4 ms·
The point people are making about using GitHub profiles for hiring is that it ignores great developers who don't write code outside of their job (that might be
by onion2k 8y ago
The point people are making about using GitHub profiles for hiring is that it ignores great developers who don't write code outside of their job (that might be due to other interests, family responsibilities, a second job, whatever). The fact this guy is in a position to write code in his spare time just means he's not in that group, and the fact his open source work on Github specifically landed him a job he wanted kind of proves the point people are making.
- sintaxi 8y agoPrivilege is what is UNEARNED and there is no way to qualify if those with open source contributions are more privileged than others. The very opposite could be true. The privileged can bounce from well paying job to the next with no OSS contributions while the underprivileged have to "show their value" in the harsh environment of open source. You're constructing the viewpoint you want others to see with no data or facts to back it up.
- onion2k 8y agoI'm saying that being in a position to have spare time to work on open source is a sign of privilege, and that employers should recognize that when they're hiring. Some great developers work on open source projects, but equally some great developers don't. Open source contributions are not a useful filter.
- sintaxi 8y ago> I'm saying that being in a position to have spare time to work on open source is a sign of privilege That is an assumption made without evidence. An equally qualified assumption would be that its a sign of privilege to not need to contribute to open source. You get an awesome education and go straight into well paying entry level position. Committing to open source is not something casually done at ones leisure. Anything with traction becomes a significant responsibility and it takes an incredible amount of discipline and sacrifice to stay committed.
- rectang 8y agoPeople who have the time to contribute to open source possess a privilege when compared people who do not have the time. It may also be the case that there are other privileges at work, and that if you have two people they both have privileges over each other in different ways. I think it's better to consider privilege as multifaceted rather than a single global quantity. And in that case, I don't see such a strong disagreement between you and the comment you're replying to. I very much agree with your second paragraph.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- blattimwind 8y ago> Open source contributions are not a useful filter. OSS activity is a useful low-effort implicator. As usual for implications, denying the antecedent remains a fallacy.
- watwut 8y agoThe world of open source is alternatively great place full of great people where any bad experience is suspect and alternatively harsh environment. Depending of what political point people want to make. Or maybe there are both friendly and unfriendly projects and a lot depends on where the underprivileged is trying to make it.
- vezycash 8y agoI think a good way to end the debate on Github profiles is this: Github profiles are advertisement for programmers. Advertising requires resources - time, money, creativity and commitment and not every business is ready to pay to price. Sometimes advertising pays off, some times it doesn't. No police arrests a business owner for not advertising. Same with github profiles. Decide to have one, contribute a little, much or nothing at all. It's a matter of preference.
- amelius 8y agoDesigners have portfolios. Would you do them away as "advertisements" as well? They are much more than that, e.g. they show the skills of the designer.
- reitanqild 8y agoIf I read correctly the idea is not to do away with repos but rather not using that as the single signal. Just like you shouldn't exclude any companies just because they don't advertise.
- onion2k 8y agoA lot of designers don't have portfolios.
- rueynshard 8y agoThe key difference is that designers are free to show the work they've done in their current jobs or internships. Programmers usually aren't at liberty to do the same.
- amasad 8y agoSo I mentioned, multiple times, that you shouldn't exclude people that don't have a Github profile. All I'm saying is that if you're underprivileged you have this awesome tool, use it. And no I didn't have a lot of free time. I was working and going to school but when you're young you frankly don't need a whole lot of sleep.
- mverwijs 8y agoIt is the open Internet that levelled the playing field. Of which Github and Open Source are but subsets.
- amasad 8y agoAgreed. However, it was GitHub and not, for example, sourceforge that lowered the barrier to entry for open-source. The open internet is the substrate on which innovation runs.
- BTeam 8y agoLibre software and the open source spirit existed long before Internet. Sure, It was really hard to find projects and contribute to them, but we can do it since the dawn of computer science.
- wool_gather 8y ago> Sure, It was really hard to find projects and contribute to them They also weren't as visible and easily browsable.
- onion2k 8y agowhen you're young you frankly don't need a whole lot of sleep You do if you have health issues, or mental health issues, or kids (some young people have them), or a long commute, or a second job, or if you're not young... It's hard to recognize privilege when you have it.
- amasad 8y ago
- underwater 8y agoI don’t code much in my spare time. I have kids and a busy home life, but really it doesn’t take long to build up a portfolio of work that is representative of your skills. Sharing my work got me, as an Aussie working mediocre jobs, on the right person’s radar to help me land a job at Facebook. This shaved probably 10 years off my career path. That was a great return on investment and a big leveller for someone who didn’t study at a brand name US college and have an obvious path to the door of a major tech company. I’m now in a position to hire others. I certainly don’t mind if someone doesn’t have open source code shared. It clearly not a priority for many people. But I do appreciate when people do have a good backlog of work to show as it can give a seemingly lacklustre candidate a second opportunity to shine.
- willbw 8y agoAs an Aussie with a similar background - what sort of work were you sharing that got you on someone's radar? Your own projects or contributions to someone else's?
- underwater 8y agoThis was pre-GitHub. I shared a resource for frontend developers that went viral. If I wanted to get noticed today I’d be writing libraries around something like React or I would pick a less well known project from a big company and start helping out.
- willbw 8y agoCheers!
- vonmoltke 8y ago> I have kids and a busy home life, but really it doesn’t take long to build up a portfolio of work that is representative of your skills. There are two critical assumptions you are making here: 1) The kind of development you do is conducive to sharing via small projects on GitHub. The first four years of my full-time programing career I was working on firm real-time signal processing algorithms designed to run on an MPI cluster of POWER or Xeon machines. My skills were focused on low-level optimizations for that environment and hardware, design and implementation of grid-distributed algorithms, and understanding how to translate radar concepts and mathematical models into code. Anything along these lines that I could have thrown together for GitHub (had it existed back then) would ave been trivial and not really demonstrated anything. 2) Everyone operates under a regime wherein they do not need permission from their current employer to release things on the side. Needing to do so adds work and can be a real impediment to even wanting to put things out for public consumption.
- vkbandi 8y agoSome companies does not allow employees to write code outside of work, I work in a 50+ Billion company, whose policies clearly state that, you can be fired for writing code even in your free time. We even have a "training" to clear any misunderstandings, It has been conveyed explicitly with past examples of people getting fired.