5 ms·
Yeah, because we know governments are really good at giving certifications and doing tests that mean sonething. Lets put every design decision in the hand of go
by ekianjo 8y ago
Yeah, because we know governments are really good at giving certifications and doing tests that mean sonething. Lets put every design decision in the hand of governements then! or better, nationalize car companies! Problem solved?
- amelius 8y agoIn any case, let a third party control the actual updating, so that we know when and how often cars are updated. Require at least X months of time between code submission and deployment to cars. We don't want a culture of "quick fixes".
- stickfigure 8y agoThis is a popular idea: Just put someone in charge! It ignores the incentives for those gatekeepers, who are now part of the system. In practice I don't think you're going to get better updates, you're going to get "almost no updates". See also: The FDA and drug approvals.
- amelius 8y agoSo you want to do away with the FDA? Put BigPharma in charge and let them regulate themselves? That sounds a lot less appealing to me.
- wooter 8y agofdareview.org - the fda kills more people in late/non approvals than it saves through denials. this is why compassionate use has been on the rise
- TeMPOraL 8y agoIt does not, in any way, imply that pharmaceutical companies would do a better job if left to their own devices and market pressure.
- dnautics 8y agoThere's a lot of sunlight between letting pharma companies run rampant and having the FDA. One could imagine private non-profit testing and qualifications standards organizations along the lines of the underwriters laboratories
- ekianjo 8y agoIt is not completely out of this world to imagine multiple private entities involved in pharma dossier reviews instead of having the FDA. The FDA employs tons of private consultants anyway so they bring virtually no value.
- ekianjo 8y agoIt took years for the FDA to investigate Theranos in case you are not aware. And they only did when the press started digging up. Poor, poor track record.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- AmVess 8y agoFlying in an airplane is safe because of direct intervention by the government. Cars have been made safe for us also by direct intervention by the government. From important things like mandating seat belts and crash safety to smaller things like forcing the recall of tens of millions of faulty air bag inflators. These are just a few of the many things Uncle Sam has done to make things safer for us.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoIsn’t flying mostly safe because of post hoc safety analysis followed by operating requirements? I don’t think the FAA tests every change made to aircraft before they can fly?
- AceyMan 8y agoDe facto the FAA indeed does that very thing. First, any change in design (or in configuration, in the case of repairs) is backed by PEs or A&P mechanics who sign off on the changes. Their career rides on the validity of their analysis so that's a better guarantee than some commit message by a systems programmer. Second, the FAA basically says "show us what you are changing" after which they will absolutely require physical tests (static or dynamic tests, test flights, etc., as appropriate to the scope of change). And I'd say flying is so safe mainly from the blameless post-mortem policy that the American industry instantiated decades ago and which is constantly reinforced by the pros in the NTSB. It's a wonderful model for improvement.
- sokoloff 8y agoI think that the FAA's role is theoretically as you express, but in practice, there is significantly less oversight (especially direct oversight) than implied. As an example, the crash of N121JM on a rejected takeoff was due (only in part) to a defective throttle quadrant/gust lock design that went undetected during design and certification, in part because it was argued to be a continuation of a conformant and previously certificated design. (Which is relevant to the current discussion in that if you decide to make certification costly and time-consuming, there will be business and engineering pressure to continue using previously certificated parts, with only "insignificant changes".) https://aviation-safety.net/database/record.php?id=20140531-0 https://aviation-safety.net/database/record.php?id=20140531-... PS: I 100% agree on the NTSB process' contribution to safety.