8 ms·
Whenever a company's phone is answered by an AI, it never does what I ask it to do. At that point I just push 0 and repeat "speak to a human." Why, oh why, wo
by gwbas1c 8y ago
Whenever a company's phone is answered by an AI, it never does what I ask it to do.
At that point I just push 0 and repeat "speak to a human."
Why, oh why, would any rational person think that this kind of technology was about to suddenly take over everything?
This is a typical example of groupthink delusions.
- weiming 8y agoIt's doubly-painful when some of these force you to speak out digits (like an account number) instead of entering them.
- jenscow 8y agowhyyy???! It's not as though the tones are harder to recognise!
- xenomachina 8y ago"Why don't you just tell me the name of the movie you've just selected?" But seriously, it's the same reason so many sites won't accept a credit card number with spaces in it. Someone writing from scratch the same thing that's been written a thousand times, but only thinking about the way they would use it (or the way they were told others would use it).
- lozenge 8y agoIn my experience they always accept dialled numbers.
- epistasis 8y agoOh, if only that had been my experience, I'd probably hate these things a lot less.
- tenaciousDaniel 8y agoI do think that eventually these technologies will supersede trivial human transactions like customer service calls. The problem is that no one seems to understand the sheer difficulty of the problem. You have to create a machine that can realistically speak to a person, with all the nuance that entails. We're far further from that than AI marketers would lead us to believe.
- RodericDay 8y agoIf the flowchart is so good, they should expose it in clickable form online.
- bubblebauble 8y agoThe chatbot graph is secret because its purpose is to discourage certain actions, by making you sit through a humiliating hold period with brain-melting repeated announcements, until you reach a person who has strict orders to not be reasonable. They already have those online, in the form of FAQs and knowledge bases that don't tell you anything new.
- pif 8y agoI strongly disagree that customer service calls are trivial.
- tenaciousDaniel 8y agoI didn't mean trivial in the sense you mean. I mean trivial in that, in comparison to other human interactions, the variables are more limited and therefore lower hanging fruit for automation.
- awat 8y agoI agree but really only to a certain extent. Coaxing out of humans what thier actual issue is, is more of an art than a science. IMHO and from antecdotal experience this problem seems easier to automate than I think it really is which is why I don’t personally think anyone is crushing it in this space.
- candiodari 8y agoThe issue is that an AI is limited to what the user interface programmed by the company behind it provides. The issue is not the AI algorithms and understanding but rather extremely substandard automation behind it. Of course one can say that this is not an exclusively AI issue. Call centers, especially offshore ones, have the same problem.
- stephengillie 8y agoWe can translate spoken words to text strings pretty reliably. AFAIK, we can do this locally without much processing power, but I may be mistaken. From the point that spoken words become strings, chatbots and voicebots are effectively the same. Those strings are piped through a Switch statement of static responses, or fall out into the Default response. This was the situation in 2013 when I created a speech bot in Powershell, and it sounds like the state of the art here hasn't progressed far. What's needed is logic to dynamically build the Switch statements, or otherwise better parse human entry and build responses. There has been much work on a few different fronts, but I'm not aware of any which were wildly successful.
- ghaff 8y ago>We can translate spoken words to text strings pretty reliably. AFAIK, we can do this locally without much processing power, but I may be mistaken. Cloud services backed by big data sets tend to be better although I admit I haven't tried a local copy of Dragon Naturally Speaking for a long time. In any case, at least assuming fairly mainstream American/English accents, the voice recognition isn't really the problem any longer. Sophisticated NLP and responses are. We're a long way from virtual assistants that can do anything sophisticated.
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoExactly. Interacting with a chatbot had no better features than a menu system, but you had to guess what the menus were. A crazy idea.
- stephengillie 8y ago> ...no better features than a menu system, but you had to guess what the menus were. This is also true for CLI interfaces. It illustrates the popularity of GUIs - much to the dismay of CLI enthusiasts everywhere. Edit: Yes, a -help or "help" command can be used to list the menu. But then this command has to be known beforehand. What if a clever designer decides to use -assist or "assistance" instead?
- gboudrias 8y agoNot to be too curmudgeonly but you don't have to guess, almost all those CLI interfaces have a manual and a --help function. You can't ask a chatbot what its options are.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Jaruzel 8y agoOk, so... Linux Newbie: "I need to find out how much space I have left on this machine." > freespace bash: freespace: command not found > diskspace bash: diskspace: command not found > disk info bash: disk: command not found > diskinfo bash: diskinfo: command not found > man disk space No manual entry for disk No manual entry for space > help disk space bash: help: no help topics match `space'. Try `help help' or `man -k space' or `info space'. (looks it up on the internet) > df /dev/sda1 Filesystem 1K-blocks Used Available Use% Mounted on /dev/sda1 19478160 1370768 17094912 8% / ... AND that's why GUIs are preferred by most non-technical computer users. EDIT: Maybe I should have said 'CLI Newbie' - I am in no-way singling out Linux here.
- 8y ago
- taneq 8y ago> At that point I just push 0 and repeat "speak to a human." Spamming the # key repeatedly seems to work pretty well for this too.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoUnintelligible grunting works too. After a few "I'm sorry, I didn't get that" it always transfers me to a human. The most annoying part of the experience to me is the menu items are always ~25 things I can trivially do on the website. No, I'm not calling to check my balance, pay a balance, update payment information, etc. I'm calling because your website specifically said that function isn't available online and I need to speak to a representative.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- evandena 8y agoAlso annoying is never knowing how deep the menu tree is. I have to write down (or hold my fingers out) what the best option/number at the time, because its likely to change as the resolution of options refines.
- Bartweiss 8y agoIncluding circular paths in phone menus ought to be some kind of professional misconduct, at least when they're not invoked by "go back" or "start again". There's nothing quite like getting seven levels in and discovering you swapped trees somewhere and are back where you started.
- raverbashing 8y agoMy guess is that most people call for stuff that's easily doable in the website, but they can't or won't use it
- ouid 8y agomy guess is that this is not the case, but it's still worth it to handle any situation they can with a robot, or as a consolation, an impatient customer.
- acdha 8y agoThat often depends on your definition of easy – most large companies have poorly designed or buggy websites, lousy account management, etc. The problem is that the phone acts as a safety valve for those problems but when management sees the cost they react by trying to have fewer humans answering the phone rather than getting serious about UX.
- decebalus1 8y ago> Why, oh why, would any rational person think that this kind of technology was about to suddenly take over everything? Because the boardroom got a huge boner when realizing they can do major cost cutting in the human department.
- speby 8y agoAnd I think most of us are in the same camp there. Usually, when I am calling a business, it's because of some kind of unusual or complicated inquiry or special situation because I generally don't want to call if I can do or get what I need by logging in online to the company's site to manage my account or do whatever I need there as that's often the fastest. But the online account management only does so much so when a weird edge case regarding doing business with the company arises, I will call, and in those situations the AI/voice prompts never handle the situation I am calling about such that I need a human agent/rep every single time. I wouldn't be calling for something simple!
- gambiting 8y agoAs someone for whom English is not the native language it's the worst. It's incredibly humiliating when the stupid machine can't understand what I am saying - and 100% of the ones I encountered fail to understand my surname and I have to repeat it 5 times like an idiot before it finally gives up and just tries something else as an authentication method.
- dizzystar 8y agoThe dirty secret is that there are thousands of humans listening in on these phone bot conversations. They have the power to press a button to override the endless loop. Amazing what they are spending to keep up illusions.
- qudat 8y agoI always thought it was a way to buffer calls so there is another interactive queue to delay getting to the main customer service queue.