3 ms·
> I would argue that labor is only as free as the social net for unemployed is strong. You're arguing that labor is only free so long as it can hold a gun to s
by adventured 8y ago
> I would argue that labor is only as free as the social net for unemployed is strong.
You're arguing that labor is only free so long as it can hold a gun to someone else's head (the evil 10%) and force them to support said labor via welfare by taking the fruits of the labor that the 10% produce. As though one has an inherent right to someone else's very life and property (if you did, you wouldn't need a gun to steal that property). Communism, because it has worked out so well over the last century.
It's a contradiction. You're actually saying some people get to be 'free' using coercion and overt threats of force, by enslaving other people to fulfill their needs via welfare transfers based on the taxation of other better off persons income.
The system of welfare transfers, much less actual Socialism, requires extreme force to be applied at all times to keep the system functioning, as such there can be no freedom at all - there's always a gun pointed at your head.
- AstralStorm 8y agoWelcome to animal kingdom. The whole prerequisite of welfare is to take excess resources to redistribute. Now who decides what is excess? Definitely not the person who has it and is greedy. So or societies have decided that majority or representative of the majority decided this. Reasonably equitable system, but not exactly colouring or incorruptible.
- dannypgh 8y agoI am not arguing that Communism is free of coersion. I don't think free markets exist, I believe they are an idealized model. I think this is especially true for the labor market. Likewise, I don't believe there are coersion-free societies. But that does not mean I'm willing to overlook some baseline level of coersion as not being coersion at all. Governments (regardless of economic policy) tend to assert a monopoly on the use of violence in an area, and that monopoly on violence means their policies are enforced through coersion.