4 ms·
Maybe sue isn't the correct term, but you are talking about potentially a 20 million dollar fine. I'm being told that the EU would never pursue that with a sma
by danShumway 8y ago
Maybe sue isn't the correct term, but you are talking about potentially a 20 million dollar fine.
I'm being told that the EU would never pursue that with a small business and they'd just tell you what you need to fix.
That also sounds weird to me as an American. I'm not saying it isn't true, just that it's not the way I'm used to thinking about laws.
- DanBC 8y agoEuropean law tends to talk about the maximum available penalty under the worst possible situation. It then gives a list of factors to be taken into account. I'm not sure why that's a bad thing. Look at the US COPPA, with potentially $41,000 per violation. Why isn't this more scary for American website operators? https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/complying-coppa-frequently-asked-questions#COPPA%20Enforcement https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/com... > A court can hold operators who violate the Rule liable for civil penalties of up to $41,484 per violation. The amount of civil penalties a court assesses may turn on a number of factors, including the egregiousness of the violations, whether the operator has previously violated the Rule, the number of children involved, the amount and type of personal information collected, how the information was used, whether it was shared with third parties, and the size of the company. Information about the FTC’s COPPA enforcement actions, including the amounts of civil penalties obtained, can be found by clicking on the Case Highlights link in the FTC’s Business Center. I mean, any US website that's compliant with COPPA should find GDPR to be a doddle. https://corporate.findlaw.com/law-library/ftc-imposes-largest-coppa-civil-penalties-to-date-children-s.html https://corporate.findlaw.com/law-library/ftc-imposes-larges...
- danShumway 8y agoCOPPA is frightening to web operators, at least in the abstract. The majority of web services online at least make a cursory effort to either ban users under the age of 13 from accessing the site or force them to give parental consent. Technically speaking, if you're under 13 you're not really supposed to be on sites like Twitter. The equivalent reaction for GDPR would be if everyone either started making half-hearted efforts to block European users (which isn't what EU wants), or if everyone forced all of their users to agree to the same data collection before they signed up (which as far as I can tell is not legal). From the law: > However, an operator of a general audience site or service that chooses to screen its users for age in a neutral fashion may rely on the age information its users enter, even if that age information is not accurate. This line is basically the entire reason why COPPA is generally not seen as a problem for US businesses.
- briandear 8y ago> ..started making half-hearted efforts to block European users (which isn't what EU wants.. Are we sure about that? GDPR seems like a gift to European startups who don’t like American competition. BlaBlah car in France got huge, incidentally right around the time the anti-Uber hysteria in France reaches a peak. The sale of Daily Motion to Yahoo was blocked by the French government under ridiculous national economic interest grounds. Europe loves tariffs and trade barriers and they have a history of “protecting” the public from competition. Try shipping spare parts for a child’s stroller to France — I was taxed at 50% — the tax even applying to the shipping fee, not just the parts. My dad made the mistake of sending kids clothes to my kids with the tags still on them — $100 worth of clothes cost me €65 in duties. When I ship small amounts of stuff to the US, I literally have never had to pay a tax. The EU loves protectionism. Farmers literally set fires and throw rocks when Spanish wine crosses into France and the authorities don’t prosecute a single person. Now that EU countries have a bunch of lotteries tickets with American tech companies, the governments are likely foaming at the mouth with excitement over fining American companies. And, sadly, many people in Europe actually think this is about privacy.
- ttoinou 8y agoBlablacar has a different business model than Uber and Dailymotion is now useless because of government intervention. American startups have less to worry about than european ones, they have their non-GDPR market to address and grow, and we'll see in the future if extra european companies get fined (AND effectively pay) because of GDPR
- gliboc 8y agoBlaBlaCar is about carpooling, it is not a Uber ripoff, but you'd know that if you had travelled once to Europe. It is about different values - solidarity, ecology, social relationships - than just underpaying the guy-next-door to do anything you're willing to pay for with your smartphone. Otherwise the only person that seems to be "foaming a the mouth" is you, in this ridiculous Murica rant. Do I need to remind you that your country is just starting an economic war on the rest of the world with illegal customs taxes ? Also, enjoy getting scammed by your own ISPs now that net neutrality effectively got cancelled on you. You don't realize how little Europeans care about your precious American tech companies, and more about values such as not being the data points of international megacorps with shady business practices, or low-end programmers ready to milk people of all their data just to install a phone game.
- detaro 8y agoSurely US law also has fines proportionate to what has happened. E.g. EPA has hit large companies with multi-million fines for systematically polluting water over a long time, but if your small company makes a small mistake that's not the same. GDPR explicitly has a list of criteria to assess when determining the fine, and there's no reason to believe courts won't hold regulators to that. For past experience with German privacy regulators (as an example, since our old law was fairly strict too), I'll quote a recent comment of mine: From what I know, the German DPAs (they are organized on state level) hand out like 2 fines per month each, generally way below the maxima (under old German law, the max was 300000 €), and concluding the majority of cases without a fine. E.g. from the Bavarian DPA (german doc: https://www.lda.bayern.de/media/baylda_report_07.pdf https://www.lda.bayern.de/media/baylda_report_07.pdf, page 151): in the years 2015-2016 they had 173 proceedings that involved potential fines. 52 of those resulted in fines. 34 of those fines were <1k€, 13 were <10k€.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- danShumway 8y agoWell, I'll operate under the assumption that EU posters know EU governments better than I do :) If that's the case then I suspect you'll see fewer companies panicking over time. It may just take an adjustment period for companies to realize, "Oh, this legislation isn't actually filled with hidden land mines."
- matwood 8y agoI posted this above, but the old maximum fine from the ICO was £500k which was never used. The same people worried about being put out of business by the $20M max I guess were okay with close to the ~$750k max? For a lone website operator the new maximum is effectively no different than before. https://government.diginomica.com/2017/08/10/ico-maximum-fines-gdpr-will-last-resort/ https://government.diginomica.com/2017/08/10/ico-maximum-fin...
- petre 8y agoEven in the worst case scenario you have the option of going out of business and filing for bankrupcy if you are incorporated in the EU and do get hit by a 20M fine. The EU can certainly try to take that amount from the company, but if it's a Ltd. or Gmbh. or equivalent its liability is limited by its shares. Or you can incorporate outside of the EU (Guernsey or soon enough the UK perhaps?) and ignore the GDPR. At which point we'll just wait and see if the EU has any teeth outside its jurisdiction and how it will enforce this law.
- bigbugbag 8y agoThe only way to get hit by a 20M fine is to do something really wrong on a very large scale and ignoring warnings and refusing to fix it.