10 ms·
GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016)
- OJFord 8y agoI thought this was interesting to re-read in light of Microsoft's (reported) acquisition of GitHub; it was previously discussed a bit at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12131844 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12131844 But closed as dupe due to another similar company blog post on the front page.
- miguelrochefort 8y agoWhat if Microsoft open sources GitHub?
- tedeh 8y agoMay be hard to explain to stock holders looking for return on the acquisition...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mnky9800n 8y agoMsft has been doing a good job of giving a return while also open sourcing everything.
- tedeh 8y agoSay what? Open sourcing everything?
- unreal37 8y agoMicrosoft is the largest public user of GitHub, with the most number of checkins to open source projects. Gasp! [1] https://medium.freecodecamp.org/the-top-contributors-to-github-2017-be98ab854e87 https://medium.freecodecamp.org/the-top-contributors-to-gith...
- jbigelow76 8y agoThe code maintainers that (now) want an open source hosting solution are leaving anyway. Microsoft also already owns a git-as-a-service solution in Visual Studio Team Services. My take is this is another way to get closer to people and orgs that will probably need cloud services of some sort, so make it as easy as possible to choose Azure. I think the OP makes an excellent suggestion, as a dev and a (infinitesimally small) shareholder I would be for it 100%.
- fnord123 8y agoOne click GitHub Enterprise deployment for Azure.
- veidr 8y agoMy take on that is: a.) A huge part of GitHub's value is their default-ness. Anybody can build a website UI to git, although it is a lot of engineering work. Gitlab and Bitbucket are somewhere in that equation. People uneasy about MS are all over the Internet talking about moving off of GitHub today. MS announcing that they are open-sourcing GitHub would instantly evaporate a lot of that doubt/resentment/NOFUCKYUOM$!!!!URRRGH. b.) They could also open-core it, not totally open-source it, just like GitLab. Thereby keeping basically all of the more-lucrative enterprise business (that's probably way more comfortable with Microsoft anyway).
- jasonlotito 8y ago> They could also open-core it So, literally not open sourcing it, which defeats the purpose.
- chemicalcrux 8y agoThat defaultness is huge. I often catch myself conflating "Git" and "GitHub" because they've been so tightly coupled for me for years.
- test6554 8y agoThe main thing github gives microsoft is a pool of people it can try to push into Azure. Azure means that Microsoft no longer needs to care whether you develop apps for windows or linux or mac, or the web. As long as you make and deploy apps to Azure, you can use whatever stack you like. For that reason, they have a strong incentive to keep people happy and on github, and they have a huge incentive to make it easy to deploy from github to azure with a single click or something similar.
- peterwwillis 8y agoIt ties in nicely with the other open source (compatible) solutions they're trying to make money off of right now. The money is in GitHub Enterprise, and in how they can roll the product's workflow, issue management, and huge developer base seamlessly into their cloud offerings. They don't lose any customers by open sourcing it. Nobody's going to use GitLab if they can just download GitHub, and companies will still pay for Enterprise because they still need support for their massive investment in GitHub's extended features.
- veidr 8y agoI am sad this HN topic isn't trending up more, because THAT would change EVERYTHING. (By which I mean everything whiny MS-skeptics have said today (myself included).) It would be a knockout PR move, suddenly sucking all the wind out of the sails of all knee-jerk-antiMicrosoftism surrounding this acquisition. Satya, bro, you should really take a page out of Apple's playbook, and announce right now that you are going to. (That way, whether you really do[1], or you don't[2], most people won't remember the idea anyway...) [1]: https://swift.org https://swift.org [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FaceTime https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FaceTime
- jasonkostempski 8y agoI think the people having these reactions aren't going fall for any PR stunts, no matter how grandiose. Even with the OSS they have, they're constantly undermining the spirit with opt-out telemetry, some even forced, in fundamental tools, and they are unapologetic about it. Even if they announced they were taking all that out, I wouldn't trust it to last, or that they wouldn't use that PR to leverage something even worse.
- bradrydzewski 8y agofwiw gitlab also has opt-out telemetry that includes identifiable data such as instance hostname https://docs.gitlab.com/ce/user/admin_area/settings/usage_statistics.html#usage-ping https://docs.gitlab.com/ce/user/admin_area/settings/usage_st...
- sverhagen 8y agoNot an Apple follower, could you explain the "Apple's playbook" reference?
- veidr 8y agoOh, it's in those two footnotes: Apple pre-announced that they were going to open source Swift, and then they did, and they did a great job and there was much rejoicing. But there was some skepticism, because Steve Jobs had previously announced they were going to open-source their FaceTime technology so non-Apple platforms could adopt it and it could become a cross-platform communications system... but they never did. Both announcements got people excited, though. EDIT: Okay, my bad; I stand corrected. I remembered him saying that in 2012, but I googled it after lowtolerance disputed my claim, and what he actually said was, "We’re going to the standards bodies, starting tomorrow, and we’re going to make FaceTime an open industry standard.”
- dis-sys 8y agoballmer will have a heart attack.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoI too wonder if they would. It would be for the best if they did. They have a lot more to gain if they did and GitHub already has an enterprise self hosted option so I assume its already generic enough code wise to be redeployed anywhere.
- Aardwolf 8y agoThat won't help with the hosting, the github.com URLs of tons of public projects, the community, followers, etc...
- exikyut 8y agoOh boy the amount of language and infrastructure tooling that's going to change from "code hosting" to "supports github and gitlab" GitLab should treat GitHub as S3 and copy everything. I don't mean the git part, I mean the GitHub API bits that run on top.
- Aardwolf 8y agoI don't fully understand what you mean, please help me understand. Why would the generic term "code hosting" change to two brand names, and what does S3 have to do with all this?
- exikyut 8y agoSure, sorry. By "code hosting" I mean that most places say "we support code hosting" but in reality their systems are only setup to work with/use github.com; the domain at the very least, and possibly the API on top of that. Now places are going to have to generalize a bit, at the very least by thinking of multiple domains. There are undoubtedly going to be tiny differences between how gitlab handles things; those will surface over time. They probably won't make headlines, but they'll cause tiny localized headaches. As for S3, I mean that the GitHub API (issue tracking, etc) is all non-git proprietary stuff. GitLab should copy that so people's workflows Just Work™. I have no idea if they've already done this, I'm sure they've considered it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kakwa_ 8y agoI'm not sure it would be really useful. Github is more a service than a software, you need tons of components to make it work (Elastic Search, a DB, haproxy or nginx, a lot of ruby, a few C/C++ libraries, a few python libraries, etc) it's a big beast. I know they provide VM images for Github Enterprise, but IIRC, it was quite a big beast, requiring at least 16GB of RAM a fast CPU with many cores and a large disk last time I looked (3 or 4 years ago). And there was a lot of stuff in that image. If I had the source code, I'm not sure I would be able to properly deploy it and maintain, even with some documentation. Too many moving parts. And I feel a lot of sysadmins would be in the same situation. There are some services that open source there code. Travis-ci is the one I've in mind, yet I don't know of any deployments outside of travis-ci.
- irq11 8y agoYeah, well...Gitlab is also built on libgit2 and rugged. The core libraries that power Gitlab’s interaction with Git? Those are open-source projects written by Github. I did some work with libgit and rugged and said to myself that I was shocked Github was open-sourcing such a core competency...these libraries make it pretty easy for an average web programmer to build their own Github. Github has been pretty damned generous to the open-source community, and it’s sad to see a fast-follower project use this kind of rhetoric successfully.
- kbutler 8y agoAcknowledged in the article: """GitHub very actively contributes to open source themselves, including many contributions to Git and Ruby on Rails, and releasing libraries and applications like libgit2, Atom, and Hubot. Also note that we build GitLab with software that GitHub open sourced such as libgit2."""
- dnomad 8y agoThe article is profoundly dishonest. They've built their whole company on open source code provided by the "closed source company" Github. Here's the truth that so many seem to be in denial about: it is "closed source" companies like Google, Microsoft, Facebook, IBM and Oracle that produce the overwhelming majority of high-quality open source software. It's not even close. Over the last ten years these companies have given away billions of dollars in value in the form of open source software. These companies have done much more for open-source than GitLab and their buggy Javascript ever will.
- dis-sys 8y agoWondering whether Microsoft has ever acquired any major open source project/product? from memory, minecraft/skype/github are all closed source stuff. It is also pretty amazing that Microsoft still refuses to open source any of its major products like Windows, Office, SQL Server or even Visual Studio - even when most of them have better open source alternatives. If you look, the most embarrassing thing about Microsoft is that they pretend to be embracing open source under the new CEO, yet their entire WSL joke aimed for running linux apps on Windows is not open sourced. There are numerous WSL bugs, there is an official github repo for WSL there but there is no WSL source code you can read. Maybe for Microsoft Open Source is still considered as a cancer?
- tgtweak 8y agoFor a company whose existence is largely due to selling software licenses, is this surprising? That being said, I wouldn't be surprised to see a larger open sourcing effort at Microsoft in the coming months/years. Let's hope they do it better than Oracle.
- oblio 8y agoIf .NET, Powershell, VS Code are any indicators, they're getting really, really good at Open Source stuff. They run a really tight ship and all it takes is to point it in the right direction. Just look at this: https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/50477 https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/50477 It's basically their May 2017 release plan for VS Code 1.24. Fully public. My guess is that they're preparing some major announcements, I think at some point Windows will be Open Sourced and the consumer editions will be free. Basically we'll all be beta testers for the Pro and Enterprise editions. Which is not half bad, if they ramp up QA a bit.
- mikece 8y agoXamarin was also closed source and $1000 per platform per year (my employer at the time was paying $3k/year for the mobile devs to churn out iOS, Android, and Windows mobile apps from one Xamarin code bas). Immediately after being acquired by Xamarin the price was dropped to zero and it was announced that the entire Xamarin platform would be open-sourced (and this promised was fulfilled less than a year later). This is not the Microsoft of Balmer where Linux was called a cancer. Under Satya Nadella the company is serious about providing the best office and cloud products regardless of what OS you use.
- romanovcode 8y agoI have another one: GitLab is slow, GitHub is fast.
- dgellow 8y agoA more realistic one IMHO: GitLab is slow, GitHub is faster (but really, it's still slow).
- yani 8y agoIt is the opposite for me so not sure what you are talking about.
- exikyut 8y agoWell, it certainly will be for the next few days as GitLab wraps their minds around the new scale they're working with (<1k API calls -> 20k API calls \o/)
- dalore 8y agoGitLab is self hosted, and I don't know what you mean by slow? Just see what the bottleneck is (disk/memory/cpu) and use a higher powered instance. If you mean GitLab Hosted is slow? Well it's probably getting hosed and that's understandable. I did find that GitHub was slower for us though and had far less features.
- 0xfeba 8y agoI have this one static page that uses their API to list all pipelines across all projects. Like 50 API calls at once. It's usually terribly slow (1-2 mins to finish, sometimes more). Today it's the fastest it's ever been. <1 second to load.
- 0xfeba 8y agoWelp, back to normal now. Really slow.
- mikegerwitz 8y agoI also want to highlight what I wrote in 2015 about GitLab's commitment to free software: https://about.gitlab.com/2015/05/20/gitlab-gitorious-free-software https://about.gitlab.com/2015/05/20/gitlab-gitorious-free-so...
- exikyut 8y agoTwo questions: - What are the code/feature differences between CE and EE? - Does GitLab EE have a test VM version like GitHub does?
- lloeki 8y ago- Tiers: https://about.gitlab.com/pricing/self-hosted/feature-comparison/ https://about.gitlab.com/pricing/self-hosted/feature-compari... - Trial: https://about.gitlab.com/free-trial/ https://about.gitlab.com/free-trial/
- exikyut 8y agoInteresting. Each of those non-free features should be a link to a video. Possibly even the same video, with a time/position key.
- feduzi 8y agoI've been using GitLab for a while. And for me this looks like a PR move in the light of Github being bought by Microsoft. EDIT: did not notice post was from 2016. Has nothing to do with Microsoft buying Github. GitLab (not self-hosted) has constant deployment/stability issues. They do an update and sometimes GitLab is down for several hours. This is not a huge deal for me, as I can just push my code later. But the main concern I have is that recently they've just removed some free features in order (I guess) to force people to pay. Features removed (the only once I've noticed): - Merge requests: squash commits feature - Push rules: make sure users do not push commits with non-Gitlab user emails. - Protected branches: allow certain users to push/merge, not a whole role. There was no email notifying about this changes, it just happened that I've created a new repo, and then noticed some stuff missing. EDIT: Since this got traction. I've started digging to see the differences between repos. I have one group that is under "Early Adopter" plan, which has all the features mentioned. Recently I've created a new group, which went under "Free" plan, and this group does not have features mentioned. I wonder why the "Early Adopter" plan is not carried over to my new group. EDIT: From Gitlab blog (https://about.gitlab.com/2017/09/01/gitlab-com-paid-features/ https://about.gitlab.com/2017/09/01/gitlab-com-paid-features...): > For existing users on the Free plan, we've created a special Early Adopter Plan for you. This plan has all of the existing features available in our Silver plan, with the exception of additional CI minutes or premium support. Any group or user account created before September 1st will be put onto this plan for a year for free. While we will not add new paid features to this plan, you'll continue to enjoy powerful features, like multi-project pipelines and canary deployments, for the next year. After 12 months, you will get rolled back to the Free plan. You can upgrade at any time. Still personally feels like they're taking away free features, but just giving me a year to enjoy what I've already had.
- rwmj 8y agoWhat do people think of Pagure? (https://pagure.io/pagure https://pagure.io/pagure) I've used it a very little. They've unfortunately copied the terrible workflow around github "pull requests", except made it even more confusing. The rest of it looks reasonable.
- jwilk 8y agoGitHub might be closed source, but it doesn't matter that much in practice. The code is not where most of its value is. The value is mostly in large community of users and reliable infrastructure. Also, for me, GitLab's heavy reliance on JavaScript disqualifies it as a serious competitor to GitHub.
- phyzome 8y agoThe advantage of a large community of users goes away as soon as you can implement federated identity, which can be as simple as OpenID. (Heh, OK, could probably be simpler than that, too.)
- JeremyBanks 8y agoYou'd need to federate more than identity if you want to penetrate GitHub's network effect.
- akmittal 8y ago>Also, for me, GitLab's heavy reliance on JavaScript disqualifies it as a serious competitor to GitHub. How in the world using JavaScript makes a project less serious. Although Gitlab use mostly use Ruby and Go. JavaScript is used for Web UI only like most companies.
- foresto 8y agoI'm guessing the key word here is reliance. Some of us are fine with sites that use JavaScript, but only if the core functionality still works when scripts are blocked. If you're wondering why someone would feel this way, the reasons vary from person to person, but perhaps the best reason is that a site that becomes nonfunctional when client-side scripts are disabled puts itself at odds with basic web security precautions.
- memonkey 8y agoThat JavaScript isn't a serious programming language is a decade old understanding of the ecosystem and a disregard to the current day use of the language. A lot has happened in the last decade to make JavaScript "more serious" like NodeJS, TypeScript, and React. Even on the back-end, it's becoming more and more popular.
- EGreg 8y agoI have a major question about self hosted software like GitLab. As many of you know, I am a huge proponent of open source and the collaboration economy. I have put my money where my mouth is by reinvesting over half a million dollars from our startup company’s revenues into building the open source Qbix Platform, in the hopes of leading a revolution in all SAAS software, including the stuff where you need profiles, permissions, collaboration, notifications, realtime and social features on top of whatever you’re doing (git, editing a document, planning a trip). https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI Having built v1.0 recently, we began making backwards compatible changes to eventually turn the Federated model (communities = landlords) into a permissionless, end to end encrypted and secure model for everyone. It may take us another year: https://qbix.com/blog https://qbix.com/blog We are even making our own browser because the current browsers don’t have all the features we need to pioneer the whole vision: https://projects.invisionapp.com/m/share/TKHYMVSJNW2 https://projects.invisionapp.com/m/share/TKHYMVSJNW2 BUT here is the question I have. What is the best way to UPDATE the software on the back end? We want this thing to be secure. Discourse, Wordpress et al tell you about updates. That’s fine but how do you actually install them? By entering a password into a web interface you can get the web server user to replace all the core files of the installation? Isn’t that a vector for serious attacks? All the attacker has to do is somehow get your password or password hash, and it’s game over. They can send the right request to do arbitrary code execution. On the other hand, if a developer signs the new payload, this may mitigate things. It is what app stores do. Still, how do back ends get upgraded in self hosted open source software? In SAAS you just don’t worry about it. This is one area where we could use some professional consulting :)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- brodock 8y ago> BUT here is the question I have. What is the best way to UPDATE the software on the back end? GitLab has the Omnibus packages. We build it for few major linux distributions and you can get the package from here: https://packages.gitlab.com/gitlab/gitlab-ce https://packages.gitlab.com/gitlab/gitlab-ce (you can also add it as debian/rpm source, see installation). Upgrading is a matter of `apt update && apt upgrade` and checking for eventual configuration changes/deprecations in `/etc/gitlab/gitlab.rb`. If you read the release note posts, upgrade instructions are always on the bottom of the page. All packages are GPG signed, so you can check for tempering. If you don't trust our builds, you can fork our omnibus-gitlab repo and trigger a build on your own hardware.
- Aardwolf 8y ago"open core" sounds like a different word than "open source" to me why are none of the popular open source hosting providers fully open source? that's the least you'd expect of such service! wikipedia can do it after all, so it must be possible!
- geoah 8y agoBecause no one really wants to self host their own version of wikipedia. But many companies want and do host their code themselves.
- Qwertie 8y agoNo one wants to self host wikipedia but many self host wikis that are off topic for wikipedia.
- Piskvorrr 8y ago...and it has a yearly donation drive. Okay for a community project (in the sense of "steward to public data"), not okay for a service provider. And a service provider needs to cover costs - e.g. by running a customized, better version of the OS product.
- sGatling1788 8y agoThe elephant in the room is that GitHub is closed source yet is the one who sold for $7.5B.
- burkaman 8y agoThat seems irrelevant to this discussion
- nimbius 8y agoive been using gitlab for 3 years now in an enterprise environment, and the only complaint I have is lack of federation (albeit im told after the MS move, this is getting a lot more attention.) I have 1400+ projects and more than 700 users in 3 geographic locations using my server. backups with ruby fog libraries included in gitlab are taken once a night and im expanding the CI presence to include a kubernetes cluster. In short, Gitlab is worth it if you have the resources to deploy. If not, gitea is a great alternative as well. https://gitea.io https://gitea.io
- sytse 8y agoWe're open to federation, please see https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ee/issues/4517 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ee/issues/4517 and https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues/4013 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues/4013
- hunter23 8y agoI have also been using gitlab for 3 years. The main complaint I have is usability / UX. For example, if you go through their merge request flow, parts of the page are unreadable. Sometimes it feels like this: http://corsairmediaservices.com/images/blog/bad-interface.jpg http://corsairmediaservices.com/images/blog/bad-interface.jp... Unfortunately, I haven't seen much improvement on the design side. While their company has invested in design resources, it feels like every designer is focused on a specific feature. When you group those features into a page (like merge requests) you get this jumbled mess. Luckily after using the product for 3 years you start to have muscle memory of where things are but overall the design severely lags Github's.
- svesselov 8y agoOuch, that's a rough comparison @hunter23. We hear you though, there is a lot packed into that Merge Request area. I would love to hear what you think about this updated design https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues/37479#note_71376767 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-org/gitlab-ce/issues/37479#note_71.... "While their company has invested in design resources, it feels like every designer is focused on a specific feature. When you group those features into a page (like merge requests) you get this jumbled mess." Thank you for the honest and direct feedback. We work together as a team and try to keep a holistic view even as we iterate on specific features. We know we can do better here and are actively working to make things consistent and understandable. We have opened several epics dedicated to this, you can see them here: https://gitlab.com/groups/gitlab-org/-/epics?scope=all&utf8=%E2%9C%93&state=opened&author_username=sarrahvesselov https://gitlab.com/groups/gitlab-org/-/epics?scope=all&utf8=...
- briandear 8y agoThe marketing department of Gitlab seems especially active on HN lately. Why is this article being revived? This was already talked about two years ago. You know what is also open source? Git. I am not sure what the value is for having an open source clone of Github. Repositories can be changed in seconds thanks to git. So unless people are actually afraid of Microsoft reading private repos and can’t afford Github Enterprise, than I fail to understand why it matters that Gitlab is “open core.” Site reliability is far more important. I have never cared to look at Github source code. What for? It’s a utility for me like Dropbox or iCloud. GitHub and Github Enterprise have always worked great for me; as long as that continues to happen, why would someone like me care about Gitlab? Can anyone provide a specific benefit of Gitlab over Github? At the end of the day, what’s the value proposition?
- dang 8y agoI agree it isn't the best article to revive when there are fresh articles on the major news. But I don't think it's "the marketing department of Gitlab". It's just that a bunch of users want to talk about Gitlab and open-source generally in the context of the news. Same reason https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17223116 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17223116 was a huge thread yesterday.
- tbiteteitb 8y agoThe only thing keeping Us from deploying access to Gitlab to the rest of the Organization is the lack of multiple file upload in the Web UI Gitlab is really an amazing piece of software and We would like to have all the Organization on Board to handle Everything alas Redmine It's the only thing missing in our criteria or use case taking into account that Gitlab is not a software for the whole Organization and more oriented to software development. But adding a pair of things, it can be of use to all the departments in an Org