4 ms·
I’m not sure optionality is the problem so much as they didn’t NEED to combine three things into one. If USB-C has video and USB it would be pretty great. Vide
by MBCook 8y ago
I’m not sure optionality is the problem so much as they didn’t NEED to combine three things into one.
If USB-C has video and USB it would be pretty great. Video could be optional but that’s easy enough.
But Thunderbolt is a HUGE complication. It should have used some other connector and then this stuff would be easy enough to figure out but you’d still get plenty of benefit.
Of course TB already used the Mini-DP connector, so that would have made video out a mess. And it was too late to fix that.
And leaving all three separate is it’s own mess.
I’m not sure there was a good solution at this point. Which seems like a lack of planning.
- jrockway 8y agoA more aggressive re-imagining of how peripherals interoperate is probably what needs to happen. Having a cable and connectors just be some differential pairs is perfect for pretty much everything, that's how PCIE, DisplayPort, USB 3.0, Ethernet, etc. all work with their own special details. The problem is how computers are built. PCIE is expected to be contained inside the computer, and fully trusted. Video data for monitors is just binary data flowing along the differential pairs, but the only place on the computer that can produce that data is the video card, which has no way to send that data anywhere but a physical port on the video card. Thunderbolt 3 is just some PCIE lanes with some security/authentication on it. So in the end, it's perfectly reasonable to have One True cable/port that delivers power and data over some differential pairs. The problem is cost and legacy. If we have one power delivery spec that can power a giant TV, it will be too expensive to make a cell phone charger with the same port type just to charge a phone. Similarly, nobody is going to buy a new monitor that uses our new interconnection method when HDMI and DisplayPort are good enough. (People should be alarmed that most monitors come with both HDMI and DisplayPort ports... they do the same thing, but society could not decide on just one, so we pay for two protocols every time we buy a monitor or video card.) USB Type-C tried to fix both of these problems by just reusing the old protocols and being flexible about power... but it's too confusing for users. The old system of one port doing one thing was much easier to understand. Nobody ever tried to connect their hard drive to their monitor... until Thunderbolt came out and made that physically (but not logically) possible. For that reason, I don't see a solution.