10 ms·
Take that view with a huge grain of salt. Nobody is denying that someone, somewhere is making $400k as a software engineer, but we are talking outlier employees
by ryandrake 8y ago
Take that view with a huge grain of salt. Nobody is denying that someone, somewhere is making $400k as a software engineer, but we are talking outlier employees at outlier companies. You’re not getting this as a medium level rank and file engineer, or at a non-FAANG company. This whole “software engineers make $400k” trope seems to have taken on a life of its own. Every time salary comes up here, these guys come out of the woodwork to tell you that their brother’s girlfriend’s roommate makes $400k at Facebook, therefore it is an average compensation in Silicon Valley. That is far from accurate.
Most startups are not competing for talent that would otherwise be making $400k.
- sidlls 8y agoFine, leave those FAANG "outliers" out. Startup comp is still wildly below market.
- kenhwang 8y agoSome of my most mediocre acquaintances have jobs at FAANG/Big N. You don't have to be exceptional to land a high comp job there, you just have to be exceptionally tolerant to BS and mindnumbingly boring work and be willing to grind interview prep. If anything, landing a job at an unicorn is much harder cause they care about things like culture fit, enthusiasm, esoteric FotM frameworks, and entrepreneurial spirit.
- throwawaymath 8y agoTrading one anecdote for another: I've met plenty of mediocre engineers at unicorns. Every company has its own flavor of BS and "mindnumbingly boring work."
- kenhwang 8y agoI have a friend that I consider borderline incompetent. He works for an unicorn. He claims he makes up for it in spirit in charisma. Point is, compensation and skill don't correlate as strongly as people think.
- hello_moto 8y agoThere's a group (Dropbox, Airbnb, LinkedIN, Splunk, etc) between FAANG and Startups and this group pay really well too. I heard Oracle OCI also pays in the 300-400k range (even for Seattle).
- sidlls 8y agoYep, and that's my point: startup compensation is below market even for average, not well known companies.
- dmode 8y agoFAANG + Microsoft + Uber + Airbnb hire thousands and thousands of engineers in the Valley and Seattle every year. 400K is L5-L6 salary (senior engineer, first level manager). There are a TON of engineers making that money. They are not really outliers, and FAANGMUA is also not really outlier considering Google itself has 80K employees and Amazon and MSFT have over 200K employees.
- diminoten 8y agoI think you guys are agreeing with each other, right? L5-L6 isn't "average", is it? Most FAANGMUA employees are not managers/senior engineers.
- CryoLogic 8y ago400k is an outlier for sr engineer or 1st level manager. Most all of them fall into 200-300/yr in the valley or Seattle at those companies.
- dunpeal 8y ago400k is not unusual for a senior engineer working at big tech for several years in the Bay, Seattle, NYC, or even a city like LA. Base salary will be around 200K, and bonus would be another 200K. Can easily be 50-100K more than that on some years. Outlier would be 750K or more, which means the engineer is one of the most valuable members of the team.
- praptak 8y agoStartups require crazy hours and solid dedication. If you put that into a career at a big software company, even with average talent, you will reach the level which yields that kind of money.
- pm90 8y agoNo you absolutely won't, unless you luck out and end up on a good team. Big companies are notoriously bad about rewarding hard working and talented engineers. That is in fact one of the main reasons people leave them (including yours truly).
- Cofike 8y agoIf startups don't reward engineers and neither do big companies, then what does?
- cellis 8y agoNothing. In all my years ( 13 ) software engineering, the people who made the most were the ones who could sell. And I don't mean like "sales engineer", but rather who could sell their projects to team members, bosses, etc. Making money really comes down to being able to sell A) actual, i.e. what you've built or B) potential, i.e. what will you build And then to get rich you need a multiplier on those things. But just being a good engineer, in general, does not get richly rewarded. If you show me a pure engineer who makes 1 million, I can show you a founder who made 100x from his work.
- praptak 8y agoSelling own labor in capitalism won't generally get you very rich.
- pm90 8y agoI'm just pointing out that its not absolute. So in general I recommend being open to switching jobs/companies until you find and environment that you personally find enriching, both professionally and financially.
- mathgeek 8y ago> these guys come out of the woodwork to tell you that their brother’s girlfriend’s roommate makes $400k at Facebook Reminds me of grade school, when "my uncle who works at Sega" always had let their loving nephew/niece play that game that wasn't out yet.
- Latteland 8y agoIt's not that amazing. I work at a startup, 300k cash comp, plus probably worthless options :-0.
- jzl 8y ago400 is starting to push into standard deviation territory but 300 (total comp) is absolutely right in the center of the bell curve for a mid-level engineer (not a rock star), from everything I've seen and heard both first and second hand. In the valley, anyway.
- saryant 8y agoThat's where I am. I'm pushing $300k total comp at Twitter as a senior SWE out in Colorado. Before this I was first employee of a startup that eventually sold to Google. Even if I'd stuck around for the acquisition I'd have gotten $0 from my stock options—employee options were wiped out completely. Why put up with that bullshit when a big publicly-traded company will reliably deposit large sums of money into my bank account every quarter and I don't have to work crazy hours?
- brendonjohn 8y agoSpeaking as someone that has stock options... how did your employee options get wiped out?
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoThe usual way is that all the investors, who hold preferred stock, get paid before all the employees, who hold common stock. If there's not any money left over after the preferred holders get paid, the value of employee equity is 0.
- tayo42 8y agohow did you get that much? Hired as senior with a lot of rsu? is it mostly rsu after the jump the last few weeks? If I got to senior I wouldn't be making that much based off what Im being told about comp increases. I must have gotten a shit deal when I joined lol
- saryant 8y agoI worked here during the years when the stock was in the toilet and managed to get some retention grants that have turned into a tidy sum. Plus I joined as a SWE1 so there are two promos in there.
- colordrops 8y agoMaybe I'm in a bubble but everyone around me is making at least 400k total comp. Doesn't seem that uncommon in California.
- jensvdh 8y agoBut if you work at Uber/Airbnb/Whatever out of that 400k total comp 250k is just paper money.
- colordrops 8y agonaw, the people I know work at netflix, apple, amazon, google, spacex, microsoft, tesla, etc
- freyir 8y agoFrom what I’ve heard, SpaceX pays pretty poorly. Extremely long hours for below-average aerospace salary. Surprised to see you mention them, but maybe they’ve improved lately.
- seattle_spring 8y agoNot really... If you have 250k / yr equity, your salary (plus bonus) is usually north of 200k at those companies.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- netheril96 8y agoBut successful exit of a startup is also outlier. It is only fair if we compare outliers to outliers.
- pfarnsworth 8y agoYou literally have no idea what you're talking about. Every one of my friends who is a senior software engineer, including myself, at a decent-sized company has a total compensation between $300-400k per year. One of my good friends has a total comp of $650k, with almost $300k base salary. I have friends at Facebook, Google, Uber, Airbnb, Apple, etc. We all share compensation information with each other. My friend at a startup is ready to quit because he's only paid $170k for the last 5 years and he regrets not staying at Apple because the shares he left on the table were worth over $1M now. He is now 0/2 in startups, both of which you have heard of, and he's very frustrated.
- chambo622 8y agoWhere does your friend with $650k TC work and what is their role/level?
- pfarnsworth 8y agoFANG, L6-equivalent level.
- kentonv 8y ago> Most startups are not competing for talent that would otherwise be making $400k. But why not? Obviously you shouldn't only hire $400k-TC engineers. But if you're going to hire a team of 5-10, wouldn't it make sense to hire at least one more-senior engineer to help lead and mentor the more-junior ones? When I was an early-stage startup founder, I was told by various advisers* that $150k should be the absolute upper limit on engineer salaries, and that I should try to talk engineers down to $110k or even sub-$100k by selling them on the "vision". I was told I should make up the difference in equity, but also that I shouldn't give an employee more than 1% in equity or maybe 2% for a "rockstar". Do the math here. A company raises a typical seed round at $6M valuation cap, and is offering 2% over four years (considered VERY generous!). Even if we pretended that was preferred stock rather than common, it's worth $30k/yr. So you're trying to hire senior engineers while offering less than half their previous total compensation. What ends up happening is you hire people straight out of college or away from other startups. But you cannot hire a senior Google engineer. In my opinion, a tech-oriented startup should plan that exactly one of their first 5-10 engineers should be a senior engineer for whom they offer a salary of $200k-$250k and equity of 3-5%. Aim to poach an L6 from Google with this offer. (But only hire one such engineer early on. A team with too many senior engineers can be even worse than a team with none.) Or alternatively, make sure one of your co-founders is such an engineer and is able to focus their time entirely on engineering, not other founder duties. * Advisers all say different things, often contradictory. It's probably best not to listen to them, TBH. Yes, that advice applies to this comment as well, and even this footnote. Have fun.
- zuhayeer 8y agodepends on level / YoE most of the time, theres breakdown for FAANG companies at http://levels.fyi http://levels.fyi