6 ms·
“[Driver’s] hands were not detected on the steering wheel for the final six seconds prior to the crash. Tesla has said that Huang received warnings to put his h
by MBCook 8y ago
“[Driver’s] hands were not detected on the steering wheel for the final six seconds prior to the crash. Tesla has said that Huang received warnings to put his hands on the wheel, but according to the NTSB, these warnings came more than 15 minutes before the crash.”
This kind of stuff is why I’ve lost all faith in Tesla’s public statements. What they said here was, for all intents and purposes, a flat out lie.
Clearly something went wrong here, but they lept to blaming everyone else instead of working to find the flaw.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jakobegger 8y agoAlso, „hands were not detected“ does not mean that they really weren‘t on the wheel. Maybe someone who drives a Tesla can comment on how reliable the hand detection is.
- cf498 8y agoNo idea about tesla, but how do you screw up hand detenction?
- sjm-lbm 8y agoIt's based off measuring torque on the steering column, not some sort of (say) heat or pressure sensors on the wheel itself. So, having your hands on the wheel and not moving them can be sensed by the Tesla as "not having your hands on the wheel".
- cf498 8y agoLearned something new, thanks a lot.
- MBCook 8y agoIn my car (a Honda) I can have my hands on the wheel and if I’m not doi enough steering it will yell at me. There are one or two spots around town that are straight enough that I don’t need to give any steering input and it will sometimes flag me there even though my hands were on the wheel the whole time. On a freeway? Don’t think I’ve ever had thay happen though.
- ingenieroariel 8y agoThe hand not applying any pressure and barely touching the wheel. It happens consistently on my Ford Fusion when I am driving on a straight line. Car says my hands are not on the wheel when they are touching it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- martin_bech 8y agoHand detection is pretty good. You only need to rest your hands on the wheel. Have a model s as my daily driver.
- TheForumTroll 8y agoLots of drivers have problems where they have to "shake" the wheel to make the car understand that they do indeed have their hands on the wheel. The system is pretty rubbish.
- kwhitefoot 8y agoIt seems to me that my 2015 S70D expects me to be holding the wheel firmly enough to actually take action. Mostly I just keep one hand lightly on the wheel when driving down a motorway with autosteer on and just give it a gentle squeeze or wiggle once in a while. If I use it on less good roads I keep both hands on the wheel in the proper location for taking control. It seems pretty good to me.
- Lucent 8y agoThen it must vary significantly per car. I have to squeeze the wheel pretty hard to dismiss the message on mine.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoOr, perhaps more probably, by driver. I am far more inclined to think that a large variation in hands exists, rather than a large variation in mass-produced steering wheels.
- intherdfield 8y agoThis came up last month and a Tesla driver had this to say. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16822623 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16822623
- jonhendry18 8y agoThe driver clearly didn't take any action to intervene, so his hands probably genuinely weren't on the wheel.
- jschwartzi 8y agoIf I were rapidly approaching a barrier at full speed on a highway, I might put my hands up and guard my face before the crash.
- vm 8y agoIf you were aware of what was happening. Smartphones are distracting.
- alasdair_ 8y agoIs there any proof that the guy who died was using a smartphone at the time of the crash?
- vm 8y agooops didn't mean to imply that for the driver. meant it to as a meta-comment. my point was that the driver probably didn't know the crash was about to happen. broader investigation into "why the crash happened" is more fruitful than "what the driver could have done differently once the crash happened"
- martin_bech 8y agoBut then you would propably also be applying the brakes..
- Balgair 8y agoExample: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nvckBJP8QPU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nvckBJP8QPU I mean, auto-pilot, as promised, would be a god-send for such a poor driver (or anyone with even mild motor impairments). That it preformed soooooo poorly and that Tesla has responded soooo shadily, should put anyone seeking auto-pilot (as a real need, not a gadget) on notice.
- devy 8y agoAdd to that, the last bullet point from page 2 of the official preliminary report[1]: At 3 seconds prior to the crash and up to the time of impact with the crash attenuator, the Tesla’s speed increased from 62 to 70.8 mph, with no precrash braking or evasive steering movement detected. That to me is a strong indicator that Tesla's AP2 can not recognize a crashed attenuator, probably one of the strongest argument that AP2 without LiDAR is unsafe and fatal (let alone of missing the redundancy in sensors and brakes[2]). [1]: https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/HWY18FH011-preliminary.pdf https://www.ntsb.gov/investigations/AccidentReports/Reports/... [2]: https://arstechnica.com/cars/2018/04/why-selling-full-self-driving-before-its-ready-could-backfire-for-tesla/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2018/04/why-selling-full-self-d...
- mikeyouse 8y agoIt reads like he was following another car that was driving at a slower speed but once that car left his path, his car began to accelerate to the pre-set speed of 75mph.
- devy 8y agoIt doesn't matter if he was following another car or not. If there is an obstacle, AP2 should brake and in that case it should brake hard or use evasive turning maneuvers to avoid head-on collision.
- MBCook 8y agoThat’s the thing, it clearly didn’t detect the obstacle. Given that there were no (known) obstacles, it behaved correctly. Fix the obstacle detection.
- fixermark 8y agoThe problem is it's entirely possible the obstacle detection is un-fixable without swapping out the sensor suite the Tesla ships with. Tesla is quite clearly expecting the problem to be solvable with that sensor suite alone (this is more-or-less the line I was given by a Tesla seller when I was shopping for a car), so it's not going to be in the T-sheet for them to recall every Tesla on the road to fit a LIDAR to them, assuming that's at all feasible.
- ebikelaw 8y agoMusk prefers to lie to the public and benefits from the disintermediation of the media that various Internet distribution channels have allowed. Tesla often makes clearly false statements. SpaceX, when part of their heavy lift rocket crashed into the ocean, cut away from that scene to a shot of two happy smiling spokesmodels pretending to not know what had happened. Today what we need more than we ever needed it is skepticism, journalism, and vigorous investigation. You can’t take anything these companies are saying at face value.
- dpcx 8y ago"Spokesmodels"? Those were SpaceX employees. SpaceX engineers. And at least initially, I don't think they actually knew what happened. Maybe they did later, but not initially.
- mikejb 8y agoThe SpaceX comparison is a bad example. Sure they could have said "this and that happened", but there's always the point on how much you can trust the data you get at that point. I fully understand them not talking about failures when cause and consequences aren't even remotely understood. But I understand where you're coming from, and I agree: Tesla quickly released statements claiming the safety benefits of Autopilot, putting all the blame on the driver, and even providing misleading statements ('the driver was warned multiple times' but leaving out that that happened 15+ minutes prior). That was the exact opposite, when they didn't know the cause of the accident, but were quick to just deny any wrongdoing.
- Maybestring 8y ago>This kind of stuff is why I’ve lost all faith in Tesla’s public statements. I don't understand why they would issue any statement other than, 'condolences, we're committed to safety, we're working with the NTSB to understand what happened'
- debt 8y agoBecause Musk views people as crustaceans rather than human beings.
- jumelles 8y agoIt's hubris.
- xab9 8y agoMoney.
- Maybestring 8y agoI'm not sure it's in Tesla's financial interest. Misleading statements give the plaintiffs more room to argue for punitive damages, and California juries have awarded tremendous punitive damages on auto companies.
- xab9 8y agoTesla is a symbol, Musk is a strong personality. To me it's the same as when Jobs said during the antenna fiasco that "you're holding it wrong". Being a symbol, being an entity that creates objects of desire is financially beneficial to the company. The question is, who's message will the potential customers hear: the NTSB's or Musk's? Of course I'm not saying that this is a good strategy - Tesla may as well fall from grace eventually, but the bully is ultimately powered by greed and hunger - for adoration, for money, for financial gains.
- aero142 8y agoI think Musk strongly believes that flipping the switch to sacrifice 1 and save 5 in the trolley problem is clearly the correct choice. If the numbers show that less people die with self driving cars than with them, then that is the right choice. I suspect he even believes that the people that die along the way in the transitional periods are worth it if that is what it takes to save hundreds of thousands of lives in the long run. Most people aren't ok with this kind of utilitarianism, but I suspect he is. The PR is just another tool of keeping people from banning self driving cars before they get to the place where they are really ready.
- ckastner 8y ago> Clearly something went wrong here, but they lept to blaming everyone else instead of working to find the flaw. Precisely. As I mentioned in another comment: Autopilot indisputably failed. They are (understandbly) shifting the discussion away from the technical issue (Autopilot failed) to the legal issue (who is to blame), because the latter is something that they can dispute.
- dogma1138 8y agoIt’s feature maybe? After all after insane and ludicrous mode kamikaze kinda fits. I don’t understand why people had faith in AP 2.0 in the first place, especially since Tesla boasted that it took them only 6 months to develop it. And unlike AP 1.0 the regulated ADAS features were not enabled (officially as in outside of AP mode) on it for the longest time some still aren’t.
- WiseWeasel 8y agoSuicidal mode - we'll make it look like an accident.
- agumonkey 8y agoMusk has lost touch with reality if that's true..
- Shivetya 8y agohttps://www.tesla.com/autopilot https://www.tesla.com/autopilot and best of all, guess what Tesla shows on that landing page. A driver with their hands in their lap
- letsgetphysITal 8y agoThey do expect you to change that posture if Autopilot does something you think is dangerous, though. Wandering out of lane uninitiated (lane change indication, for example) and accelerating towards a barrier would likely count as one of those situations. I've yet to see an incident so far where a human driver, properly engaged with the driving experience and road conditions as they should be when in charge of a vehicle, couldn't have taken action and prevented the accident. There were 7 seconds between the beginning of the maneuver and impact; Human reaction time (including taking action) is typically 0.5 seconds. That leaves 6.5 seconds to correct steering or apply the brake, bearing in mind that Autopilot will always relinquish control in either situation. Not apologising for Tesla, they need to sort out this edge case, but that's exactly what it was and exactly why the driver is supposed to remain engaged.
- netsharc 8y ago> They do expect you to change that posture if Autopilot does something you think is dangerous, though. Their lawyers and their marketing departments are contradicting each other. Their legal department will always insist that your hands must remain on the steering wheel. If your hands are not on the wheel, and the car crashes, they will mention this clause and implicitly blame the driver. Their marketing department (like this webpage) say "This car can drive itself!". And the car itself? Well it has a sensor that detect hands off wheel situations (plus point from the lawyers' "cover our asses" side), but it allows a few (/lot of) seconds of that situation before it warns you (their lawyer must've once screamed "Why the fuck does the sensor tolerate this situation!"). For a stupid analogy, it's almost like a bar owner advertising his bar as a smoke joint, but saying "you're not allowed to smoke in here, and I can spot anyone smoking" but still tolerating a few minutes of lit cigarettes.
- agildehaus 8y agoTruly fixing the flaw would be to skip to Level 4 as Google decided to do, instead of shipping a system that many drivers get too comfortable with leading to accidents such as this one. But skipping to Level 4 fairly clearly requires LIDAR at this point in history and Musk is on record saying he thinks it can be done with cameras and radar alone. So pride will prevent that.
- mikejb 8y agoIt doesn't even have to be pride. If he now says they're switching to Lidars, all cars before sold with "self-driving hardware" and "full SDC is only a software and computer upgrade away" promises are screwed, which may create a huge liability for Tesla, and impact share prices significantly. As CEO, he still has to answer to shareholders and act with them in mind.