3 ms·
How much of this ICO story is simply rediscovering things that old finance had already found? All this talk about being able to trust the entrepreneurs, that t
by lordnacho 8y ago
How much of this ICO story is simply rediscovering things that old finance had already found?
All this talk about being able to trust the entrepreneurs, that they were building a real business in good faith, it's not exactly a new problem.
The solution, before blockchain muddied the waters, was that you'd find a reputable investment bank, which would stake its reputation on your sincerity, and they'd introduce you to people who would be willing to invest. There would be a bunch of rituals to go through, like a road show, presentations, meetings. And that's not all; there was a regulatory process they would show you how to pass as well.
- wpietri 8y agoDefinitely. So much of cryptocurrency world seems hell-bent on rediscovering why current financial regulation exists. At one point in US history, it was relatively easy to create a bank, and the banks could issue their own private currencies: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildcat_banking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildcat_banking This provided relatively little value and quite a lot of failure, so it was taken as a "let's never do that again" lesson. The Etherium fork after the DAO theft was in my view people rediscovering the value of having a regulator. Given the regular and massive losses due to breakins, scams, and fraud, I have to wonder if this is the most efficient way to learn these lessons.
- jesusthatsgreat 8y ago> Etherium Is this a running joke or something? I've seen the misspelling of Ethereum several times now on hackernews and it's a tell-tale sign that the people talking about it haven't invested much time researching it or delving in to the space in any way. > Given the regular and massive losses due to breakins, scams, and fraud, I have to wonder if this is the most efficient way to learn these lessons. Where there is money changing hands, there are scams and fraud. The difference with crypto is that you can follow / track the money at all times. It doesn't mean you can get it back, but it does increase the chances that somewhere along the line the attacker will slip up and reveal themselves once they try to buy something or exit in to fiat currency. The bottom line is that crypto exists because the banking system is perceived as broken by many. It's slow, expensive and corrupt as far as the average person on the street is concerned.
- lalaland1125 8y ago"Ethereum" does not match normal English spelling rules, so native English speakers have a tendency to spell it in the "correct" way as Etherium. If anything, I would argue that "Etherium" is the more proper spelling and that we should migrate to that.
- wpietri 8y agoYes, that was indeed my mistake. Thanks.
- wpietri 8y agoI agree that fraud, scams, and crime happen everywhere. Which makes it a useless statement. My point is that it seems to happen way more in the crypto space than elsewhere. Are you claiming that it happens the same or less? If so, I'd love to see your data. Because I suspect comparing the failure rate of, say, IPOs vs ICOs would show a significant difference. And I think you're wrong about why cryptocurrencies exist. Philosophically they're rooted in an anti-government, technoutoptian, anarchocapitalist line of thinking. You could digitally transfer money for a decade before Bitcoin existed, and more if you count things like Western Union. It of course didn't really get going until the hucksters and the speculators discovered you could make a lot of money. At which point, any real effort to be "electronic cash" went out the window, because although deflation and volatility are bad for currencies, they're great for hype and speculation. Now we're at the point where Bitcoin is basically useless for what people normally use banks for: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/16/nyregion/new-york-today-living-on-bitcoin.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/16/nyregion/new-york-today-l... And even prominent Bitcoin advocates have given up on the idea it's a currency: https://avc.com/2017/08/store-of-value-vs-payment-system/ https://avc.com/2017/08/store-of-value-vs-payment-system/ I definitely agree that the banking system is antiquated, and that there's plenty of room for improvement. But cryptocurrencies do almost nothing to solve that problem. In comparison, look at M-Pesa. It started at about the same time as Bitcoin, but has had major success in serving the unbanked.
- hectorr1 8y agoHow much of Uber was simply rediscovering things that the taxi industry had already found?