7 ms·
It is worth reflecting that, if Grace happened to be have a world outlook that was a smidge more venal and materialist, she wouldn't have been able to do what s
by roenxi 8y ago
It is worth reflecting that, if Grace happened to be have a world outlook that was a smidge more venal and materialist, she wouldn't have been able to do what she did. This is because dying with $7 million in savings means that she could have spent about $7 million more on enjoying herself in life.
I completely agree with her apparent outlook, and would rather have security and the pride of knowing I'd given a lot more to my fellows than I've taken back. And if everyone thought this way then society would be a lot better about preserving and growing what we have.
However, I've met countless people who behave like the executive in the opening paragraph not because they have 'bad behaviors', but precisely because they are clever and in practice wanted to maximise money spent/personal resources consumed. I doubt they would word that as harshly as I have, but the implicit meaning behind the behavior is very clear.
Now, if you start with a value proposition that the purpose of the economy is to maximise the resources available for individual consumption, it is actually quite hard to argue for dying with savings. The families who try to maintain inter-generational family wealth actually cop a fair bit of flack socially (in times of stress, they seem to near inevitably get branded 'hoarders', and times of extreme stress they have their wealth confiscated).
Basically, I like the argument and the value structure it comes from - but there are other views of the situation that are reasonable and deserve mention.
EDIT Fun fact, apparently $7 million gets you very close to the top 1% by wealth [1]. So technically, the sort of people who want "the 1%" to do more have people like Grace in their sights. We all know they don't want that, but it shows the normal attitude to wealth and savings imo.
[1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/050615/are-you-top-one-percent-world.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/05061...
- vorg 8y ago> because dying with $7 million in savings means that she could have spent about $7 million more on enjoying herself in life The point of much of the article is that dying with $7 million in savings means that she could have instead spent about $7 million more on enjoying herself, not in life, but on the day before she died. She probably couldn't have even enjoyed children and a car "in life".
- WalterBright 8y agoConsider the role of luck and risk. If you go to Vegas and gamble, your returns are pretty much luck. But for the casino, the quantity of bets makes their profits a virtual mathematical certainty, even though the outcome of each bet is luck. Transferring this idea to the stock market, outcomes from an individual stock have a high degree of luck, but an investment in an index of stocks reduce the luck factor by quite a bit and move towards mathematical inevitability.
- ouid 8y agothe central limit theorem only applies to uncorrelated random variables.
- csomar 8y agoAre you sure about that? The stock market is not a mathematically defined process in the long run. It is still a gamble. Let's say you are investing in T-bonds that generates a guaranteed 5% + inflation for 50 years. The lifetime of the US is, say, 500 years. After the lifetime of the US, the value of the USD drops by 100%. So, yes, it is a good deal as long as it works. Some people are going to live 95 years and experience the stability and rewards of the T-bonds. Some people are going to invest for 10 years and lose it all. Some people are going to invest for 50 years and lose it all. Worse, if they don't diversify they'll be at an age where they can't generate wealth again (old). You'll need a model of the USA lifetime to be able to determine the real returns + risks of the stable mutual funds. There is no such thing as "compounding interest". Wealth doesn't compound like an e function. You are making money off someone else either "legitimately" by getting their work in exchange for your capital/risk. Or you are making money on a big, very long "ponzi scheme" known as "most world governments".
- AstralStorm 8y agoIt is not a Ponzi scheme if the returns do not exceed actual economic gains and taxes by which they are paid. Please do not misuse words for a libertarian strawman. Of course these bonds do drain money and other resources from economy so you are profiting of work (and taxes) of others. In a much more diffuse way than say dividend stocks or futures. The treasury bond is essentially a low return loan to the government, expected to be paid by economy via taxation and economic growth. If you do not invest in bonds you are taxed the same as someone who does. (Mostly.) Governments can and do default on loans, but more rarely than companies. The other form is by adjusting interest rate on the bonds.
- EGreg 8y agoAnd if everyone thought this way then society would be a lot better about preserving and growing what we have. The Paradox of Thrift says that the economy would actually shrink if everyone saved to such an extent, and people would have less overall with time. Even Hayek remarked that individuals can save, not an entire country.
- roenxi 8y agoWell, sure the economy would shrink, but that is the point. There would be less demand for consumer goods, because preservation implies less consumption. Imagine a pretend happyland where everyone owned their own home and had a stockpile of 30 years of food. They change their usual work week to take Mondays off and sit comfortably at home. 20% of the economy literally disappears overnight. It isn't obvious that the anyone would be suffering. The reason the economy shrinking is so terrible is because people generally live hand-to-mouth. If you have enough resources stockpiled to last you the rest of your lifetime, you technically no longer need an economy. It is still nice to have and some resources can't actually be stockpiled (eg, a doctor's time) so I wouldn't advise doing without it, but the economy is mostly important because people don't stockpile resources. There seems to be a feeling that we should not stockpile resources because the economy is important. That line of thinking is very popular, but imo precisely backwards. Links the right things in the wrong order. Bit of a non-sequiter, but that thinking is why governments and central banks keep printing money. All this is an interesting but philosophical point. People, in the main, consume everything they have available to them and then work to earn more. EDIT It is notable that if no-one borrows then by definition no-one can make money by lending money. Again, although this is radical compared to what we do now, it isn't actually obvious what the problem would be. Again, it isn't advised because borrowing money for the purpose of investment is a source of fantastic economic efficiencies. The issue is we all know there is borrowing going on to fund consumption. That isn't a good idea, although the cost is carried by the people responsible so I have no beef with it happening.
- EGreg 8y agoLet’s take one vertical that people clearly need: food. Sure there’s non perishable food. But a lot of the food people eat is perishable. They have to keep buying it. Who is going to source the food if no one pays money to buy it? How will they pay for the operations to get the food? Now apply this reasoning to other verticals. In many fields, the investments lead to actual improvements in technology, and increasing automation and productivity. If everyone sits at home that only works if nothing ever breaks and no one needs improvements and technology. We’d still be using gas lamps if no one built electric stations etc. About debt you can watch this: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PHe0bXAIuk0 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=PHe0bXAIuk0
- dougmwne 8y agoI agree, yet have a slightly different angle on this. I doubt she had any great need to enjoy herself more and I don't see her not spending her savings on herself as a terrible waste. I do think it was likely a waste though. She was uniquely positioned to steward her own capital having worked and saved her entire life to gain it. By giving it away to charity by bequest she's really just throwing that money to the wind in the hopes that whoever finds it will have the motviation to use it better than she could. If you want to change the world, roll up your sleeves and change it. Throwing money at someone else and dropping the mic is not a great way to go about it. Further reading: https://www.ft.com/content/b66e3314-30fb-11e8-b5bf-23cb17fd1498 https://www.ft.com/content/b66e3314-30fb-11e8-b5bf-23cb17fd1... https://www.cnbc.com/2017/10/13/after-librarian-leaves-4-million-to-unh-critics-question-spending.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/10/13/after-librarian-leaves-4-mil...