3 ms·
Why is it that the US women are consistently the best in the world, and US men are consistently middling? Do women in other countries just not play as much socc
by oh_sigh 8y ago
Why is it that the US women are consistently the best in the world, and US men are consistently middling? Do women in other countries just not play as much soccer as US women?
- megaman22 8y agoThe best US male athletes play more lucrative and entertaining sports.
- lordnacho 8y agoOne thing that probably makes a difference is there are a number of other sports drawing the young male athletes in the US. (American) Football, Baseball, Hockey, Basketball. If you look at the countries that tend to be good at football, the main sport everyone cares about is football. So why do the women do so well? It's well funded, and it's more of a contender among the sports for women.
- mmsimanga 8y agoI can speak for South Africa and Zimbabwe. Anecdotally based on everyone I grew with and went to university with. Most women give up sport the moment they leave high school. Only a handful of sports are professional. Women's soccer is not professional. As a result, both men and women tend to focus on studies and work. Logistically in your early career, it is also difficult to play sport. Getting lifts to and from practice when you don't have a car is a nightmare, buying kit and footing your own travel expenses to matches. The men continue to play sport on a social level right up to their 40s. I gather in the US women get soccer scholarships. It doesn't happen this side of the world.
- MisterBastahrd 8y agoWomens' soccer gets the US' best athletes. There are plenty of stadiums open on Friday nights with 10-30K fans watching boys play American football. You would be lucky get get 100 to watch soccer.
- poulsbohemian 8y agoTrue at the local level, but go attend a PDX Timbers or Seattle Sounders match - eventually that excitement will trickle down.
- ghaff 8y ago>Womens' soccer gets the US' best athletes. I'm not sure I agree with that. US women do well at the international level in a fair number of sports. But it's probably true that women in the US are more likely to seriously play soccer growing up, including at the collegiate level, than women in other countries are. And, of course, the US Women's national basketball team is utterly dominant. Though given the relative popularity of basketball in the US compared to other major countries, that's not exactly a fair comparison.
- Brakenshire 8y agoI’d say, women’s football has not been a well funded or highly persued sport in most countries until relatively recently, for instance in Britain women used to play different sports, hockey, netball, tennis far more. Likewise men’s hockey used to be quite rare here, but is more popular now.
- diegof79 8y agoI live in Argentina. Based on what I see from movies, news, and TV series from the US. It seems that in the US football (soccer) is considered a game usually played by girls. Here in Argentina, it's a different story. Until the last years, football was considered a men's only game (and still is for many). If your daughter wants to play football, you don't have teams or football schools to send her. So girls usually have more options to learn volleyball, field hockey, or handball. Fortunately, that started to change. However, the professional football league is still men's only. There is a women's league, but it has zero presence on media. The media sponsorship have a lot of influence on how professional teams develop, that could explain why the US women team performs better compared to other countries where football is still limited to men (that includes most of the Latin American countries, and probably Europe too).
- ghaff 8y agoI don't think it's that soccer is really seen as just a girl's game in the US. But there are major US sports, notably American football but also baseball (women mostly play softball) and, to a lesser degree, ice hockey that women largely don't play. As a result, although boys/men play soccer, they're more likely to spend their time playing something else.
- sonnyblarney 8y ago"Do women in other countries just not play as much soccer as US women?" Basically, yes. Women don't generally play that many sports in most countries. Even in W. Europe, surprisingly not a lot of football. There are some exceptions here and there: skiing in Austria and XCountry skiing in Scandinavia ... The issue with US soccer is mostly the anomaly of the fact there are other, way bigger sports like US football, basketball etc. that people focus on. Even in hockey - Sweden, Czech, Russia - with great men's teams ... their women's team are not good and it's all Canada vs. USA in that sport for women. That said ... it's still weird that the US cannot field a competent team. I mean there are 300 million Americans, a lot of central/south American types, tons of cash, a deep field for most sports. It is a little odd.
- VeejayRampay 8y agoThe women team dominates physically and tactically (physical preparation is advanced in the US, it's true for all sports) but the mens team is simply too technically limited to achieve greatness at international level. Despite the result, it was blatant in the latest France - USA, the technical gap between the two teams was HUGE.
- dustincoates 8y agoThe technical gap between the two is certainly large, but the US side had an average age of less that 22.5 and the French were preparing for the World Cup. I wouldn't read too much into this—or any—friendly where the goals of the two sides are so different.