5 ms·
It seems a little silly to me that someone would trust a "secure OS" from a situation where one guy could "seize control" of the company and infrastructure. Thi
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
It seems a little silly to me that someone would trust a "secure OS" from a situation where one guy could "seize control" of the company and infrastructure. This is largely why I've never seen third party ROMs as a significant solution to the security situation with mobile phones.
That being said, I'm curious what the other side of this story is. The email makes it sound like the guy's being fired.
- strcat 8y ago> The email makes it sound like the guy's being fired. The person being 'fired' owns 50% of the company and is the CTO and sole developer of the products, with most of it written on their own time. There's no employment / copyright agreement in place with Copperhead.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 18pfsmt 8y agoYou seem like a good guy and principled person, but you should let folks know that you are the developer in question, no?
- nextos 8y agoI disagree, at least to some extent. CopperheadOS is open source. The scripts to build a ROM are open and it's possible to audit them. In fact, if you don't want to pay for COS you are free to build your own image using said scripts. I've done it. It's easy. I think the whole mistake CopperheadOS did was switching to a Creative Commons license that prevented commercial use by third parties. This has effectively made it tricky for Daniel Micay to continue his great work on CopperheadOS elsewhere once the company imploded. It's sad, because it's IMHO the very best ROM out there. I don't want to use anything else. I think they should have gone for a more sustainable business model. In his shoes, I'd restart COS by doing a crowdfunding round and aiming at a few other devices (which may not be hard now with device-agnostic ROMs made possible by Treble). COS has had a reduced target market since Google decided to price Pixel terminals much higher than Nexus. There are rumours that they might release a cheap Pixel to compete with iPhone SE. That might be good for COS.
- craftyguy 8y ago> CopperheadOS is open source. Technically, it is. But, as you pointed out, the license they chose guarantees that it will essentially die out, specifically the bit prohibiting the non-commercial use of it. It's also mildly interesting that Daniel aggressively defended the creative commons license they chose, when challenged.
- Fnoord 8y agoI don't understand this. What exactly is licensed under Creative Commons Non-Commercial? It is either open source, or it isn't. If it is open source (OSI approved), that doesn't prohibit non-commercial work. Because then it wouldn't be OSI approved. Right?
- Dylan16807 8y agoYou don't understand that people might use the words "open source" in a slightly different way than you do?
- Fnoord 8y agoIt isn't "a different way than I do"; its different from both the defacto meaning of the term open source, and it isn't according to OSI. That makes calling such open source deceiving, just like calling shared source open source would be deceiving. Seen enough of that shit to stick to frameworks such as OSI-approved (which is more liberal than FSF or DFSG so it could be even more strict ie. we're being generous).
- Dylan16807 8y ago"shared source" doesn't let you use the code yourself. CC-NC gives you the exact same rights to use/modify/redistribute that you got the code under. The OSI approves licenses with various restrictions on them, such as displaying authorship, or reciprocation, or patent grants. I haven't seen any reason to categorize a noncommercial restriction as fundamentally different. The noncommercial clause is a huge issue because of how vague it is, but that's a different topic entirely. Also, using the OSI list as the ultimate reference isn't appropriate in the first place. They only approve licenses that are designed for software. I think almost everyone would agree that CC-BY and GFDL are open source licenses, despite them not being on that list.
- auslander 8y ago> "secure OS" from a situation where one guy ... Best comment. Security is a probability theory. You rate probabilities of factors and multiply them. Probability of one guy inserting backdoor is much higher than probability of inserted backdoor in iOS or Android, hence, you'd be better off with stock SW. And you'll be sticking out like bamboo tree in midwest, with your 'secure os'
- horsawlarway 8y agoThis is silly. Security is not so much probability theory as it is cost vs benefit. The probability of one guy inserting a backdoor is high, but the payoff for compromising his platform is incredibly low. The probability of compromising one of the big two - android/ios - may be low (keyword: may. It turns out large groups are also made up of lots of "one guy"s) but the payoff is huge.
- auslander 8y ago> probability of compromising one of the big two - android/ios - may be low - payoff is huge. Whats your point? My point is that it takes nation state to do that.
- esrauch 8y agoIt takes a nation-state to do it and nation-states have an interest in doing so. Copperhead maybe could be comprised in the short term by just any thug with a led pipe making threats but those thugs have much softer targets than that so why would they?
- auslander 8y ago> the payoff for compromising his platform is incredibly low True, but price of the compromise is low as well. Scratch that. All it takes is to hack this one guy, i can do that :)
- acct1771 8y agoVisiting the HN website is pretty "sore thumb", I wouldn't skip a secure OS for that reason. We should just ALLL choose a secure OS!
- staticassertion 8y agoNo one could seize control of the company, that's the point. The signing keys were wiped - compromise is now impossible through that avenue.