8 ms·
There were a couple points in there that could, may, should have been left on the cutting room floor. Some good points were made however. Social Security in i
by salawat 8y ago
There were a couple points in there that could, may, should have been left on the cutting room floor.
Some good points were made however.
Social Security in its original Ponzi-Schemesque form will end up even worse for wear with declining birthrates. (Not saying Social Security is bad in concept, but it only works in times of sharp population growth, and even then, banking on the youth to carry you just because seems squicky to many ).
The observation of millenials being reluctant to have children is also spot on. Many that I have spoken to in the demographic are very much a "lost generation". They've seen parent's and elder's life savings disappear.
They have a harder and harder time adjusting to a world that seems specifically tuned to resist and feed off of them. See financial product/debt product proliferation.
It's harder to find opportunity when one has an additional complication of digital footprint to manage with a dearth of interest in anyone older than them willing or interested in making sure the past engraved on the net doesn't mark them for life.
The hamfisted "feminist" overtones aside, the article makes a chilling point. Long cycle economic predation and the social pressures to avoid debt first and foremost are an effective suicide switch at the population scale. An entire generation has been shaped by these pressures, and with no relief in sight, a drastic shift in values may be needed to avoid a grievous societal destabilization.
Interesting times indeed.
- AIX2ESXI 8y agoGreat critical analysis. Generally, I avoid Vox articles due to the unsubtle feminist ideologies that are interwoven in their articles. Saw a recent cringe Vox interview with Jordan Peterson that kept trying put words in his mouth and avoided the issues he brought up as usual. Personally, I see the writing on the wall for America and am doing everything I can to move out of here in the next 4 years. As a young American cis gendered man in his 30's, I see no future for myself outside of being someone's mortgage hound or alimony sugar daddy. I can have a higher quality of life and and my SMV will be higher in most developing countries. I wonder if we will start seeing a massive exodus from America by professional Gen X/ millennials.
- devereaux 8y ago> I avoid Vox articles due to the unsubtle feminist ideologies > (...) recent cringe Vox interview with Jordan Peterson that kept trying put words in his mouth > (...) I see no future for myself outside of being someone's mortgage hound or alimony sugar daddy. That escalated quickly!
- soontobemd55 8y agoI feel this too. Most of my cis male friends won't date people that will make less money than them. I know I won't.
- kasey_junk 8y agoIs your intention to have a partner that walks in lockstep through career paths over the course of a long career? How do you intend to deal with illness, career changes & family raising?
- dominotw 8y agoI think lower earning person can make up by doing extra chores and house work. That's what I do now. Not sure how fair that is but I think it's fair.
- AIX2ESXI 8y agoYup. Most men will actually marry down economically, but women generally marry up economically. Perhaps when this is finally noticed, men will only marry their equals. With women graduating college at higher rates, perhaps this changes? https://www.smh.com.au/opinion/marrying-down-why-men-are-the-ones-now-looking-for-wealthy-wives-20170831-gy7ykl.html https://www.smh.com.au/opinion/marrying-down-why-men-are-the...
- Jedd 8y ago> Most men will actually marry down economically, but women generally marry up economically. If the first phrase is true, then the second must also be. Of course we're conflating income with wealth (or 'economical value'), which may be fraught. > Perhaps when this is finally noticed, men will only marry their equals. I think asking all men to think the way you think is going to be disappointing. I also think that proposing the evaluation of people based on income and/or economic potential is breathtakingly depressing.
- grawprog 8y ago...as much as I know it's pointless commenting on things... Here's my perspective. I'm thirty, I've been in a relationship since I was 17...the same relationship..we've talked about kids a lot...at this point...I really don't think even with both of us steadily working for several years now at decent jobs we can afford to raise a kid. We've agreed we don't feel like it's fair to raise a child without being able to provide a decent standard of life and our own standard of life ia not the best as it is, despite both of us working full time, with regular overtime, at skilled jobs. As far as online presence goes...clearly as I'm shadowbanned on here I haven't quite grasped the...uh...I would say subtlties, I suppose, of having a reasonable online presence. I haven't gotten used to the idea of the internet being a place where one posts real personal information, despite having been on the internet since the early nineties....I still see it as a place where identities don't matter and people who post personal information online are fucking idiots. In all honesty, i've never really participated much on online communities until recently but still go about it with that nineties mindset not really understanding people are fairly hypersensitive (a bunch of little bitches) to stuff online these days.. I keep a fairly strict separation between stuff I do on a computer online and everything else in my life. I realize it's a necessity to start mixing the two...but I find it hard to combine an online presence with my real life stuff. It's one of these thing's i've beeen working on though because i've found that's what all my friends and people I know have done.
- kartan 8y ago> (Not saying Social Security is bad in concept, but it only works in times of sharp population growth, and even then, banking on the youth to carry you just because seems squicky to many ). Social Security works with economic growth. It doesn't matter if you get 10 babies or 10 robots. Automation makes possible to keep proper living standards without exponential population growth. Social Security, as other services like education, stops working because it is not shared. Actually, with enough automation, it is easier to satisfy a smaller population. There are 3.5 million professional truck drivers in the United States. Self-driving trucks mean that you need 3.5 million fewer babies to carry out that task. Just 3 million if you actually need 500,000 people to maintain the software. So, I agree with you that in the past Social Security was depending on population growth. That has been changing fast for the past 50 years. There is no economical reason to not have Social Security in the future.
- darawk 8y agoI believe you mean that some theoretical structure vaguely like social security could work, in principle, without population growth. However, the social security system we actually have acquires its funds from the income of individuals. You could structure social security as a tax on capital, but that isn't how it currently works.
- kartan 8y ago> You could structure social security as a tax on capital, but that isn't how it currently works. Yes. 100% true. I just mean that it can be changed. It is not an economic constraint, but it is the current situation.
- koolba 8y agoSelf driving trucks don’t pay payroll taxes (as distinct from general income tax). The engineers and mechanics maintaining them do, but if the net cost of them plus the tech isn’t cheaper than the current human driving approach then the industry wouldn’t be switching to it anyway.
- chillwaves 8y ago
- crdoconnor 8y agoThe narrative that social security will eventually bankrupt the country (or the updated version: "it's a ponzi") dates back to its inception 80 years ago and it's been pretty consistent ever since: https://www.huffingtonpost.com/peter-dreier/post_9910_b_7988992.html https://www.huffingtonpost.com/peter-dreier/post_9910_b_7988... While the economy has grown about ~400% dependency ratios have gone up about 11% I think. Social security's affordability has always been about political choice - e.g. tax cuts for the wealthy or money for pensioners.
- sametmax 8y agoAlso a lot of people don't want children. It's a lot of responsabilities and constraints, so you need to feel the desired for it. The new generation grew with aids, feel less influenced by the authority selling the one family lifestyle and use more contraception. Now wait for Vasalgel to take off. When males will have total control of their involvment in pregnancy, you will see the numbers go down even more. And probably some serious changes in the man/woman dynamics.
- pavel_lishin 8y ago> Also a lot of people don't want children. It's a lot of responsabilities and constraints, so you need to feel the desired for it. This is true, but are enough people feeling liberated enough to not have kids to have this be a significant part of the lowered birth rate?
- sametmax 8y agoWell, health aside, to not have kids, you have to actively avoid it. Or be very ugly.
- u90g4u8904 8y agoThere's a problem with that argument. http://www.wbur.org/onpoint/2018/05/23/birth-rate-drop http://www.wbur.org/onpoint/2018/05/23/birth-rate-drop Stephanie Coontz, professor of history and family studies at The Evergreen State College: "I think the most important and concerning thing about this is not the number of people who are voluntarily childless, but the tremendous gap between the number of children women said they wanted to have and the number that they will probably have. Early this year, the gap reached its highest level in 40 years. I think we need to think very seriously about what it is that pushes people into this kind of 'delaying.'"
- sametmax 8y agoThere is a problem with that argument. You often need a man to make the baby.