2 ms·
Software is design, not construction. This is why it's hard to estimate. You ask an architect to design a new skyscraper in a fixed three-month timeframe, good
by Jtsummers 8y ago
Software is design, not construction. This is why it's hard to estimate.
You ask an architect to design a new skyscraper in a fixed three-month timeframe, good luck. It won't be what you want, or it'll have severe problems discovered during construction.
Software developers are creative workers, we have to accept this. Unless you're doing the nth iteration of basic CRUD/RESTful web app, or a trivial "display data from a database" app (note: the DB design may take more time, some of the controls on interaction will take more time, but the core of it will be the same) you can't reasonably estimate your time.
Once you know Ruby on Rails, making a prototype of a webapp is a rote task. You can knock it out in a known (from experience) time. Then you try to improve it, add new features, customize the backend (first time you've written a DB connector), things start going off schedule.
The only other way to have reasonable estimates of the development, is to spend a ton of time upfront (unestimable) designing the system before we touch the code. Ok, now the coding tasks are well understood, but you also just spent 2 years designing it. And, like the architect, if you rush this design part, problems will crop up during coding that will blow your schedule.
- nradov 8y agoArchitects regularly design new skyscrapers on fixed schedules. Look at some of the major developments going up in China.
- Jtsummers 8y agoHow many of those fixed schedule projects are based on old and proven designs? I specifically emphasized new in that sentence. Perhaps I should have said to produce novel designs. Which is what many programmers are asked to do and estimate.
- rurban 8y agoHaving built such a modern scyscraper in China by myself, I have to disagree. The first such scyscrapers where incredibly poorly planned, because they didn't have the proper budget and management culture. They probably outsourced the CAD work to some shop in Singapure or Indonesia, struggled with the metric/imperial system and tolerances. Workers conditions were horrible. People died all over, nobody cared, the bodies were just carried away. They did emergency welding of parts not fitting together on site on the 30th floor, and so on. The higher the less it fit. They didn't care about proper procedures. It was a nightmare. Only when the Chinese realized it doesn't work this way, they gave the next projects to established european companies with experience, which didn't have to outsource their planning and construction, everything started to work out properly. Nowadays I'm incredibly proud of the changed Chinese engineering culture. They've surpassed Japan in all measures.
- tomatotomato37 8y agoI may be talking out of my ass here, but aren't architects more equivalent to product designers, with the structural/civil engineers actually being most similar to software engineers in having to implement the design?