5 ms·
Doing a little math... Considering 1100 Gtons in the atmosphere and $200 per ton would be roughly $220 trillions. The current world's GDP is $78 trillions. E
by pier25 8y ago
Doing a little math...
Considering 1100 Gtons in the atmosphere and $200 per ton would be roughly $220 trillions.
The current world's GDP is $78 trillions.
Even if the world invested $10 trillions every year it would still take 20 years to remove all the carbon emitted between 1850 and today.
Of course we would keep pumping about 37 Gtons per year (and growing).
https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-global-co2-emissions-set-to-rise-2-percent-in-2017-following-three-year-plateau https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-global-co2-emissions-se...
- jessaustin 8y agoMaybe the first goal could just be removing the current year's production? That would still be a vast improvement over every other proposed solution.
- Scarblac 8y agoBy his numbers that's still ~ $7.4 trillion, or about 10% of the world's GDP. And it doesn't include storing the captured CO2 anywhere permanent. I think it's a lot more practical to reduce our emissions to close to zero, hard as that is.
- jessaustin 8y agoAnything we do is going to be expensive. "Stopping all use of fossil fuels" like you suggest would also be very expensive, even if we ignore obvious costs like disposing of all the corpses created by such an endeavor.
- epistasis 8y ago20 years is an incredibly quick timespan in which to do this. If we can become carbon neutral by 2040 and carbon negative after, we can stave off many of the worst parts of climate change.
- padobson 8y agoI'm with you. I have to believe a joint country climate accord where member nations pledge to suck X gigatonnes of carbon from the atmosphere (or finance those that do) is a much easier political sell than 1) taxing fossil fuel companies/cartels or 2) enforcing emissions restrictions on various industries. Cleaning up 150 years of emissions in 20 or 40 or even 60 years seems like a miracle on par with the moon landing or eradicating smallpox.
- abraae 8y agoJust stopping things from getting worse would be an achievement on those scales.
- chrisweekly 8y agoI love your real-world examples of "miracles"! In front of me right now I have the June issue of the IEEE Spectrum special report, titled "Blueprints for a Miracle: 10 Technologies for a More Livable Planet". Its highlights include carbon-eating fuel cells; turbines driven by super-critical CO2 (nearly "free" carbon capture, courtesy the Allam cycle); a plant in Iceland producing methanol fuel from renewable (geothermal) energy and waste CO2; a pure-electric airplane; plant-based and in-vitro meats; and a sodium-cooled travelling-wave nuclear reactor with decent performance.... It seems to me like we're coming to the fight awfully late, but we may also have more weapons than we'd realized.
- pier25 8y agoAn economic loss of $10 trillions per year during 20 years would be catastrophic for the economy. It's simply not sustainable economically. Also, let's not forget that our emissions are still significant (and growing) and that feedbacks will keep on warming the planet regardless of what we do.
- allthenews 8y agoYou don't need to capture anywhere near the total amount emitted into in the atmosphere. Just enough to offset warming.
- CapitalistCartr 8y agoThat "just enough" is probably half of what is presently in the atmosphere. The oceans have absorbed huge amounts of what we've emitted, and would disgorge it accordingly. The CO2 level in 1900 was about 300 ppm; now its 400. To make a substantial reversal in climate change by only removing CO2 from the atmosphere, we'd have to make a massive stride by 2050.
- m0llusk 8y agoThe oceans may also end up being a higher priority at least at first because there is already evidence that acidification caused by absorption of excess atmospheric carbon us causing ocean ecosystems to break down while disruption on land is still relatively minor.
- oasisbob 8y agoI'm not sure you can target oceanic CO2 over CO2 in the atmosphere. Ocean acidification is an equilibrium process driven by the partial pressure of CO2 in the atmosphere increasing. If you start reversing acidification, the ocean is just going to start pulling in more CO2 from the atmosphere.
- patrickyeon 8y agoSounds like you should "just" target whichever one is easier (cheaper) to pull CO2 out of, then.
- m0llusk 8y agoIn most cases it is easier and more practical to accelerate reactions in liquid media as opposed to gases. This is chemistry not magic.
- st26 8y agoPresumably, Zeno's Paradox will be hard at work. We don't have to remove it all in one go. We just have to remove it faster and faster and faster, as we get closer to the limit (whatever that limit is). This isn't my field, but so many human endeavors go like that. Just buy a little time so we can figure out how to do better, which then buys time to figure out how to do even better.
- ebbv 8y agoOn top of the fact that this probably doesn’t scale up to geo-engineering scales linearly even if you assume the article is correct in the costs it gives.
- dietdrb 8y agoThis industrial approach to carbon dioxide removal is but one of several in our toolkit, and by no means the least expensive. Project Drawdown ranks every approach in terms of tonnage of CO2 and cost. http://www.drawdown.org/solutions-summary-by-rank http://www.drawdown.org/solutions-summary-by-rank These approaches get amplified by a price on carbon. If you are interested in convincing your Member of Congress to price carbon, take a look at the most effective organization doing this work: http://www.citizensclimatelobby.org http://www.citizensclimatelobby.org
- skosch 8y agoThank you for spreading the word about Drawdown and CCL! They are probably the two easiest ways regular folks can learn about and get involved in climate policy (and I mean real impacts, not just clicktivism). Please get involved – it takes no money and very little time!
- cobbzilla 8y agoThank you for introducing me to Project Drawdown. How eminently practical and sensible these recommendations are. I love the data-driven approach. I was surprised to find that, of all things, "Refrigerant Management" is the single thing that holds the greatest potential to reduce carbon emissions [1]. It makes a lot of sense, but it would definitely not be what I would have guessed. [1] http://www.drawdown.org/solutions/materials/refrigerant-management http://www.drawdown.org/solutions/materials/refrigerant-mana...
- DoctorOetker 8y agothat #1 single thing only makes up 89.74 of the total 1050.99 at the bottomm of that column! or about 8.5%
- Double_a_92 8y agoSure... educating specifically only the girls is #6 on the list. Why would they have to bring feminism into that? I mean sure, it's a good thing to educate everyone. But why mix it? How can I trust all the other points on the list now? What if they are also just pushing some other political agenda? I can't. They just compromised the list's integrity by that.
- jessriedel 8y agoSeeing as that the entire world economy for the last century, responsible for the greatest reduction in poverty in the history of the world, is driven heavily by fossil fuels, it does not seem that unreasonable.
- mkempe 8y agoReminder: If CO2 levels fall below 150 ppm there will be a mass extinction of land-based plants. It is a grave mistake to believe that CO2 as such is bad and must be removed from the atmosphere. It is an essential fertilizer for both phytoplankton and land-based plants (at current levels these plants are in effect starved for CO2, because they evolved during geological time periods with much higher CO2 levels).
- JetSpiegel 8y ago> these plants are in effect starved for CO2, because they evolved during time periods with much higher CO2 levels Oh, the old argument trotted out again. What do you mean, plants "evolved" in the past and then what? Stopped evolving? If plants were starved of CO2 now they would go extinct, which they aren't. To prove my point, I present exhibit A: The Amazon rainforest.
- mkempe 8y agoStarvation is not equivalent to death, it means that plants are not growing as fast nor as well as they would with higher levels of CO2. This is a proven fact and has been amply demonstrated in scientific experiments; it is related to well-understood biological processes in photosynthesis. It is the reason greenhouses deliberately increase CO2 ppm. [1] And yes, the plant kingdom has evolved just a few pathways for photosynthesis that worked well at much higher CO2 levels (10-15x current) when they originated; and these pathways are not magically "evolving" to function with diminishing CO2 levels, they've merely become suboptimal given the atmospheric conditions in the last million years, and would stop working below specific levels. Your ignorant dismissals are moronic denials of facts and science. Surely you don't pretend that there is no lower limit to the viable amount of CO2 in the air for Earth vegetation to survive? [1] http://www.omafra.gov.on.ca/english/crops/facts/00-077.htm#suppl http://www.omafra.gov.on.ca/english/crops/facts/00-077.htm#s...
- delbel 8y agothis is why I have been trying to promote CO2 production to a target level of 1200PPM. With enough solar, biofuels and wind -- which are all net negative entry input vs energy output (which promotes CO2 production) I was hoping we could do this.
- erentz 8y agoI’ve been sending the same math to people who’ve been getting excited about this. It’s premature. Even just trying to remove our annual emission would take 7% of our global GDP. This needs to come down in cost 20x to be a viable solution to our problem. And that’s just going by cost, not looking at the logistical aspects. For example the plant pictured captures 1 million tonnes annually. So we would require 37,000 of those giant plants to capture our annual emissions. We haven’t explored how much energy would be required to do that and where we would get it from. The plant shown uses gas, a polluting power source oddly, and a very cheap energy cost figure in its calculations. Presumably we’d want to use solar. And thus half the efficiency of that plant. So double the number required to 74 thousand. Everyone getting excited that this is a solutions has gotten ahead of the science and logistics. We’re far from being there.
- DennisP 8y agoNuclear seems like a better option than solar. Assuming capital cost is a major factor, you'd want the carbon removal plant to run all the time, not shut down at night. Constant load is perfect for nuclear.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoThere are countless ways to store energy: hydrogen, artificial hydroeletric, batteries, etc. Solar energy is practically unlimited. Nuclear still requires fuel, and it's a very limited resource unless you start considering things like extracting fuel from the ocean where costs just skyrocket. And it's likely that our global energy usage will skyrocket in the future for a variety of reasons. The first level is that many places are still undeveloped and have not yet hit their 'China' phase. But beyond that we can also just do some really cool sci-fi soundings things if we massively ramped up our energy production. Fossil fuels, and fuels in general, were never really fit for these sort of ideas - but solar certainly is. This [1] article goes into detail on the remaining nuclear material. Keep in mind that this is at current consumption rates. Energy usage rates are going to increase in the future, and right now only 4% of global energy production is nuclear. In other words, you can shave orders of magnitudes off the numbers they give in that article to give a ballpark for how long nuclear would last. It's just not a great fit for the longterm future. [1] - https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-long-will-global-uranium-deposits-last/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-long-will-glo...
- jillesvangurp 8y agoYour math is not wrong but your assumptions are. We only need to remove enough to produce fuel so that we can stop dumping c02 in the atmosphere by consuming oil and replace that with what we produce from co2. Once we do that, nature will do the rest. Slowly of course but it will trend the right way. So, there is no need whatsoever to actively remove that many tons of CO2.
- thinkcontext 8y agoThere are many tons of emissions that can be avoided for far less that $200/ton. These are the things like stopping the burning of fossil fuels, increasing energy efficiency, planting trees, capturing from industrial point sources, etc. DAC is the high cost alternative, that means it will be used last as a strategy for dealing with CO2 emissions.
- SolarNet 8y agoMy thing is that we should be charging/taxing the companies producing these sorts of emissions. But of course capitalism is about socializing the costs (fixing these emissions) and privatizing the profits.