9 ms·
Kallithea – Aself-hosted alternative to GitHub
- rgrieselhuber 8y agoLove the idea. The UI looks a bit dated. My recommendation would be to just copy what the main players have done as a starting point, unless you have a radically better UX solution. Then innovate from there.
- godzillabrennus 8y agoI like starting with the excellent and open source AdminLTE interface. https://adminlte.io/themes/AdminLTE/index2.html https://adminlte.io/themes/AdminLTE/index2.html
- pierreortega 8y agoI consider Gogs a better option. The UI is also less painful https://gogs.io/ https://gogs.io/
- mistrial9 8y agoGogs is a visual clone of the Github graphic design, functions, menu structure, in short, just about everything from Github. SO sure, it works well and looks good, but uh.. its a total copy. Meanwhile Gitea has forked Gogs, as noted extensively very recently. Regarding Kallithea, I installed and used it for work. I like Kallithea, although the features and interface are not as well developed as some alternatives discussed here. Kallithea is far more lightweight to setup and admin that Gitlab, but not as full-featured as Gitea, which I recommend to anyone who asks.
- keyle 8y agoI just installed gogs. It's very nice. Smooth, simple, familiar. I wonder how they can get away with copying Github so obviously though.
- hliyan 8y agoAlso, Kallithea does not seem to have its own lightweight issue system. Based on how you look at it, this could be either a positive or a negative...
- slantyyz 8y agoGogs is also available for some NASes as a package. I have an instance installed on my Asustor NAS for my personal stuff, and it works great.
- kankroc 8y agoI've heard that Gitea (the fork) is more actively developed right now so it might be worth investigating that claim before jumping to gogs.
- Proven 8y agoGPLv3? Worse than proprietary!
- durandal1 8y agoBut instead of only the code being handled by the VCS, why not make the wiki and tracker distributed too? Fossil: https://fossil-scm.org/ https://fossil-scm.org/ Notable user: https://sqlite.org/whynotgit.html https://sqlite.org/whynotgit.html
- mikekchar 8y agoI'm going to give Fossil a try, mainly because it is the only thing I've seen that has everything that I currently want. I'm a little bit worried about the Cathedral/Bazaar approach... I really like the idea that every copy of the source code is an implied branch. However, I suspect that I will have few enough collaborators for it to be of any matter. Their characterisation of GPL vs BSD licensing in the git vs fossil comparison is frustrating though. I wonder if there is a way to convince them to update it because it really reduces their credibility. I'm specifically referring to "the GPL license grants the right to read source code to anyone who promises to give back enhancements". This is just completely incorrect. From the GPL V3: "You may make, run and propagate covered works that you do not convey, without conditions". In other words, as long as you don't "convey" (distribute) your changes, you can do whatever the heck you want (including reading the source code).
- hvidgaard 8y agoWhen taken out of context, it does sound bad, but please include the entire paragraph, because it's clear that not as you describe. > To a first approximation, the GPL license grants the right to read source code to anyone who promises to give back enhancements. In other words, the act of reading GPL source code (a prerequiste for making changes) implies acceptance of the license which requires updates to be contributed back under the same license. (The details are more complex, but the foregoing captures the essence of the idea.) A big advantage of the GPL is that anybody can contribute to the code without having to sign additional legal documentation because they have implied their acceptance of the GPL license by the very act of reading the source code. This means that a GPL project can legally accept anonymous and drive-by patches.
- 8y ago
- niftich 8y agoKallithea originated in 2014 [1] as a fork of RhodeCode 1.7.2 to rectify a licensing ambiguity that the fork-author felt arose in 2013. The GUI web interface was the most affected by hasty replacements, which perhaps explains the lack of polish in design. RhodeCode continued to be developed, and in 2016 the RhodeCode Community Edition was re-licensed under AGPLv3. [1] https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2014/jul/15/why-kallithea/ https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2014/jul/15/why-kallithea/
- justnopelol 8y agoHave you tried github.com instead
- everdev 8y agoIsn't GitLab a self-hosted alternative to GitHub?
- copremesis 8y agohttps://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/tree/master https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/tree/master (run as rails standalone) https://hub.docker.com/r/gitlab/gitlab-ce/ https://hub.docker.com/r/gitlab/gitlab-ce/ (run as docker image)
- mikekchar 8y agoYes. But it's not the only one. I think the question you were hoping to have answered is, "Why would you pick this over GitLab?". And potentially the discussion you wanted to invoke was, "Is there an advantage to going with a full free software solution as opposed to a product that is primarily proprietary, but has an open core?" Personally, I think there is, but in the case of GitLab it may not matter. Now that there are some free software heavy hitters (Gnome and Debian) who rely on the open core of GitLab, there is some more assurance that this open core will not become a kind of cripple-ware try-before-you-buy situation. Those groups have enough horse power to maintain the open part of GitLab if they choose to do so. Having said that, I think there is room for other free software entries in this space and I'm looking forward to seeing how it plays out. In some ways the acquisition of GitHub may be the catalyst necessary to get things started, and I think it's a good thing.
- hawski 8y agoIn a way AFAIK Gnome and Debian moved to GitLab, because, among other reasons, they did not have enough horse power to maintain their own solution - plethora of services. Of course if the GitLab would fold, they would maintain it, but I'm not sure they would be better off than before in case of work allocation at least.
- sam_goody 8y agoIf gitlab were to fold, they would probably move to whoever is the best candidate at the time. While moving is very painful, the fact that git is distributed means that setting up camp somewhere else is pretty smooth. Even the headaches of the other stuff, such as issues et al, will probably be handled by whoever the new host is.
- Samis2001 8y agoIt would be even better if Kallithea or RhodeCode adopted the UI style shared by GitHub/Gogs/Gitea and friends. Then we could have the best of both worlds - good, well-known UI but with software that isn't as closely coupled to Git as some others are (and is lightweight with requirements)
- copremesis 8y agoI'm surprised out of all the drama surrounding M$ purchase of GitHub I haven't seen many mentions of BitBucket https://bitbucket.org/ https://bitbucket.org/ I've been using this for years now since you get free private repos.
- qmarchi 8y agoThe biggest complaint that I've seen against bitbucket is the ties to Atlassian and the fact it is a closed source product. Most of the ones featured here are some form of open source or open core for GitLab.
- paulryanrogers 8y agoLast I looked it was limited to 5 users. Gitlab on the other hand offers unlimited users and limited repo size: 10G.
- _wmd 8y agopre-Atlassian BitBucket was a lovely app, then they landed that Web 9.0 JS abomination redesign. Because waiting 30 seconds for uncached Javascript assets to load while on the clock is totally acceptable, when all you really need is 500 bytes worth of a Git directory listing to render. Left feedback, no response. Left feedback again, still no response. Moved everything to GitLab. It's really hard to see great apps like this (and Reddit as a more recent example) destroyed by.. seemingly.. people given too much time to do their jobs. I'm not a front end guy, but the feeling I get is that it has the same problem as backend. Can't just cobble a few well-tested Django views together any more, must have a 16-microservice mess to ensure the CV is fully padded. Makes me so sad
- aviau 8y agoAlso worth checking out: Fedora's minimalistic git forge. https://pagure.io/pagure https://pagure.io/pagure
- seagoat 8y agoI've been using Kallithea with 8GB+ binary Mercurial repos. It works on a server with 2GB of RAM and has been running for a few years now. If you want something lightweight that will work with huge binary repos (game projects and such), Kallithea is for you.
- kuberstone 8y agoI compared in details both rhodecode and kallithea for our org ui is something personal i guess, both aren't perfect. For usage in 50+ users enterprise rhodecode is much better. It has more features, and it feels this project is actually moving forward contrary to kallithea https://www.mail-archive.com/kallithea-general@sfconservancy.org/msg02605.html https://www.mail-archive.com/kallithea-general@sfconservancy... The only thing we liked more is GPL license over AGPl of rhodecode
- andrzejsz 8y agoDoes anybody knows about some alternative with homepage feature something like github pages?
- kuberstone 8y agoI believe only gitlab
- hkt 8y agoGitbucket - http://github.com/gitbucket/gitbucket http://github.com/gitbucket/gitbucket It has a "pages" plugin, at the time of writing it is mentioned in the README
- nothrabannosir 8y agoThis is not what you asked, but if you’re looking to host a static website by pushing to Git in particular, you might be interested in Netlify. They’re essentially a build step + static host. If you like Github pages, this might be up your alley.
- sam_goody 8y agoSince there are so many threads already, here is a recap of the competition: Self Hosted (in order of anecdotal popularity) - Gitlab - Gitea (fork of Gogs) - Gogs - Phabricator - GitBucket - Rhodecode - Kalithea (fork of Rhodecode) - GitPrep - Allura - GitSSB - Pagure If you want hosted Git, there are many competitors, but some of the notable are - Gitlab - Attlassian BitBucket - Google Cloud Repositories - Amazon CodeCommit - Canonical Launchpad - Sourceforge All of which assume you want git, but other DVCSs are Mercurial (which is supported by a number of the above servers) and Fossil.
- DC-3 8y agohttp://sr.ht http://sr.ht is another service.
- andrzejsz 8y agoWhat's the difference between hosted and self-hosted?
- dmurray 8y agoSelf-hosted means you own a computer and you install their software on it. Hosted means they own the computer and run their software on it, but they allow you to have an account and store your code there. If you don't know what you want, you probably want hosted.
- lucb1e 8y agoMost people count a VPS or container as self hosted as well, though. You don't need to own the hardware if that's not your thing.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- icc97 8y agoSeems like it needs a Github awesome list: https://github.com/ianchanning/awesome-github-alternatives https://github.com/ianchanning/awesome-github-alternatives
- akskos 8y agoI hope there won't be anymore one single source control site that everybody uses.
- bovermyer 8y agoIn that scenario, how would source discovery work?
- krupan 8y agoSame way you discover anything on the internet.
- cweagans 8y agoWander aimlessly through hundreds of pages of Google results until you find something loosly related to what you're looking for in a forum post from ten years ago by a person who doesn't seem to exist anywhere else on the internet except for this one forum -- and he's been inactive for eight years?
- IshKebab 8y agoNo screenshots. No demo. Do they really want anyone to use it?
- ptman 8y agoNo demo? What about the "see it in action" link on the page: https://kallithea-scm.org/repos/ https://kallithea-scm.org/repos/
- kankroc 8y agoIf anyone want to setup Gitea easily (but not in a docker container) I made a gist a couple days ago that install it and creates a service for easy management on ubuntu 16+ https://gist.github.com/cbdec05bca7907d70b156662dbd7c811 https://gist.github.com/cbdec05bca7907d70b156662dbd7c811