13 ms·
the entire FB and Google business models cannot suddenly change to move away from user data collection They can though - they can go back to untargetted advert
by onion2k 8y ago
the entire FB and Google business models cannot suddenly change to move away from user data collection
They can though - they can go back to untargetted advertising based on page content as they were doing 10 years ago. All the personal tracking data is a layer on top of that tech aiming to improve the 'targettedness' of adverts. Nothing in the online ad industry really needs any of that personal data, and arguably it doesn't actually make many ads more effective anyway.
- hyperbovine 8y agoLook at the revenue of those companies 10ya vs. today.
- mapleoin 8y agoCorrelation does not imply causation.
- onetimemanytime 8y agothey are certainly not charging less for targeted ads, the opposite is true.
- Maro 8y agoNot strictly related to this discussion, but perhaps worth sharing. I worked at a smaller tech company, and we kept saying "Correlation does not imply causation", and trying to come up with ways to separate them, etc. We spent/wasted a lot of time on this, explaining it to non-mathy people (which leads to even less confidence in data). Then I went to work at one of the big tech companies, which is probably one of the best in the world at testing/data for product, and there I never heard it. If there was correlation, unless it was clearly spurious or a statistical fluke, they pushed on it hard. "It looks like more X means more DAUs. So let's manufacture more X." And it works pretty well for that company. My takeaway is, I stopped thinking about this too much. Today, if there's correlation, unless it's clearly spurious/etc, and unless somebody has a better idea, I tell the product/eng team to push hard on it and don't even mention correlation vs causation.
- syastrov 8y agoI have experienced the same thing myself, but I would explain it differently. Even in science where the focus is actually on proving things, it is difficult to prove causation. I see this more as a question of whether you act on a correlation that you’ve discovered or whether you simply talk about it. While it’s fine to discuss things, it sounds like at the small company you worked at, that that was more important than taking action (or perhaps the company was too insecure to make a decision about what to do). At the big company, the focus was on making experiments and seeing what the results are, and then iterating on that. In the end, the business doesn’t care whether something causes something else, it is only interested in adjusting things, measuring results and if they increase some important metrics, then the business is happy. That said, it can be taken to an extreme where only the metrics are thought of as important, rather than other qualitative or hard-to-measure things. It is much easier with web companies who can quickly roll out changes and use AB testing to run experiments. Also, those companies with larger user bases will have better sets of data on which to base their decisions. Companies that are well established will also have historical data that will make it easier to interpret results. It also sounds like at the first company, the tech team was interested in being theoretically correct, while at the second one, the engineers were interested in trying things. It is an understandable problem in some ways: good programmers are lazy and won’t want to make unnecessary changes, so they tend to argue against changes that haven’t been proven ahead of time to yield results. However, for the business to thrive, knobs must be adjusted and experiments made. And those programmers have to turn the knobs (or make them adjustable by someone else). So there is a strong counter-motive at play there. However, good programmers who are also engineers with a focus on the product / business will understand the importance of doing this. It’s important for the engineering team to be aligned with the business and it helps to have cross functional teams. Otherwise you may end up with departments protecting their own interests. See also Conway’s law and its derivatives.
- alien_at_work 8y ago>Today, if there's correlation, unless it's clearly spurious/etc, and unless somebody has a better idea, I tell the product/eng team to push hard on it and don't even mention correlation vs causation. Because it's actually a stupid thing to say. Correlation does not conclusively prove causation would be better. It certainly gives a sensible place to look.
- TomK32 8y agoLook at the userbase of the internet and those companies 10ya vs. today.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- adventured 8y agoThere's nowhere else for the ad money to go. If less personally targeted online ads are the sole option, then that's the sole option. The ad money will go where the user attention is, which is increasingly online. Besides, for Google, they don't need Facebook style personal targeting. When you search for womens shoes, they feed you ads for womens shoes, it's a wildly lucrative approach and it doesn't matter if you're 28 or 34 years old, or what your favorite music is (yes, there are gains to be had with more personalized ad targeting even in that case, it doesn't matter, Google's model is still an extreme money machine). Radio, newspapers and TV were absolute dogshit for targeting for the prior 60 years. It was mostly blast and pray. At least with the Internet, even with less personal targeting, you still gain a lot of tech capabilities to improve ad systems (including intricate content targeting, matched with information on the demographics that like that content, and so on).
- paulie_a 8y agoIt is astounding that with all that tracking data ad quality has not actually improved in 20 years. They are still garbage ads that are still rarely relevant.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bojan 8y agoFor days after I make a purchase I keep seeing ads for the very thing I have already purchased.
- Maro 8y agoEven at big tech companies, a lot of those ML models are fed by nightly jobs, so updated once a day. If the targeting occurs on an outside property, there may be more delay. So if you make a purchase on day X, you should expect to see the ad for another ~48 hours. That's assuming there's logic which actually de-targets you post-purchase.
- oldcynic 8y agoEven Amazon don't get this right and should have unbeatable knowledge of when the sale completes. Their helpful suggestions still only seem to work usefully for books and music.
- Mvandenbergh 8y agoI suspect that's because those are the only things that are easy to model. People buy them: a) based on personal taste b) in volume I just bought a ladder on amazon, what information does that tell them? Since it's the only tool I've bought from them it doesn't tell them much. They now know that I might be willing to buy more tools from them in the future but doesn't help in targeting which kind or how often. Me being a ladder buyer is a very weak signal that I will buy any particular item from them. If on the other hand, I've bought 15 Aubrey Maturin books from them over the last few months, it doesn't take the most sophisticated model to determine that I probably want to buy number 16 next. Or that I might like to read the Horatio Hornblower books.
- zaidf 8y agoarguably it doesn't actually make many ads more effective anyway Source?
- nabla9 8y agoYou make an error when you assume that targeted ads should improve user experience to work.
- rmc 8y agoIs that economically viable now? Can FB survive on that sort of adverts?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- criddell 8y agoProbably. My medium sized city has several OTA television stations that survive partially on untargeted advertising. Ads shown to the relatively small audience supports the running of a significant amount of equipment including broadcast antennas, satellite uplinks, a helicopter, several vans with lots of radio gear in them, servers, a staff of on air personalities and all the other people required to run the station. How much infrastructure does Facebook need to serve this city? Facebook will be fine.
- w0m 8y agoThough they are still targeted insofar as show X attracts demographic Y so gets Ad Y. Targeting has become a boogieman I think.
- criddell 8y agoI have no problem with targeting an audience. Afterall, Cosmopolitan attracts a different audience than Guns n Ammo. It's the individual targeting that has such high costs (in resources and privacy) for an apparently small increment in effectiveness.
- roemerb 8y agoUnfortunately, even if they did that, a lot of their other products would suffer as things like Assistant etc. depend on the personalised data collected from their users internet traffic.
- celeritascelery 8y agoBut google assistant is on device, so it is not hampered by these sort of limitations.
- Iv 8y agoAnd actually they will have to. Their business model is becoming illegal in EU and I suspect that fines will start raining in a year or two.
- hedora 8y agoOn the other side of the coin, targeted advertising is a way to get viewers of high-quality content to view your ads without paying a premiums to the people and institutions that produced the premium content. This saves money for the advertisers, by transferring wealth away from content creators. It boggles my mind that publishers still favor this model over display ads (targeted to articles, not readers).
- SN76477 8y agoDepth of targetting is the easy button for the modern marketer.
- ucaetano 8y ago> This saves money for the advertisers, by transferring wealth away from content creators. Not really. It actually increases the pool of money available to content creators. Everybody wins. > It boggles my mind that publishers still favor this model over display ads (targeted to articles, not readers). Because they generate more revenue, I'd guess. Mind-boggling, I know.
- kstrauser 8y ago> Everybody wins. Well, except for the people being targeted, and the ones being served malware, and the ones having their cross-Internet activities being tracked, logged, and analyzed. It's not such a win for them.
- ucaetano 8y ago> Well, except for the people being targeted They win too. They get content without having to hand over cash. Everybody wins because the value of what they are giving is, for them, less than they are receiving. And the value of what they are giving, for others, is more than what others are giving. Going back to non-targeted ads would significantly reduce monetization, reducing the pile of money available to content creators, and driving many (if not most) of them out of business. You can always not access any ad-funded content or service, the option is yours. Take it.
- w0m 8y ago> and arguably it doesn't actually make many ads more effective anyway. I think this would be a contentious point, the advertising giants have invested significantly in targeting based entirely on their metrics of it actually working, random anecdotes aside.
- notheguyouthink 8y agoI really hope some sort of media subscription service becomes common place. If I want to read articles online, I'd love to pay $10/m and have it go to the content creators. Ads for me are unacceptable, but I'll happily pay, and I barely even read tech articles. The specifics of the implementation would have to be very consumer friendly though. Ie, I can't imagine I make all sites combined more than $1/m from my ad traffic each month.. maybe that's not true, I just don't see it happening. So I don't want to (as a consumer) pay $5/m per site or anything silly like that. That's why as a consumer I like the idea of splitting an amount (say, $10/m) up between all places I go. I remember a service like that... flutter I think? It never caught on though, because people don't like paying. We've got a tough hill to climb in this ad war, heh.
- JeremyBanks 8y agoThis is objectively false. Ad conversions are indeed way more efficient than they have been in the past. Your scorn doesn't change the facts