gerald Stanton. (1984). Songs to Seven Strings: Russian Guitar Poetry and Soviet Mass Song. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press. 195-196.
- sidcool 8y agoReminds me of Victor Frankl's book, Man's search for meaning. Very profound.
- kgwgk 8y agoPrimo Levi wrote three books about his experience at Auschwitz. The last one (The Drowned and the Saved) is centered on the "philosofical" issues. https://theorangutanlibrarian.wordpress.com/2017/08/01/grappling-with-the-drowned-and-the-saved/ https://theorangutanlibrarian.wordpress.com/2017/08/01/grapp... "Though of a similar nature and sharing the same subject matter (Auschwitz and the Holocaust), Frankl’s book is one of the most uplifting reads I’ve ever experienced. Victor Frankl more than just physically survived the war; Primo Levi on the other hand felt like a different story. Put simply: Levi is the darkness to Frankl’s light."
- forapurpose 8y agoLet's recall that there are people living these experiences and worse, right this moment, in Gulags in North Korea (and possibly other places I'm not thinking of).
- TimTheTinker 8y agoGood reminder - thanks.
- Muromec 8y agoOne doesn't need to go to NK for that. Modern Russian state still tortures political dissidents in prisons even now. Not in large-scale labor-camps, just because it is not that necessary. And they still send people to frozen shitholes to fuck them over. ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oleg_Sentsov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oleg_Sentsov
- helloindia 8y agoAnd the re-education camps in China. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/15/opinion/china-re-education-camps.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/15/opinion/china-re-educatio...
- wallace_f 8y agoOf course we wouldn't mention CIA black sites, the possibility of more Abu Ghraibs, or even those in the US allowed to be beaten, killed or tortured at the hands of other prisoners, guards, or even police.
- TimTheTinker 8y agoCommunist dictators and other ideological authoritarians in political power (who demand assimilation) are orders of magnitude more murderous and deadly than US torture places, bad as those may be.
- 8y ago
- pnathan 8y agoUnchecked power is a bad thing to hand to another human being.
- mrobot 8y agoI don't know that much about the Soviet Union. This guy was basically sent to prison for 'participating in “counter-revolutionary Trotskyist activities.' I have been following some leftist stuff and saw this article recently by Trotsky. It is called "Hitler the Pacifist" and starts out "Hitler wants peace." Trotsky didn't seem like that good of a guy, but i haven't read that much about him yet. In any case here is the article: https://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/1933/11/pacifist.htm https://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/1933/11/pacifist.ht...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Muromec 8y ago> This guy was basically sent to prison for 'participating in “counter-revolutionary Trotskyist activities.' This is catchall phrase that means essentially nothing. He was publicly critical of Stalin and his father was a priest, which sounds more like real reason.
- noobermin 8y agoActually, the wiki page on the writer says he tried to share Lenin's last testament, which was a threat to Stalin and suggested Trotsky push Stalin out of power.
- ptaipale 8y agoIf you know anything about the GULAG, you know that people sent there as "counter-revolutionary Trotskyist activists" very often did not have anything to do with counter-revolutionary activist, or Trotsky, or anything. Very often it was just being unlucky, and even then, they strongly believed in the Soviet system, they just thought there was some clerical error, and tried to appeal to higher leader to have those errors fixed - without understanding the point of the Terror. Most people eventually did understand, of course.
- Cadabrum 8y agoAnd... The point of the Terror was ..?
- TimTheTinker 8y ago> I saw that the only group of people able to preserve a minimum of humanity in conditions of starvation and abuse were the religious believers, the sectarians (almost all of them), and most priests. I’m curious which religions were represented, and what he meant by “sectarians”. Christianity at least would seem to be implied (by “priests”) and the fact that this was a Soviet gulag — Christians in particular were strongly persecuted under the USSR. (Perhaps at least partly because they resisted ideological assimilation more strongly than any other groups — even to death and martyrdom in many cases.) It’s also very interesting that military and party members were the first to lose it. No wonder communists feared and/or hated religion — they knew their own ideology couldn’t strengthen people or hold them in its grip anywhere near as well.
- DylanDmitri 8y agoMostly Russian Orthodox. Sectarians were also russian orthodox but also members of these psuedo-monastic religious orders that were popular at the time.
- Fins 8y agoBaptists, pentecostals and other non-traditional denominations are usually termed as sects in Russian/Soviet usage. Old Believers (schismatic Orthodox) would be included too.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoStalins cult of personality and terror only reached so far.
- SSLy 8y agoOne particular sect that is relevant are the raskolnikovs (old-faithers)
- pouetpouet 8y agoMembers of the Russian orthodox church I suppose. Sectarians are likely also eastern orthodox but not under the Moscow Patriarchate like Old Belivers or the Catacomb church.
- archagon 8y agoIf anyone wants the original: https://shalamov.ru/library/29/ https://shalamov.ru/library/29/
- zczc 8y agoStrangely, #5 from the original is missing from the English text: "5. I have understood the difference between the prison strengthening character and the camp depraving human soul"
- mlechha 8y ago>7. I saw that the only group of people able to preserve a minimum of humanity in conditions of starvation and abuse were the religious believers, the sectarians (almost all of them), and most priests. This, to me is the point of religion. We need religion when things are hard and unpredictable. In a world where most things are certain and predictable, religion has no value.
- ekianjo 8y ago> In a world where most things are certain and predictable, religion has no value. Not much is predictable in your life.
- heavenlyblue 8y agoThe more white and privileged you are - the more predictable your life is.
- zingmars 8y agoYou could've just said 'rich' and do without the silly assumption that white people have it better than others because of their skin colour.
- heavenlyblue 8y agoI know - thanks, it wasn't a serious statement. Look at someone speaking about cancer over there: the guy's clearly missing the point that if you're rich and you die from cancer - then you're probably still going to be better off than if you're poor and die from cancer.
- ekianjo 8y agowhat a ridiculous claim. How much certain are you about contracting or not contracting illnesses?
- heavenlyblue 8y ago
- pmoriarty 8y agoAnyone interested in this would do well to read Victor Frankl's "Man's Search For Meaning" about his imprisonment in Auschwitz.[1] He found that a sense of meaning was critical to survival there, and went on to develop a new school of psychotherapy he called "logotherapy", which focused on finding meaning in life.[2] [1] - https://www.amazon.com/Mans-Search-Meaning-Viktor-Frankl/dp/080701429X/ https://www.amazon.com/Mans-Search-Meaning-Viktor-Frankl/dp/... [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logotherapy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logotherapy
- ryanstorm 8y agoI picked this up on a recommendation similar to yours and I now consider it one of the most important books I've read.
- ramblerman 8y ago> I saw that the only group of people able to preserve a minimum of humanity in conditions of starvation and abuse were the religious believers, the sectarians (almost all of them), and most priests. I am an atheist and don't need religion to tell me it is wrong to kill another man, or so I've always believed. This makes me think about the value of religion in our troubled history, and in shaping our culture. Because would I still be moral if I hadn't eaten for 5 days? I'm not sure.
- trashtester 8y agoWhy is it wrong to kill another man? I claim that most atheist that think they know the answer to this question, base it on a naive understanding of their own underlying value system. (PS. I'm also an atheist)
- monsieurbanana 8y agoFor some reason your comment seems incredibly haughty to me. By all means, enlighten me. Why is it wrong to kill a man? My personal reason is that I am an empathic person.
- simula67 8y ago> Why is it wrong to kill a man? It is not wrong to kill a man. It is only wrong to murder a man > My personal reason is that I am an empathic person. Lots of things can override empathy. Anger, jealousy, ambition etc. 'Do whatever you feel like' does not sound like much of a moral framework to me
- brobdingnagians 8y agoI think that's a good point that lots of things can override empathy. It would require something much stronger to not be overridden by _any_ circumstance encountered in life. (Even being married can be difficult, and it requires a strong belief in marriage and the value of it, to continue working at it and seeking the joy you believe you can have.) Religion with a belief in immortality and eternal justice with eternal possibility of happiness gives a very strong reason to live a certain way in order to get eternal happiness (which is, in some ways, an extension of the idea that living a certain way in this life brings happiness, cooperation, prosperity, industriousness).
- megous 8y agoPerhaps 7. is one reason for the religious radicalisation thriving in prisons.
- oblio 8y ago> 44. I understood that moving from the condition of a prisoner to the condition of a free man is very difficult, almost impossible without a long period of amortization.
- omginternets 8y ago>I understood why prisoners hear political news (arrests, et cetera) before the outside world does. What does this mean?
- alfredallan1 8y agoWhen someone politically notable gets thrown in the prison system, word of it gets around within the prison communities straight away. The official version released to the press has to go through officials and PR people, and arrives a bit later.
- picsao 8y agoDo not work to hard.. If you work to hard you will sweat. If you sweat you will freeze.
- wallace_f 8y ago30. I discovered that the world should be divided not into good and bad people but into cowards and non-cowards. Ninety-five percent of cowards are capable of the vilest things, lethal things, at the mildest threat. This is incredibly consistent with my observations. Possibly an explanation for the nature of the Founding Fathers.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pattle 8y agoOn a similar note and for anyone interested, I read "Zone 22" recently https://www.amazon.co.uk/Zone-22-Tig-Hague/dp/0718153561 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Zone-22-Tig-Hague/dp/0718153561 It's the story of a UK business man who got caught with a small amount of hashish in his pocket at Moscow airport and ended up spending 4 years in a prison camp. It makes for a pretty interesting -if grim at times - read.
- ctack 8y ago> 38. I realized what a terrible thing is the self-esteem of a boy or a youth: it’s better to steal than to ask. That self-esteem and boastfulness are what make boys sink to the bottom. Sounds like start up culture. Move fast and break things. Better to do than to ask permission.
- scottLobster 8y agoOnly superficially. "Better to do than ask permission" long predates startup culture and often holds just as true in large corporations. Especially true in fact, often there's a lot of red tape that people won't bother to enforce if you can present a working solution in the correct manner. "Move fast and break things" largely means "grow quickly enough that you're breaking stuff", which may or may not be a positive. Contrast that to choosing to steal another inmate's food instead of asking, because it would be too humiliating to ask or trade. All that's going to do is make you enemies, and reveals an underlying character weakness that will probably hurt you in other ways.
- jschwartzi 8y agoI prefer Grace Hopper's version, "It is often easier to ask for forgiveness than to ask for permission."
- agumonkey 8y agoit's very true, but one might add "if you're acting for the general good", not if you're only trying to have fun or disrupt social fabric