29 ms·
I fear Google's control of the web
- beaner 8y agoUgh, Google Reader wasn't a "huge part of the web," it was a product offered by a company. If GR and RSS were basically equivalent then Google was right to conclude that RSS wasn't popular. RSS is an open standard and GR never had any compelling competition even though it should have if RSS were used widely at all. That people are still angry over this shows how out of touch many developers are with the real world / average consumers.
- ucaetano 8y agoYeah, ask anyone outside of hacker news if they ever heard of Google Reader. Or RSS. Nobody.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoWell RSS you know plenty of devs have... At least hears of it... I hope...
- ksk 8y agoIsn't this entire site dedicated to discussing things 'nobody' has heard about?
- CharlesW 8y ago> Yeah, ask anyone outside of hacker news if they ever heard of Google Reader. Consider that because of your highly-technical background, you may be underestimating the popularity of Google Reader and overestimating the popularity of Hacker News among the general internet-savvy population at the time.
- ucaetano 8y agoAre you replying to me? That's exactly what I'm saying. Google Reader was an irrelevant product to the general public, only adopted by a very small niche of users, just as Hacker News is largely irrelevant and unknown to the general public.
- pdonis 8y ago> Google Reader was an irrelevant product to the general public Do you have any numbers to back this up? From what I remember, it had at least several million users.
- ucaetano 8y agoNo hard numbers, but here are some estimates: http://googlesystem.blogspot.com/2013/03/google-reader-data-points.html http://googlesystem.blogspot.com/2013/03/google-reader-data-... While CNN and Engadget had 24M and 7M RSS subscribers (which include Google Reader), the numbers drop quickly, with the 3rd one having 1.7M (NYT). Also, apparently the Google Reader Android app had <5M downloads at time of shutdown. Given that distribution and how fast it drops, I'd expect Reader to have had a couple million daily active users at time of shutdown, a tiny drop in the Internet & Google ocean. And you can go around and ask people who don't work in tech: nobody will have heard of Google Reader.
- ehsankia 8y agoAlso, Google literally has hundreds if not thousands of products, but everyone just loves going back to the one decade old example of Reader being shut down. Also Reader was nothing special; there were dozens of other just as capable RSS readers before and many more since.
- smt88 8y agoThey've killed or neglected many others. Google Voice and Hangouts seem to be on life support. Play Music will be killed soon too.
- csydas 8y agoReader is a convenient example of a product with a large following that met a simple need. Google is notorious for product and feature churn; being one of their paying customers is exceptionally frustrating as you're basically at the mercy of the Product Management's whims when it comes to features in the product. (Either having them added or removed) No one is denying that other products have a similar issue, but with many other products, you have the option to not update or to stick to a version that meets your needs. With Google, there is no choice. ou Similarly, with their free-in-exchange-for-data products, you can't really count on anything being around that long because it's entirely built in Google's world. Any other standalone product, it works even if the company goes belly-up. Whether or not there are alternatives is kind of irrelevant -- not all alternatives are built equally, not all are cross-compatible for some functionality, migrating out of a product is not always simple, nor is migrating into a product. Google burns good-will with every product they off; the numerous iterations of chat application is a perfect and current example of this, as I don't doubt that there's probably already a new Google chat product in the works in some department that will be pushed out to Android shortly.
- pdonis 8y ago> being one of their paying customers How many of the "large following" of Google Reader were paying customers? As far as I can tell, the answer is basically zero. And that's the problem: Google has no idea how valuable its various apps and services are to their actual users, because the actual users are not the ones paying for them.
- onli 8y agoThat does not really follow, nor is it a good point. A product offered by a company can be a huge part of the web, and if RSS and Google Reader were equivalent it still could've been popular. One can dispute both, saying that it was only known in a small circle even back then, but none of those points speaks to that. > That people are still angry over this shows how out of touch many developers are with the real world / average consumers. I'd rather see it as a lesson on how long developers remember if they feel betrayed by a company. Google Reader + Google Plus real name policy + its integration into Youtube was like a perfect storm to undermine Google's popularity, and then came Snowden. But it began with Google Reader, and I think that is why people remember. PS: Given who the author is I think no one can fault him to give in his reasoning much importance to RSS.
- Kalium 8y agoGoogle Reader was a huge part of the web experience for a small number of rather vocal people. It was a social network for many of them, and they feel like they lost something they built and owned. Myself, I used google reader. But only for RSS. So I just moved to a different reader and I've been fine ever since.
- RIMR 8y agoI guess I just don't see the point of complaining when a company shuts down their own product. It was a free product. It came with no guarantee. Just because you liked it doesn't mean you were entitled to it, and it doesn't mean Google did anything wrong by shuttering it. If you are still using RSS, you need to get with the program. RSS aggregators are out of style for a reason...
- jessaustin 8y agoWhat are you saying? That we should use Atom instead? There is no important difference between the protocols. Or are you saying that we shouldn't use "simple syndication" anymore? Why, so we can let Facebook tell us what to look at? Yeah no thanks.
- Kalium 8y agoI believe parent is saying that RSS became something publishers publishers did not prefer to Twitter, Facebook, and real-time search. Simple syndication might be preferable to users, but it is not for publishers.
- jessaustin 8y agoSure, but I don't see how that's a criticism of RSS? "Nobody uses it because users prefer it!" Besides it still drives e.g. podcasting; apparently those publishers are still making money.
- Kalium 8y ago
- iuguy 8y agoLets look at technologies Google has captured then adversely affected either the adoption or implementation thereof. * Google Reader and RSS * Google Talk and Jabber * Gmail and self-hosted mail (not exclusively Google, but one of the big mail senders) The post's point was not that this is malicious, it's about what happens in big corporations with big ideas, big roadmaps and big reorgs. The fact that this has happened quite a few times is unsurprising.
- citrablue 8y agoI disagree on the third point. It was spam and scams that ruined self-hosted email. Gmail (and other large providers) became the solution to that because the network effects of centralized spam filtering made for an increasingly valuable service to users.
- pasbesoin 8y agoWhich started with their purchase of Postini, IIRC. One of the premier commercial spam identification and filtering services. Checking this, a quick search finds: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postini https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postini Oh, and, perhaps a bit ironically with respect to recent conversation and concerns around Google and its acquisitions: In September 2011, Google announced it would discontinue a number of its products, including Google Web Security, which was acquired by Google as part of Postini.[7] On August 21, 2012, Google announced it would be shutting down all of Postini's web services and folding the service's users into Google Apps. I recall that, but it was no longer in my conscious memory.
- cwyers 8y agoHow did Google adversely affect Jabber?
- iuguy 8y agoThey implemented Google Talk, which was fantastic and opened it up to the world with XMPP support, again, fantastic. Implemented Jabber federation which again was great. One of Google's stated goals was interoperability[1]. Because of this a lot of people moved from running their own Jabber servers to Gtalk. Google then started to add non-standard extensions[2] and in 2014 dropped all interoperability in favour of Google Hangouts integration, meaning that with a Gtalk account you could no longer talk to Jabber accounts. If this was Microsoft, the term that would be used would be Embrace, Extend, Extinguish, but it's probably more along th lines of team reorgs and changes in strategy. Google claimed trouble with spam XMPP federation, but this[3] article sums up some of the feelings at the time, and it's more likely that with a bunch of different products Google needed to consolidate efforts and the new team had different prioritie (like hangouts and wave at the time). [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Talk#History_of_interoperability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Talk#History_of_interop... [2] - https://developers.google.com/talk/jep_extensions/extensions https://developers.google.com/talk/jep_extensions/extensions [3] - https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-moves-away-from-the-xmpp-open-messaging-standard/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-moves-away-from-the-xmp...
- yesiamyourdad 8y agoBeg to differ. The RSS Reader landscape had many, many competitors, then Twitter happened and Facebook opened up to non .edu domains. And then Google Reader happened. RSS wasn't even the point. RSS as a standard is still in use. It's just that we've come to a point where it's a battle of platforms, and platforms mean money. Do you use Facebook, or Twitter, or IG, or Snapchat? I'd still like a unified experience, but none of those companies want to be a party to it. They want to take as much of the pie as they can get.
- ucaetano 8y ago> once Google has control of the web How does this even make sense? This is like saying "Once flying squirrels take control of the government...". Sure, a government controlled by flying squirrels is something scary. But that doesn't make any sense. You should be scared of walled gardens displacing the web.
- siteshwar 8y ago> How does this even make sense ? Google is highly influential in how information is consumed and distributed. People use chrome to browse web, google search for searching information etc. If they have major control over how information is distributed, they have major control over the web. Ofcourse there are other similar services that are not provided by Google, but they are very less influential due to lack of users. > You should be scared of walled gardens displacing the web. What if web becomes a walled garden ? Look at what Google did with DRM[1], even Mozilla had to give up their efforts to fight against it[2]. How could that be possible without having a major influence over the web ? [1] https://boingboing.net/2017/01/30/google-quietly-makes-optiona.html https://boingboing.net/2017/01/30/google-quietly-makes-optio... [2] https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2014/05/14/drm-and-the-challenge-of-serving-users/ https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2014/05/14/drm-and-the-challen...
- ucaetano 8y agoNone of that equals "having control of the web". > What if web becomes a walled garden ? That, again, doesn't even make sense. A walled garden isn't "you need to pay to access my content". A walled garden is "you can only access my content". Apple is a walled garden. Facebook is a walled garden. The web, by definition, isn't a walled garden. And that's why Apple and Facebook kinda hate the web.
- milcron 8y agoNot to mention AMP on every news site, and Google Analytics on nearly every page.
- cirgue 8y agoGoogle is absolutely central to the overwhelming majority of the user experience of the internet in the US. From the perspective of most consumers, Google already does control the internet.
- sarcasmic 8y agoCombine this with yesterday's ill-received-on-HN 'HTTPS Anti-Vaxxers; dispelling common arguments against securing the web' [1], where Scott Helme calls out Dave Winer on his past articles that bemoan the effects of browser-makers' push towards HTTPS. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17287877 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17287877
- mudil 8y agoAs a small publisher since 2004, every day for 14 years, I am sick and tired of Google's serfdom. Their monopoly on ads, their Panda updates, etc etc, do not respect anyone else, but Google's interests. They will make internet into a strip mall like entity with the same boring list of players, the monotonous list of websites, all for their own profit and monopoly. Internet is supposed to be about the content, ideas, journalism, etc. But there is virtually no VC investment in the content. Nothing. That is scary, and Google is single handedly responsible for it.
- lallysingh 8y agoIf you can reach your customers yourself, instead of Google sending them your way, why care about Google at all?
- mudil 8y agoBecause when you live in a serfdom, you are a serf. It's just the system we have under the Google's monopoly. And the system defines what you are able to achieve. See here: medgadget.com/google
- njarboe 8y agoWe need a micropayment system so I can donate a dime or a dollar to an article or info site I like. Seems like something the US government should do to improve peoples lives and promote commerce. They are the controllers of the US dollar after all. Then someone needs to set up a search engine that has the option of only returning sites that are controlled by an individual person, not a corp or non-profit or other group. I would be interesting to see how that might work.
- makz 8y agoThe bitcoin cash guys are tying to do that. https://www.moneybutton.com https://www.moneybutton.com https://www.yours.org https://www.yours.org
- ucaetano 8y ago
- donatj 8y agoI find this guys fears potentially coming from a place of fundamental misunderstanding. Personally I far more fear Amazon's literal control of the web and the monoculture they've created. For us personally moving off of AWS would be a nightmare.
- dsr_ 8y agoPerhaps you should be making plans to be multiplatformable now?
- iaml 8y agoThere is software like terraform that allows to abstract away the differences in cloud providers exactly for this reason.
- jessaustin 8y agoAt this point I'm happy to do business with AWS to sustain it as a counterweight to Google and Facebook. Amazon are fairly evil to their employees and suppliers, but thus far they haven't done evil to their customers in the way that the other two have.
- fjabre 8y agoYou should fear ATT & Verizon much much more.
- bitmapbrother 8y agoMy favorites are the ones that never knew Google Reader existed, but use it as a martyr every chance they get. >My fear is this -- once Google has control of the web, they can turn off huge parts of it for whatever reason, however thoughtless, and without disclosing why. This person has either been watching too many movies that depict the web as a place where IP's can be traced by writing Visual Basic GUI's or doesn't understand how the Internet works.
- matwood 8y agoFor many people the web is google. If google drops a site out of search it is effectively turned off for many people. Another point that he has been harping on is that lots of sites do not need https, but Chrome will shortly warn on visiting those sites. It stands to reason some future version of Chrome will block those sites outright. There are parts of the internet that could disappear when that happens. You may not necessarily agree with his doomsday scenarios, but I assure you Dave Winer[1] understands how the internet works. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dave_Winer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dave_Winer
- filleduchaos 8y agoThere is no site I know of - or to be more accurate, there is no user of an internet application I know of - that does not need transport-layer security.
- jessaustin 8y agoI don't need it when I'm reading sports stories, when I'm researching a technical topic of interest, or when I'm reading out-of-copyright literature. If someone else does need it when doing the exact same things, that's fine, but my unsecured reading does not impose a cost on them.
- filleduchaos 8y agoCorrection - you think you don't need it when you're reading those things, which indicates a serious misunderstanding of HTTPS' problem domain. Unless what you're trying to say is that you're totally fine with third parties (governments, ISPs, the person whose WiFi you're connected to, some random script kiddie): - snooping on your browsing habits (you can intercept and read off an entire HTTP request plain as day, including headers such as User-Agent strings, the specific URL that's being visited, etc, allowing you to build a profile of/digitally fingerprint the unsuspecting user; these are encrypted in an HTTPS request) - maliciously handling your requests, returning whatever response they please instead of forwarding it to the intended remote, allowing them to not just censor the content but straight-up lie to you without your knowledge - tampering with responses - injecting a cryptominer, tracker, script that adds your computer to a botnet or other malicious/non-benevolent script into the response before it reaches you or even just fucking around with the CSS or throwing in porn for the lulz
- sofaofthedamned 8y agoIsn't this the guy that got a bone-on about https ranking higher on Google Search? Edit: Yes, yes it is http://scripting.com/2014/08/08/myBlogDoesntNeedHttps.html http://scripting.com/2014/08/08/myBlogDoesntNeedHttps.html
- microdrum 8y ago"[Google] talks to me like I have no idea how tech companies work internally, but I do. After the next reorg they won't remember any commitments the previous management made." OMG this is so true in our experience. Google doesn't quite lie, but they come very close. They are always changing people and policies, always in a downward direction. Makes me think they won't be around for much longer. They're just maximizing a monopoly, and everything they do reinforces that view.
- ryanisnan 8y agoI don't prefer to share whether or not I agree or disagree with your opinion on whether or not google lies or almost lies, but... Google is very healthy among many axes. Sadly, I don't think truth or honesty are as potent motivators as ubiquity and convenience. This all to say, Google will be around for a long while.
- rhizome 8y agoGoogle doesn't quite lie, but they come very close. The telltale sign for this is a lack of true commitment in their statements. It only counts when they draw a line in the sand.
- pwinnski 8y agoPeople are going to dismiss Dave Winer as a crank right up until the day they or one of the things on which they rely get "googled," and then they will wish they'd listened sooner. Google's power over the web today, already, is not healthy. There are a lot of people within Google who care deeply about the free and open web, and a lot of people who don't, or who define "free" or "open" in ways that involving trusting a for-profit corporation more than anybody wise ever should. Many people get upset when they see Google being attacked, because the part of Google they depend on is a part that really supports the free and open web, or because they themselves don't value the freeness and openness as much as they should. Google delivers a lot of value right now, and without people pushing back, hard, that value will enable them to get away with anything. Anybody who has been around long enough ought to understand that power you grant to someone you trust inevitably ends up in the hands of someone you don't. Political parties switch back and forth, CEOs and corporate priorities come and go. Sometimes it's best to accept an option that is second-best today in order to avoid giving too much power to the organization providing the first-best for them to misuse tomorrow.
- fredgrott 8y agoBUT, Google does not have exactly ultimate power hat DW implies..ever here of Facebook? how about other content social players?
- dnomad 8y ago> Google delivers a lot of value right now, and without people pushing back, hard, that value will enable them to get away with anything. So the more Google does for the web the more dangerous they become. Should Google then start fighting the open web? Would that make the web... better?
- quanticle 8y agoI agree that Google has far too much control over the web. However, this is a silly reason to argue against HTTPS. HTTPS is an open standard. Google doesn't control it. HTTPS doesn't require anyone to use any Google product. You can use HTTPS just fine by getting your certificates from LetsEncrypt and browsing with Mozilla Firefox. Or Microsoft Edge. Or Internet Explorer. Moreover, the security guarantees that HTTPS brings to the web benefit everyone, not just Google. More generally, Dave Winer seems to have an attitude of reflexively opposing everything that Google advocates, merely because it is Google that is advocating for it. It reminds me of the late 90's and early 2000's when open-source people talked about "M$" and reflexively opposed everything that Microsoft did merely because it was Microsoft that was doing it, leaving aside technical merits or other considerations. Corporations are neither pure good, nor pure evil. They are collections of people with collective interests that they pursue. Sometimes, like in the case of HTTPS, or net neutrality, those interests align with our interests as developers and users. In those cases, we should ally ourselves with corporations and use their leverage to effect change more quickly. In other cases, such as with RSS, and vendor lock-in, our interests diverge and we should oppose them with all our might so that we don't lose the free and open Internet that we've become accustomed to. In both cases, however, we should examine the issue on the merits of that issue, and neither support nor oppose merely because the "right" or "wrong" organization is pushing for it.
- deklerk 8y ago> but capturing RSS and then shutting it off ... what? Ultra, ultra hyperbole much? I get it, shutting down reader sucked, but seriously you can literally use any RSS reader to read feeds. Google didn't "kill RSS". Seriously, voicing opinions is one thing but fear mongering and hyperbole is another and this article leans far too heavily towards the latter.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- aeorgnoieang 8y agoI stopped following the author's site many years ago because I found myself too angry too often at the things he writes.
- Clubber 8y agoI'm not a big RSS guy, but when I read an article on that before, what I understand happened is: 1. RSS readers everywhere 2. Google comes out with one 3. Other RSS readers wither on the vine b/c everyone uses #2 4. Google decides to sunset their RSS reader. 5. ??? Is that wrong?
- deklerk 8y agoYep, not what happened. Google didn't make one; they acquired one. Google sunset that reader (I'll agree that in retrospect it was the wrong move, but regardless), but at no point did RSS readers stop existing. Two notes: - RSS readers are _dead simple_ to build. If you're an average programmer you could make an MVP within 2 days. - Many of the RSS readers are/were free. I don't think Google having Reader caused any great migrations, but even if it did I doubt it would have caused other readers to implode or anything like that. I _believe_ what happened is that Reader had a small but vocal user group who were (understandably) upset at the sunsetting, and caused a big hubbub about it. I _suspect_ many of today's Reader complainers have never actually used Reader, and are just piggy-backing off some low-hanging Google bashing fruit. Again, I'll happily nod at the badness of Google killing off Reader, but I intensely dislike the amount of hyperbole in the statement that Google "killed RSS". It's a thing that never took off. That's all that happened. It's still accessible, there are many clients you could use, and so on - it just so happens that most sites don't bother creating an RSS feed.
- dnomad 8y agoIt's a bit remarkable how quickly this sort conspiratorial thinking feeds on itself. The victim constructs a paranoid fantasy where a single company can "turn off huge parts" of the web. This is silly in itself but what's interesting is how the fantasy completely diverges from reality. Here the simple reality is Google single-handedly saved the web by introducing a browser, Chrome, that actually implemented web standards faithfully and made the web performant. And this is just one contribution: on the whole, including everything from web fonts to HTTP/2 to Android's support for the web... and it's clear that no other single entity has done more for the web than Google. But note the dynamic where the truth reinforces the paranoid fantasy. Every single contribution now becomes just more proof that Google controls the web and will shut it down!
- bronlund 8y agoI'm a bit tired of the fear that Google or Facebook or whatever will ruin the internet when the solution is so simple. Just stop clicking on the freaking ads already!
- codingowl 8y agoLike most IT guys, I block everything possible: cookies (whitelist), CSS history, ads, beacons, tracking of all sorts, http/s referrer, webrtc, browser fingerprinting, DNS prefetch, and much more, passing all of this through a personally-controlled remote non-US VPN that logs absolutely nothing. Ads? What ads? I pass all traffic through this, including mobile devices, so protection even when away from home. Is it 100% foolproof? No. But I have yet to have issues, and Google and others have zero profiles on me, as I have no accounts with them or Facebook, et al. It's nice to be able to be relatively off-the-grid while still taking advantage of what the Internet has to offer.
- systematical 8y agoLook at what happened with Google Maps recently. Was pretty cheap to use, people flocked to it. Then they changed prices. We went from never worrying about paying since we have a relatively small amount of traffic, to scrambling to reduce our usage. Now it is their product, they can do what they want with it, but how many sites are pretty locked into Google Maps? This seems to be what Google does. They either kill off a free service that people relied on or begin charging lots of money.
- kanox 8y agoNon-web person here: No idea that Google Maps costs money for anyone, assumed it was ad-supported like anything else.
- systematical 8y agoIt was a thing on here just over a month ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16980166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16980166 I think the service used to only really impact medium-to-big sites, but the price change basically impacts any site. After 25,000 map loads (page hits) you start incurring some substantial fees.
- spadros 8y agoWell, in this case it's if you want to use their API to show maps in your application. If you're doing that, you're going to need to pay them in terms of total requests to their backend. Their B2B service and advertising probably funds the normal consumer app (ie just logging onto 'maps.google.com' to find your local coffee shop).
- systematical 8y agoI think they gave us 2 months, which isn't really enough time to adequately look at alternatives given all the other things going on in an organization. Had we had more time I probably would have looked at doing our own implementation using leaflet and Open Street Map. But that is a pretty big project to throw in when are in the middle of a year long roadmap. I assume this played into Googles strategy. Give them enough of a heads up, but not enough time for most to move away.
- lev99 8y agoGoogle doesn't have any significant control over the web. Google wins big in two categories. Search and Ad Revenue. Google Search processes 2/3-3/4 of all searches, with declining market share. Search is held hostage by user's expectations, if the quality of search were to decline users would leave. AdSense is in a commanding position, but it is under attack from a lot of different directions. Facebook gives more targeted ads. Snap allows more qualified ads. Apple is revamping it's ad system. Google is in a strong position, but this isn't a case of them gaining more control, and their power is defiantly under check by other interests.
- cpeterso 8y agoGoogle has significant control of how people access the web with web browsers (Chrome), email (Gmail), video (YouTube), user authentication, and mobile operating systems (Android and ChromeOS).
- crazygringo 8y ago> "once Google has control of the web, they can turn off huge parts of it for whatever reason..." What does "turn off" even mean? Following the links, it looks like the author is opposed specifically to Chrome pushing sites to migrate from HTTP to HTTPS, mainly because he claims "the web is a social agreement not to break things" and "we will lose a lot of sites that were quickly posted on a whim, over the 25 years the web has existed." This is hard for me to get on board with. Standards evolve and improve because major players push them. We don't use floppy disks anymore either. HTTPS provides desperately needed privacy and integrity guarantees. And archive.org continues to make historical sites available -- over HTTPS even if the original wasn't.
- kevingadd 8y agoWell, for one example, Google basically shut off audio for the entire web a while back and panicked and reverted it once people angrily pointed out they had messed up. Given their willingness to destroy swathes of old content (just like killing - for good reason, at least - all existing Flash and Unity content permanently) it's not hard to imagine them disabling HTTP permanently in Chrome, with exceptions for enterprise LTS builds if you have group policies. Typically Google justifies these decisions to kill portions of the web with "security" and/or "user experience", and it's easy to use both of those reasons to justify disabling HTTP forever. You can remove the 'secure' indicator!
- Fnoord 8y ago> What does "turn off" even mean Google is dominant in search engine (Google Search), advertising (via profiling and Doubleclick etc), e-mail (Gmail), mobile (Android), and in browser (Chrome). There are alternatives, but they are dominant. Though perhaps Android is the worst example due to iOS there's basically two choices you got: apple juice or robot oil. The fear is that Google -consciously or not- abuses its position to leverage another, under the guise of "doing good". They did embrace & extend with Google Reader (which is, by its very definition, proprietary software). They may do something similar with e.g. AMP or HTTP(s). If it isn't already happening. Heck, Android is more and more restrictive with each release.
- post_break 8y ago
- tomcam 8y ago> My fear is this -- once Google has control of the web, they can turn off huge parts of it for whatever reason Ask Dennis Prager, Steven Crowder, Philip DeFranco. This is old news, not a vague fear > It's like when we change administrations in Washington. Very chaotic Not at all the same. In the USA, we have a baseline of actions the government cannot take: it is described in the Constitution and contains a well defined appeals process, as well as a large set of tools to protect against tyranny. Google offers its users and even its paying paying clients none of these privileges.
- staunch 8y ago"The more you tighten your grip, the more star systems will slip through your fingers." Google is headed for a total crash on its current trajectory. Almost the entire business is built on an anti-user model. At some point there will be a reckoning. Their end will be triggered by technology trend that they will be unable to compete with. The solution to fixing Google is funding more startups with ideas on how to take them out. Google's weapon here is keeping tens of thousands of good technology people locked up with golden hand cuffs. That and strangling startups in their cradle. Microsoft's broken model got destroyed and so will Google's. It takes a long time for these slow motion train wrecks to play out.
- tw1010 8y agoRSS didn't die because of Google. Other services took over once Google Reader shut down. The same will happen when Google cuts off other arms of the octopus.
- JoshMnem 8y agoThe post should also mention AMP (E.E.E. for HTML) and Material Design animations (which appear to be applied to sites during rendering in Chrome, even when the sites don't use Material Design).
- itchynosedev 8y ago> Material Design animations (which appear to be applied to sites during rendering in Chrome, even when the sites don't use Material Design) Can you support this claim with examples?
- swframe2 8y agoSlightly off-topic... From The China Hustle, Dirty Money, and The Big Short, it is clear people are putting a lot of trust in the "free market" across the board. Society seems convinced that abusive behavior is acceptable collateral damage required for "free markets" to work; that accepting white collar crime is better than regulating a big company; giving a $1B fine to a company that made $40B in profits is punishment enough to keep companies honest. It is not clear there is a better way...
- cautionarytale 8y agoRemember, power corrupts. If you're not worried about Google's power, you're probably not paying attention.
- RIMR 8y agoOkay, I'm not even going to finish reading this drivel... Using the closure of Google Reader as an example of how Google could "turn off huge parts of web" is ridiculous. Google reader was just a web-based RSS reader. Its user base was dwindling because RSS was falling out of fashion. Google alerted users well ahead of time of the closure, and gave users ample opportunity to move their subscriptions to another RSS aggregator. Closing their own service is not a big deal. It's wasn't the first service Google has shuttered, nor will it be the last. Every company does this to services that no longer benefit the company. No data was removed from the web. No functionality was destroyed. The Google Reader source code was made available to the public. Competing services were champing at the bit to replace Google Reader (and didn't succeed, because hardly anyone uses RSS anymore). It seems like Dave Winner suffers from a lack of understanding of how the web works, and an irrational distrust of large corporations.
- ajross 8y agoYeah. I think a lot of people tend to scapegoat Google for the death of openly indexed content, when all they really did was jump ship well after it was clearly dying. I mean, it's true that Google Reader was a better product than the competition, and being free it probably did "suppress" the market for paid readers, leaving an impoverished landscape when they exited. But if RSS was a vibrant technology, would they have killed it? No, they'd have tried to exploit it somehow. But it was going nowhere. Frankly, if you want to point a finger for the death of RSS, blame Facebook and Twitter.
- slrz 8y ago> The Google Reader source code was made available to the public. It was? Where to find it? Please don't tell me it got lost when Google Code shut down.
- JasonFruit 8y agoDave Winer's writing is concise and simple. Somehow, he doesn't sacrifice beauty to achieve that.
- 8bitsrule 8y agoBut next year's roadmap from Google will make the web more like AOL.... And that's saying a mouthful.
- yesiamyourdad 8y agoI read through the comments on here and was reminded of Tim Bray's commentary from almost 15 years ago: https://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/200x/2003/07/12/WebsThePlace https://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/200x/2003/07/12/WebsThePl... "To mangle three metaphors, if you drink that kool-aid, you’re either locked in the trunk like Dave Winer says or if you like my metaphor-ware better, you’re a sharecropper. Either way, it sucks."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- randop 8y agoAll for-profit organizations employ "Boiling frog" [1] strategy depending upon the market, consumers, and as their product goes through evolution. Whether the end-goal of it is for good or not, it's hard to judge. The fear of change expressed on this article is natural. Enforcing HTTPS is good for consumers. But, we need to watch carefully with the market dominance of Google Chrome. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boiling_frog
- msiyer 8y agoThe pursuit of profit kills society. All our social suffering exists because we have been trying to merge two incompatible ideas. We expect our lawyers, doctors, technocrats, politicians... to do the right thing. However, the right thing is almost always detrimental to profits. Profit always trumps "right thing".
- craftoman 8y agoGoogle is just another big corporation with many shareholders from all over the world. They can't control or predict what's upcoming cause technology is shaping rapidly. I've seen companies go bankrupt because of this type of stagnation but I think the major problem of Google is that they dangerously centralizing everything (including open source) and they had privacy concerns in the past so yeah. In terms of innovation, stability, performance, or security I really trust them BUT in terms of privacy, spying and how they handle big data or how they shaping internet I think they will always suck. IMHO if not Google then X would actually have exactly the same plan.
- clarry 8y ago> In terms of innovation, stability, performance, or security I really trust them Just wait till their automated algorithm suddenly (and mistakenly) blocks your account for "suspicious activity." (I've been there) Maybe there is something "innovative" to using such algorithms but I'm not sure it's all good. What's bad though: stability, for you as a user.