3 ms·
I'm normally not the type to embark on wild conspiracy theories, but in this case I don't think the NSA actually believed it could push Speck into the ISO. The
by _hl_ 8y ago
I'm normally not the type to embark on wild conspiracy theories, but in this case I don't think the NSA actually believed it could push Speck into the ISO. The way Tomer depicts it, it sounds as if they almost wanted the process to fail; they made it a point to behave especially shadily.
Perhaps, and here begins my wildy unfounded speculation, perhaps Speck was an attempt at setting a carefully crafted example of how the NSA pushes a compromised algorithm in an attempt to lower the expectations of shady NSA operations - thus making their next, real attempt more credible.
But who knows.
- api 8y agoPossible but unlikely. Bureaucracies generally aren't that subtile. It is a good idea to be paranoid in crypto though. If I thought my adversary would be a nation state or anything else so powerful I would take a defense in depth approach of layering multiple independently developed systems using different algorithms and constructions.