7 ms·
Can we make a law that all data collected by devices that I bought belongs to me? Yes, that includes everything the websites I visit send back to the mothership
by adrianN 8y ago
Can we make a law that all data collected by devices that I bought belongs to me? Yes, that includes everything the websites I visit send back to the mothership.
- pgeorgi 8y agoYou mean GDPR?
- adrianN 8y agoNo, I mean all data, not just PII. If a Nest measures the temperature in my house I want to own those data points.
- JBReefer 8y agoI get your point but I think arguing information about the state of your home is PII would be fairly straightforward.
- pc86 8y agoThen pick any non-PII data point you like.
- anywhichway 8y agoThat doesn't really work because if it isn't PII, then they don't know who it belongs to (not having even your name is a field, or else it would be PII) and can't verify it belongs to you before giving it to you. Like visiting websites while not logged into anything in generating tons of data, but it can't be easily linked back to you. It would be possible to link some of it back to session IDs or other things you could be linked back to your device, but that doesn't show it was you using the device, so they may be releasing data belonging to someone else using your device to you. And that is before we get into possibilities like cookie hijacking or other methods of falsely tying your device to that generated data.
- rando444 8y agoYou're bringing up a separate argument. One worth having, but not in this thread. The argument here is that the company knows who the data belongs to, and the person above is saying that they shouldn't be able to abstract "you" away from the data and claim it as their own property.. especially because, as we know, most anonymization techniques have serious flaws that in fact do allow individuals to be identified after close scrutinization.
- ams6110 8y agoThen, and I'm being serious: don't put a Nest in your house. You know what these things are, and you know what the company who makes them does.
- criddell 8y agoNest shouldn't have any rights to that data any more than Microsoft should have rights to novels written in Word.
- adrianN 8y agoI don't have a Nest, but it becomes increasingly difficult to buy things that don't produce data. I think we should adapt our laws before everything you can buy is "smart".
- lucb1e 8y agoIt's often data about you, in which case it's linked to you in which case it falls under GDPR. This crash data is definitely about you, as general driving data would be. Your home's temperature won't be, so GDPR indeed won't apply there, but GDPR is a good first step. (I mean, EU already had it since 1995, but in USA it would be a good first step.) I agree that your proposal would be a good extension. Or at least that it should be the default, and you'd need to sign for being okay with not owning the data. Or that those devices contain warning stickers.
- rjmunro 8y agoIf the nest information is tied to your address (which is clearly personal), doesn't that make it personal information?
- lucb1e 8y agoIf they can retrieve whose house it was, then yes. But if they send it to the mothership and aggregate or anonymize it, then not. For example if they show you your house's temperature history, I assume it falls under GDPR because it's tied to your account so it's included with data about you.
- rmc 8y agoThe temperature of your house at certain times can be used to figure out when you were at home, what rooms you were in, when you went to bed, if you're just at home alone, or someone else was at home when you were there too. Sounds like PII!
- dfxm12 8y agoIf that law gets passed, you'll no longer "own" the device you bought that collects that data, but will be granted a license to use it.
- adrianN 8y agoI'm sure clever lawyers can come up with a definition of "own" that excludes such trickery.
- delbel 8y agoit would be funny to write license agreements for money. They don't actually "own" the money you "gave" them, you just grant them a license to use your money. Just reciprocate the license. Just put the EULA sticker on all your big bills and they are forced to whatever you want, right?
- Retric 8y agoLaws are flexible, it's easy enough to cover that loophole.
- teddyh 8y agoWhen computers were new, IBM would not sell computers to customers, but rent them out. Since most people nowadays seem to pay for cell phones, tablets, etc. in monthly installments and “need” to get a new model as soon as the one they have is fully paid off, I’m sure a jump to leasing/renting devices is a very small one in practice.
- noer 8y agoYou already are renting/paying a monthly use license fee if you "buy" a phone from your carrier with a monthly payment and the ability to upgrade after x months. I did this by accident when I "bought" an iPhone a few years ago and was told I couldn't keep it after I water damaged it and got a replacement. I started buying devices outright after that.
- 8y ago
- kodablah 8y agoThe question is, if it belongs to me, can I voluntarily give it up even under the known condition I can't ask for it back? I mean, it belongs to me right? That's where these laws often run afoul. You can have more freedom with consequences, or less freedom with restrictions.
- bambax 8y agoData isn't "property", it should be an unalienable right, like an author's moral rights over his work: it's yours but you can't sell it or otherwise dispose of it.
- jrs95 8y agoIsn't authors selling the rights to their work basically how the entire book industry works?
- adrianN 8y agoSelling the rights to publish your book is different from giving up all the rights you have over your book. The latter is something that (IANAL...) you can't do in many jurisdictions.
- dsr_ 8y agoThat's the copying right, not the moral right. The moral right is the right to be identified as the creator and the right to maintain the integrity of the work in subsequent copying.
- kbenson 8y agoSo, they can't sell that, as the GP is proposing, or they generally just don't under the current economic system? Because I'm pretty sure Dean Koontz does a variation of this, where he outlines the story but someone else actually writes the book, and it's published under his name.
- 8y ago
- yumraj 8y agoI'd like to go one step further and want the power to delete it, or be deleted, when I want. If I'm allowed to take the 5th to not incriminate myself and not reveal my memory (data in my head), I should be similarly allowed to delete my data when it is my data in my device. It'd be an interesting case to take to the Supreme Court.
- FireBeyond 8y agoI think they would view that as destruction of evidence. The next step in your scenario is "that security camera has data on me, I want it deleted".
- kofejnik 8y agoI believe GDPR does cover the security camera scenario, there was a comment here about a week ago from someone who successfully petitioned the German police to delete all footage of him at some protest
- Skye 8y agohttps://ico.org.uk/your-data-matters/cctv/ https://ico.org.uk/your-data-matters/cctv/ at least in the UK, you can request people who have CCTV footage of you, and also note that people have to delete CCTV when they no longer need it (how long that should be is arguable), so people have to delete CCTV without being prompted to. and this is not new with the GDPR, it's from the old law, from 1998, I think.
- yumraj 8y agoNot really, especially if the cameras are 3rd party owned. My comment was explicitly about my own devices, with the argument being that they are an extension of my brain/memory as opposed to evidence in the traditional sense. The link provided by wang_li applies and it seems such questions have come up in the past in front of courts, and honestly I won't be surprised if they come up again.
- wang_li 8y ago
- jimmaswell 8y agoThere's no real justification for anyone having that right. The device manufacturer/website owner/etc does the work of creating the data, yet you think it's yours?
- kofejnik 8y agoNo, it's my device that creates the data, so it is mine. Otherwise, does the typewriter manufacturer own the stories you type?
- cblades 8y agoI don't think that analogy holds up. Maybe: does the typewriter manufacturer own meta data such as letter frequency, average work length, etc that their product calculates based on your usage?
- kofejnik 8y agoNo, of course not. Once money exchanged hands, it's not their product, it's mine, as is _all_ of its output, including logs, etc. Otherwise, I'd call it 'spyware'.
- jimmaswell 8y agoThis already isn't the case in many instances where you don't actually "own" the thing, you just have a license to use it.
- insulanus 8y agoI agree that you should own the data that was created because of your interaction with the device, but I do not agree that the reason is that you own the device. Here's an example: You go to the library (or a privately owned web cafe), and write your stories there. It doesn't matter that you don't own the device. It's still your data.
- staplers 8y agoIf I kill someone with a hammer, is that the hammer company's liability? If not, then creation of an object (once sold) does not warrant ownership of said product and accompanying data.
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoSo, if you have a DSLR camera on a tripod set to a timer, and you do not actually take the picture, you have no claim to copyright of that image, even though the device you owned created it?
- Analemma_ 8y agoThe court system is not, in fact, a dumb automaton that is bamboozled by questions like this.
- delbel 8y ago... Yet. I read this in a cynical 90's AT&T commercial "You Will..."
- FireBeyond 8y agoWasn't this a copyright claim against Wikipedia, where an ape picked up a camera and took a selfie, and Wikipedia et al decided that meant the camera owner had no copyright claim over the image?
- gm-conspiracy 8y agoyes.
- Dylan16807 8y agoTimed photo definitely has copyright. Continuous surveillance footage is an open question. But the post you're replying to wasn't about copyright at all.