12 ms·
And yet it is kind of true. Consider that patents in their portfolio are exactly equivalent to unexpended ordinance, ready to go when the opportunity presents i
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
And yet it is kind of true. Consider that patents in their portfolio are exactly equivalent to unexpended ordinance, ready to go when the opportunity presents itself. How do you value that? A patent my go its whole life and never be infringed, or it might turn into a $500M payday from an Apple or a Microsoft.
- gwern 8y agoBut they have 95k patents and have done or backed scores of lawsuits with their $3b of capital. Surely that's enough! Y Combinator didn't need $3b to show good results despite regular VC having similar long-tail or hit-driven results.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoAll true, but how do you put an asset value on a particular patent? So if you've got a $100M fund and it spends $50M on acquiring patents and then the other $50M on prosecuting them as it can, it isn't possible to predict if one of the patents will be a gold mine or a dud. I think the closest thing I can imagine that would be like this would be mineral rights contracts. You spend $50M on mineral rights contracts on some amount of land and the rest on trying to develop useful resources out of those plots. If one has some easy to reach dense and salable minerals it pays for the others. But a plot that hasn't been geologically surveyed? What is it worth?
- gwern 8y agoWell, the value would seem to be somewhere below $3b, so that's a good place to start for assigning the average value over those 95k patents...
- gameswithgo 8y agothe price of gold could go up a bunch at any moment too. this isn't unique.
- nradov 8y agoThe only way to accurately value a patent portfolio would be to sell minority stakes in it on the open market. But if you expect to hold the patents until expiration and aren't short of cash then it's hard to see how valuation even matters.
- imranq 8y agoWhy assume the market is correct? Most people have no idea about the valuation of securities and patents are even harder to value
- nradov 8y agoIt doesn't matter what most people think. Only sophisticated, qualified investors are even able to bid on assets like fractional patent ownership. As for whether the market is "correct" that's a meaningless question since the answer can only ever be determined in hindsight. But so far no one has been able to find a more correct approach.
- greglindahl 8y agoThe only thing that matters is some LPs having to mark their holdings to market!
- barrkel 8y agoI don't think it's quite right to think of them as unexpended ordnance. They're more like signposted mines. In some ways they're only useful if they cover all possible paths through a solution space, since people can just avoid the minefield. How much overhead is there in trying to cover all the paths? Even if you're just trying to catch out the unwary (or explicitly ignorant) who don't look for the mines, coverage of most routes is still pretty important. This joint nature may affect value non-linearly, where A or B on their own are only worth X, but A and B together are worth 100X, or more.
- greglindahl 8y agoThis is not true, because almost no one reads patents. It's cheaper to do that almost all of the time than to always read and avoid them. Especially when you're avoiding patents that get invalidated in the end.
- notatoad 8y agoIf your argument is that there's no way to predict the future value of a patent, does it really have any value at all? If the patent game is basically a slot machine, investing in it shouldn't carry any expectation of return.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoPerhaps, it would be like lottery tickets as assets. But the point was that it could certainly be something that isn't covered well, or at all, by standard accounting methods and practices.