5 ms·
The key thing seems to be that the automatic breaking system has a group of systems each designed to satisfy multiple constraints and these systems aren't parti
by joe_the_user 8y ago
The key thing seems to be that the automatic breaking system has a group of systems each designed to satisfy multiple constraints and these systems aren't particularly well integrated.
This seems like how I would imagine a "dumb" system would be designed. One would imagine a "artificial intelligence" (of any sort at all) would find a way to smoothly integrate all these system. The problem is end-to-end neural nets or similar devices intended for such integration don't seem ready for prime time.
- Phrodo_00 8y agoI would generally prefer smarter (more error prone) systems to be surrounded by dumber systems. So the break pedal overrides everything, then you'd have a run of the mill radar breaking system, regular lane following system, and only after that (and maybe even further back) the more advanced self driving-ish stuff. It's weird that it isn't designed that way, since that's the way automated systems in factories and the like are setup.
- joe_the_user 8y agoSo the break pedal overrides everything, then you'd have a run of the mill radar breaking system, regular lane following system, and only after that (and maybe even further back) the more advanced self driving-ish stuff The problem the article points out is that there's no safe, dumb response to radar seeing something stopped right in front of a car going 70 mpg. If anything, the systems the article describes are a lot like what you describe - a bunch of semi-separate systems each of which can do something if it can be sure that something is safe and which do nothing otherwise. The problem seems to be that given enough no-easy-answer situations, you wind-up with a false sense of security.
- jstarfish 8y agoWhy does "in case of anomaly or ambiguity, slow the fuck down, gather more data and reassess" never seem to be part of the functional logic with these things?
- other_herbert 8y agoI think it's because at this point they would not be able to move forward at all...