4 ms·
Preferential attachment, power laws, rich-get-richer, winner-takes-all is just math. Life (fortune, luck) is intrinsically unfair. Explaining reality is not a
by specialist 8y ago
Preferential attachment, power laws, rich-get-richer, winner-takes-all is just math. Life (fortune, luck) is intrinsically unfair.
Explaining reality is not a moral statement.
Ignoring reality, or worse rationalizing it, is immoral.
Happily, thru the arc of humanity history, numerous societies have chosen to mitigate the unfairness. Some proven strategies are expanding the franchise (enfranchisement), redistributing windfall profits, debt jubilees, jobs programs, social safety nets.
- tzahola 8y agoYou forgot the guillotine from your list.
- xapata 8y agoTrue, though that brings up other ethical dilemmas.
- snackbugs 8y agoFor instance?
- xapata 8y agoThe guillotine? The ethical question is whether it is right kill someone. Most folks find that troubling in standard circumstances.
- snackbugs 8y agoI disagree; I think that most people would consider whether or not the guillotine is being used in service of justice, against cruelty to the powerless by the powerful.
- mhneu 8y agoYes. The authors basically explain the rich-get-richer macro phenomenon as a consequence of individual interactions. And it's easy to see this rich-get-richer phenomenon in action. Look at European football (soccer). There, once a team gets wealthy, it can buy the best players and continue to stay on top. That's the winner-take-all phenomenon right there. Sports in the US have addressed this winner-take-all problem with socialism. Baseball, American football, hockey, and basketball have drafts, where the best new players get distributed to the worst teams. Such non-market, socialistic practices work to the benefit of the league because they put all teams on a more even playing field. (Restrictions on the free agent market, the football scheduling difficulty increase with winning, arbitration, and max contracts are all also forms of socialism that act to restrain the free market for players). These are not bad examples of how completely free markets lead to unfair winners' advantages, and inequality. They also provide good examples of the kind of market regulations and protections that can level the playing field (no pun intended.)
- nateabele 8y agoThe talent pool in professional sports is actually a closed market that runs on the rules of the market operators (i.e. the MLB/NFL league administration). The capitalism/socialism comparisons are easy but wrong. True natural monopolies are exceedingly rare and usually short-lived — most monopolies created by government[0]. What we observe with startups and venture capital is no exception: the Fed's continuous monetary expansion policy has driven more money into more volatile investments as investors try to achieve 'escape velocity' on their returns, and success has a natural compounding effect. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r6LLQdpY7wU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r6LLQdpY7wU
- onion2k 8y agoBloody revolution with the peasant class murdering the elites has been quite a popular way of mitigating the unfairness in the past too. Possibly the most popular in fact.
- harry8 8y agoMost popular? Maybe. Least successful, definitely. It's the nuclear option of "to hell with it all, let's burn down everything we have including the hospitals and schools to get at /them/." You've already got an abject disaster when that really doesn't seem so bad.
- mistermann 8y agoBut in the past did the elites have a protection force as comprehensive and organized as the one they have now, all funded by the very people it is protecting them from?
- doorbumper 8y agoTaxes have existed for a very long time.
- mistermann 8y agoIndeed they have, but if you reread my comment you may notice that taxes were only one component of the comment. I'm noticing a distinct increase in ideologically motivated comments and a corresponding decrease in honest discourse. But then, why should HN be immune from it, it is fed by the same institutions as mainstream society.
- s-shellfish 8y ago> Ignoring reality, or worse rationalizing it, is immoral. What does it mean to be ignorant of reality?