6 ms·
Simply taxing gains as ordinary income is often unfair because it taxes stuff going up in nominal terms without actually being worth more in real terms. You can
by tim333 8y ago
Simply taxing gains as ordinary income is often unfair because it taxes stuff going up in nominal terms without actually being worth more in real terms. You can get around this by indexing for inflation, which gets complicated, or taxing it at a lower rate. Carried interest isn't really capital gains - it's income and should be taxed as that.
The deeper problem is if there is some way to reform the political system to be less easily bought.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoIsn't that how income tax works too? Why should cap gains be different?
- bawse1 8y agoIncome tax is based on income earned, capital gains is based on a sale of a asset. There is definitely a difference.
- chii 8y ago> Income tax is based on income earned, capital gains is based on a sale of a asset. but couldn't you claim that income is sale of personal time (an infinitely valuable, and non-renewable asset)?
- fleetingmoments 8y agoIf your personal time is infinitely valuable to yourself, why do you sell for way below that?
- beat 8y agoYes, but that doesn't mean they should be taxed differently. You need more justification.
- barry-cotter 8y agoInflation. Inflation is one of the two reasons capital gains should be different. You can make a large profit in nominal terms while making a real loss if inflation is high enough. This is not a risk with non-capital gains income. The real reason capital gains taxes are a bad idea is that they discourage investment and we want more of that because it’s how we increase our productive capacity and get more of what we really want, consumption. We should abolish income and capital gains taxes altogether and tax consumption. Encouraging investment by ceasing to tax it will lead to higher production and consumption in the long run.
- tim333 8y agoSay you buy a house for $1m. You then want to move to an identical house in another location and houses now cost $2m. By moving, on a basic capital gains tax calculation you have a profit of $500k and a tax bill of say $200k. But you don't have $200k and can't move. This not a good situation hence various fixes. That particular problem does not come up with income although there are other problems there. Tax is messy. I'm reminded of the quote from the 1600s "The art of taxation consists in so plucking the goose as to procure the largest quantity of feathers with the least possible amount of hissing." The above problem causes hissing.
- phkahler 8y agoSo provide an exemption for primary residences. There is a similar concern with stock sales causing tax payment, but in that case it's an incentive for longer term investment. You goose quote is really awesome. On a related note, I think we need to stop providing incentives for housing prices to go up. Municipalities could put caps on the percentage of value they'll enforce a lean on. This would reduce housing costs to the benefit of people at the bottom.
- bzbarsky 8y agoThis is a problem for all assets, not just primary residences. > I think we need to stop providing incentives for housing prices to go up. While true, the main such incentive historically is inflation: housing prices have been growing at about the rate of inflation in the long run, averaged over the US.
- sjwright 8y agoIdeally, capital gains tax should be charged on gains above the rate of inflation.
- bzbarsky 8y agoSo that still assumes that saving is risk-free (maybe) and the discount rate people apply to consumption is 0, right? The latter just doesn't match reality. But it would definitely be a step up from where we are now, in theory. In practice, measuring inflation is an interesting exercise; there are multiple measures that differ quite a bit once your timescale is "decades" as it can easily be for savings and housing. And yrs, I know I said "the rate of inflation" -- I forget which measure those studies used. For housing specifically, one could use whichever inflation measure best matched housing prices in the past, I guess...