10 ms·
GDPR is yet another moat for established companies. It may take them some time to adapt their data models and engineer systems for data deletion, but once they
by echelon 8y ago
GDPR is yet another moat for established companies. It may take them some time to adapt their data models and engineer systems for data deletion, but once they have done so, it becomes something every startup will have to implement in order to compete.
I'm not saying GDPR isn't good for privacy (we need it); it just makes competition harder.
- imustbeevil 8y agoI think of it like outlawing chemical pollution of rivers. Yes, a Corporation that manages not to dump toxic waste in rivers is going to have a moat against smaller companies that do dump toxic waste in rivers. But I'd rather it be illegal than have companies competing for who can externalize their costs more effectively by passing their problem of waste management to the state / local area.
- echelon 8y agoI'm not talking about corporations which have the means and the resources to engineer data pipelines that can be scrubbed and lawyers to deal with compliance. I'm speaking to the issue of you or I creating an MVP with a few months of dedicated hard work. How much extra time has to be spent on putting in place a process for data deletion? I'm working on GDPR right now at my company, and it's not a small effort.
- it_learnses 8y agoIt sounds like you don't really care about customer privacy and where their data ends up as long as you are able to deliver your "MVP". Please let me know what your company is so I would know to avoid it.
- adventured 8y ago> I'm speaking to the issue of you or I creating an MVP with a few months of dedicated hard work. How much extra time has to be spent on putting in place a process for data deletion? None. Do not target the EU initially, start in the US market with your MVP. It's by far the most liberal major market to do an MVP in, in all regards. It's the world's largest economy and easily accessible; plus you essentially get Canada as a bonus: a combined $21.5 trillion in economy. Entirely disregard GDPR until you've scaled the business enough to afford whatever you've calculated GDPR compliance will cost you in terms of effort / resources, then push into the EU when it's convenient.
- cheald 8y agoThat'd be fine if the GDPR were constrained to business done inside the EU, but it purports to exercise authority over any entity which asks for any information from any EU citizen, inside or outside of its borders. Enforcement and jurisdiction have yet to be tested yet, of course, but it isn't as simple as "don't set up shop in the EU".
- grigjd3 8y agoYeah, there is going to be a wealth of problems in this regard.
- adventured 8y agoIt doesn't matter what the EU purports, that's nothing more than a comical fantasy on their part. I live in the US, my business operates in the US, I operate by US law. It also doesn't matter what China purports I should do with their citizen data, or South Africa, or Australia, or Brazil: their wishes don't overrule the supremacy of US law inside the US. If China wants me to delete everything on my service about Tiananmen Square, or an anti-China activist, guess what, that's not going to happen for the exact same reason. I'm also not subject to the UK government's enforced media blackout on the Tommy Robinson arrest: they too can piss off. If a EU citizen signs up with my US based service, their data will be governed by US law. It is that simple. It will remain that simple. The US isn't going to cede its sovereignty to the EU: it's drastically more powerful than the EU in every regard. There is no scenario where the US lays back and allows the EU to legislate how the domestic US economy operates in such large ways. The only likely outcome is that the US comes up with its own new privacy rules in the next few years, which will be different - more lenient - than GDPR. If you want to operate in the two markets, you'll have to comply with each approach accordingly.
- cheald 8y agoI'd like to think that you're right, but I also don't want to be the guy that has to spend several hundred thousand dollars to defend that thesis in court.
- falcolas 8y ago> How much extra time has to be spent on putting in place a process for data deletion? Account for deletion when designing the product. When considered from the beginning, the cost is typically negligible. It's only when shoehorned on the end that it gets expensive. But... companies have had two years of notice about this. Any projects that have been running for fewer than two years have had plenty of notice. And it's not only the government who requires data deletion - it's your data sources (like Twitter) and your big customers who write it into their contracts. Just plan for being able to delete data. You are gonna need it.
- hshehehjdjdjd 8y agoThe only difference is that dumping toxic waste in rivers does actual, concrete harm. Targeted advertising? The worst I’ve heard about it is that it makes some people feel a little icky. I suppose that’s a concrete harm in a sense but it seems a much less serious one, at least to me.
- Krasnol 8y ago> The worst I’ve heard about it is that it makes some people feel a little icky. Yeah sure, all that privacy, who needs it anyway? /s
- conanbatt 8y agoIts interesting how one of the most frequent uses of the right to be forgotten is used by politicians cleaning up their search history. Who would have thought that legislators had something to gain from a proposal they push?
- Angostura 8y agoWho would have thought that legislators would be aware of legislation.
- hshehehjdjdjd 8y agoI’m sorry but this is not really a substantive objection to what I said. Yes, people have a vague preference for privacy. I never disputed that. No, failing to respect that preference has not caused material, externally visible harm.
- Krasnol 8y agoWe're not taking about some vague concept. For some of us it is part of the constitution. It's the RIGHT to privacy. Your attempts at downplaying it are the main vehicle of the advertisement industry and it's a disgrace at least. This ideology has educated those "people" to ignore that by hiding the means and downplaying the relevance. This law tries to at least regain some of the awareness that has been lost in the last decades and this is why the industry is crying so much.
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> I think of it like outlawing chemical pollution of rivers Nobody disagrees with GDPR's intent. The qualm is with its administrative approach. If someone said "write a bailout for lawyers and lobbyists," it would look like GDPR. Taking your analogy, a good law would assess a fine for dumping. A bad law would (a) require continuous certification that one is not dumping and (b) allow anyone to prompt an expensive inspection (done via writing letter responses to a regulator, not on-site inspection by an expert) by reporting you to one of twenty-eight national regulators, each of which have jurisdiction over you. The former imposes a fixed costs, regardless of compliance. That benefits incumbents. The latter promotes venue shopping, a further advantage to size and incumbency.
- phicoh 8y agoMaybe it comes as a surprise, but there are places where if you generate industrial waste (even as a relatively small company) you have to be able to demonstrate that you get rid it in a responsible way. And if somebody complains with a local government that you are dumping waste in a particular way, they will send somebody over to investigate. Note that the European consumer protection laws already allow consumers to sue in their own country. So if you do business in all EU country, you can be sued in lots of places. Maybe if you are continuously worried about regulators, then it is better to not start a business. In the real world, regulators are busy enough. Regulators are not going to bother random companies in other countries just for the fun of it.
- tomatotomato37 8y agoIt's not the technical aspect of not dumping into rivers that is the problem, its the administrative side of dealing with paperwork and inspectors verifying your business which is located 100 miles from the nearest river doesn't dump into a river In my opinion the GDPR should have tiered regulations based on global revenue. It's pretty hard to profit off of data and not have some sort of cash flow
- dbasedweeb 8y agoI'm not saying GDPR isn't good for privacy (we need it); it just makes competition harder. If easy competition is being paid for through shady practices, then it should never have been that easy. It’s a no-brainer that a large, established business has certain advantages over up-and-comers; GDPR didn’t make that the case either. It’s easier for a large, rich company to do almost anything, including respecting our privacy as enforced by regulation or law.
- hyperpape 8y ago> It’s easier for a large, rich company to do almost anything, including respecting our privacy as enforced by regulation or law. And also including doing creepy things with our private data that stay just on the right side of the law.
- cheald 8y agoThere's a consistent strain of conflation of this issue in all the GDPR threads, along the lines of "well, if you can't comply with the GDPR, you must be a evil company selling my data to bad people for bad reasons!" You don't have to be doing anything shady with data for the GDPR to be a threat to you and your business. You can be collecting a bare minimum of data that you only use with the purest of intentions and still be in violation of the law and subject to its penalties. Just asking for an email that will literally be used for nothing but to send a registration confirmation - you know, to sign up users, the same way we've been doing forever - puts you in its compliance crosshairs. You're now legally liable for a whole raft of additional compliance measures that probably necessitate paying a lawyer a decent chunk of change to make sure you're above board with. Your "MVP" has now expanded from "here's a simple idea I cranked out this weekend" to "here's a simple idea and a legal contract and audit trails that prove consent and an obligation to exfil data from my database on demand in perpetuity and data portability endpoints and data exchange contracts with every API provider I use and my database has to be encrypted at rest and highly redundant and I have to set up regular vulnerability scans and if I want to back up my database to a non-EU datacenter I have to obtain consent from all my users first and a bunch of additional requirements that possibly make it illegal to not age out my Apache access logs and why am I doing this at all again?" GDPR significantly increases the friction for moving new ideas from concept to product, even if there is absolutely zero nefarious happening in the product. If it only made life hard on the people engaged in shady practices, there'd be a lot less concern over it, but that's just not the case. It doesn't just punish the misuse of data, it punishes the lack of proactive compliance to a set of criteria which are frankly beyond many hobbyists. Some see this as a good thing. But I think that it's also fair to guess that it's going to cause otherwise good and benign ideas, products, and even entire companies to die on the vine as a result.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pscnv 8y agoI don't think "startups" should be able to get away with just doing a "deleted=1" with my personal data, or to not know where my data is ending up, just because they are "startups".
- Matticus_Rex 8y agoThere's a large distance between not knowing where your data ends up/using it badly and being actually GDPR-compliant, which in many businesses requires a massive administrative burden.
- falcolas 8y agoIf it requires a massive administrative burden, that company has collected or is in the business of collecting a lot of personal data. In which case, it's good that there's a burden, since they are holding a lot of sensitive data and should be held accountable for what they do with it, and how they allow it to be used.
- Matticus_Rex 8y ago1. One can collect "a lot" of personal data without any of it being sensitive. 2. The amount of personal data and the administrative burden are sometimes correlated, but often aren't. Collecting name and email from a few people in eighteen different ways creates a much, much larger administrative load than collecting name, email, and ten other items of information in a single way. 3. One can use all that personal data well and not violate the rights of data subjects without being remotely GDPR-compliant. 4. Most of the administrative burden does little to nothing for how well data subjects' data is used.
- matthewmacleod 8y agoOne can collect "a lot" of personal data without any of it being sensitive. I don't think this is the case at all. Essentially all personal data is sensitive. The amount of personal data and the administrative burden are sometimes correlated, but often aren't. Collecting name and email from a few people in eighteen different ways creates a much, much larger administrative load than collecting name, email, and ten other items of information in a single way. That's true, but also seems entirely reasonable. If you are collecting data in eighteen different ways, that means there are eighteen times as many ways you can fail to adequately audit or secure it. One can use all that personal data well and not violate the rights of data subjects without being remotely GDPR-compliant. Probably technically true, but in practice? Regulators are more concerned about compliance than anything else. Are there likely scenarios in which data is collected and processed in a responsible manner, but technical GDPR compliance is a huge burden? Most of the administrative burden does little to nothing for how well data subjects' data is used. Why would this be the case? Most of the administrative requirements appear to be entirely justified methods to ensure that you have understood and evaluated the methods of compliance.
- grosjona 8y agoIf a startup is able to collect enough data about their users such that they are able to monetize that data, then they aren't really a startup anymore. I highly doubt that Google is pleased with the current situation as the article implies.
- Angostura 8y agoAlternatively, start-ups that bake in privacy by design, have a substantial advantage over lumbering established companies that have to adjust their existing processes and may - in some cases - discover that their business models are funadementally at odds with the regulations.
- panarky 8y ago> yet another moat for established companies What if GDPR is what pushes distributed computing into the mainstream? If GDPR makes it even harder for small fry to compete with the giants, then the small fry should change the rules. Zero centralized servers, zero PII, no EULAs, no legaleze, only open-source P2P. Megacorps can be GDPR-compliant with buildings full of lawyers, and the rest will be GDPR-irrelevant with no lawyers at all.
- nopriorarrests 8y ago>zero PII, no EULAs, no legaleze, only open-source P2P how that should work exactly? I mean, even if platform is P2P, you still have user id, you still have user interests, et cetera. The only thing changed bc of P2P is that it gets much more complicated, or even impossible, to delete your account/data.
- panarky 8y ago> you still have user id, you still have user interests No _you_ don't. Peers on the network may have this but there's no entity subject to GDPR. So if GDPR tilts the playing field in favor of the megacorps, perhaps it also encourages anonymity and distributed networks.