5 ms·
That's where I am too. I mean, war stuff is bad, it kills people, and the US certainly isn't 100% trustworthy. At the same time... there's a real don't-rock-t
by ajross 8y ago
That's where I am too. I mean, war stuff is bad, it kills people, and the US certainly isn't 100% trustworthy.
At the same time... there's a real don't-rock-the-boat problem here. The last 3/4 of a century of US military dominance has been notable for a decrease in military/para-military violence on an order that humanity literally has never seen. It's not zero for sure, it's not always just, we may not always be the good guys, but seriously: if you are a random person anywhere in the world, you are vastly less likely to be killed by someone's bullet than you were pre-WW2. And that's important.
A world without a dominant US military is a world with fewer US-driven injustices. That doesn't seem like a good bet to be a "better world", though.
- cryptoz 8y ago> the US certainly isn't 100% trustworthy. The US is the most wildly insane, two-faced and upside-down country in the world right now in terms of military. The commander-in-chief routinely makes nuclear threats, actively hurts his own citizens in times of need, and seeks to decrease military stability by accelerating climate change and isolating his country from the world. The commander-in-chief lies about every single thing in his day-to-day life, as well as his political life; he is mentally unstable and not fit to serve. The US military is 100% untrustworthy as its direct leader has shown himself to be literally insane. > there's a real don't-rock-the-boat problem here The US is the one rocking the boat. It has already happened and it happens daily. > A world without a dominant US military is a world with fewer US-driven injustices. That doesn't seem like a good bet to be a "better world", though. I disagree. That seems like a very incredibly great bet, to me. The time of US military leadership is over. That happened the day our Military Commander In Chief stood on his inauguration day and lied about the number of people in front of him. Perhaps the US will return to a positive leading role one day, but it is not there now and it has not been for years. All this aside, I do not agree that Google is the right place to develop US Military technology. Edit: Additionally, the commander-in-chief of the US military also stated point blank that we may not have presidential elections any more in the future. This is not a time to champion US democracy, military might, etc.
- irq 8y agoInstead of downvoting cryptoz, I encourage people to counter what he said with their own replies. The majority of his statements in this post are verifiable facts. (I do not know this person, fwiw).
- Rexxar 8y agoI don't down vote him but I understand that some people want to keep political discussions out of this forum, especially when this is not directly related to the original submission.
- jds375 8y agoI agree. I’d guess that the downvoters are thinking along the lines of: - Sure it’s bad now, but the US military is made up of far more than just the president... many of which may be good, rational actors. - Just because it’s bad now doesn’t mean it won’t get better quickly (there has been a lot of pushback on the president’s agenda) - The US may still be comparatively better/benevolent than any other dominant superpower Note that these aren’t necessarily my views (I’d need more time to think and consider). But I think they point out some decent possible counter arguments to OP
- ajross 8y ago> Sure it’s bad now, That's the thing though: it's not bad now!. Not by any historical standard, at least. For most of our history and prehistory, right up to the past 70 years, stupid warfare has been the rule. Petty tribal disputes, armed insurrections, ethnic cleansing and suppression and random gang violence were absolutely routine for almost everyone even as recently as our great grandparent's lifetimes. Virtually everyone saw violence like this at some point. Now, in most of the world (no, not all of it, but yes: most), pretty much no one does. And that's important. What we've been doing is working. Don't rock the boat.
- jds375 8y agoI actually completely agree with you (Enlightenment Now by Pinker provides excellent data backing all of this up). Our collective pessimism is actually a major problem I think. But to clarify, when I said “sure it’s bad now” I meant that in the context of the current military leadership. Unfortunately I can’t really defend that argument much further given that I don’t necessarily agree with it (it was just speculation on potential counter-arguments).
- mikeash 8y agoFor most of that time, the US had an adversary that was roughly on par militarily, ahead in some areas and behind in others. The post WWII peace isn’t built on American dominance, it’s built on MAD.
- sitkack 8y ago> if you are a random person anywhere in the world, you are vastly less likely to be killed by someone's bullet than you were pre-WW2. You are spouting unsubstantiated nonsense.
- ajross 8y agoJust google it. This isn't even a controversial position, LOTS of folks in academic history love to point this out. Here's a quick slide show about exactly this effect: https://ourworldindata.org/slides/war-and-violence/#/title-slide https://ourworldindata.org/slides/war-and-violence/#/title-s... See page 6 for a charge that shows exactly the fact I was citing, though the data as a whole is much broader and worth reading. So now I'm "substantiated", I guess. You have numbers showing the opposite effect?
- sitkack 8y agoInteresting. I over reacted in the way I perceived how your statement was framed.