6 ms·
Are you sure about that? The stock market is not a mathematically defined process in the long run. It is still a gamble. Let's say you are investing in T-bonds
by csomar 8y ago
Are you sure about that? The stock market is not a mathematically defined process in the long run. It is still a gamble.
Let's say you are investing in T-bonds that generates a guaranteed 5% + inflation for 50 years. The lifetime of the US is, say, 500 years. After the lifetime of the US, the value of the USD drops by 100%.
So, yes, it is a good deal as long as it works. Some people are going to live 95 years and experience the stability and rewards of the T-bonds. Some people are going to invest for 10 years and lose it all. Some people are going to invest for 50 years and lose it all. Worse, if they don't diversify they'll be at an age where they can't generate wealth again (old).
You'll need a model of the USA lifetime to be able to determine the real returns + risks of the stable mutual funds.
There is no such thing as "compounding interest". Wealth doesn't compound like an e function. You are making money off someone else either "legitimately" by getting their work in exchange for your capital/risk. Or you are making money on a big, very long "ponzi scheme" known as "most world governments".
- AstralStorm 8y agoIt is not a Ponzi scheme if the returns do not exceed actual economic gains and taxes by which they are paid. Please do not misuse words for a libertarian strawman. Of course these bonds do drain money and other resources from economy so you are profiting of work (and taxes) of others. In a much more diffuse way than say dividend stocks or futures. The treasury bond is essentially a low return loan to the government, expected to be paid by economy via taxation and economic growth. If you do not invest in bonds you are taxed the same as someone who does. (Mostly.) Governments can and do default on loans, but more rarely than companies. The other form is by adjusting interest rate on the bonds.
- stephen_g 8y agoMonetarily sovereign Governments (US, UK, Japan, Canada, Australia, etc. but not e.g any Euro countries) never default on bonds/securities in their own currency. (Well, technically they could choose to, but only out of incompetence or malice, never by necessity.)
- AstralStorm 8y agoNever say never. That they have been too big to fail is currently a fact. Historically, monarch bonds which are a precursor to government bonds have defaulted. As have bonds of weak countries in severe crisis. (Argentina comes to mind.) It is a last resort of course. None of the countries you mentioned, not even China, are economically independent. Thus when one falls, the others will feel it. Monetary policy alone won't work if you have to combat huge inflation or deflation, it has been shown in past crises. (Especially US ones.)
- stephen_g 8y agoNo, actually never. The key words being ‘non-convertible currency’ (i.e. no longer having the artificial limitations of gold standard) and ‘in their own currency’. For example, my country’s federal Government can never run out of Australian dollars (we own the central bank!). But if I remember correctly, Argentina has a great deal of debt (like a lot of developing countries) denominated in foreign currencies. They can absolutely be forced to default on that. The Eurozone basically all use a currency they can’t control, so have similar problems if they don’t have a big enough trade surplus to compensate (like Germany does). Those problems were predicted from the very earliest days of a common currency being discussed, like by the great economist Wynne Godley in 1992 (London Review of Books, November issue if I recall). He wrote a great textbook on monetary economics in 2006 with Mark Lavoie which discusses this kind of thing. Inflation and deflation are a different issue, but can both be better controlled through fiscal measures (The monetarists’ fantasy that you can control everything just with interest rates is definitely wrong. It’s way too blunt a tool for the job).
- grey-area 8y ago1. Never is incorrect, lots of sovereign nations have defaulted. 2. A soft default is still a default for the investor 3. I’m confused by your characterisation of the US as a sovereign country vs the EU - they are both very similar federal groupings of states, just at different points on their lifetimes. US states have defaulted and some are at risk if it now.
- 8y ago