3 ms·
Germany is a welfare state and yet children from poor parents perform worse in school.
by adrianN 8y ago
Germany is a welfare state and yet children from poor parents perform worse in school.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- adventured 8y agoThe US is a welfare state. Its welfare programs consume a larger share of GDP than the welfare programs of Canada or Australia, and is just below Switzerland. The US is spending 19.3% of its GDP on social welfare programs, just behind the UK at 21.5%. https://i.imgur.com/JQfZ5vi.png https://i.imgur.com/JQfZ5vi.png Inflation adjusted per capita income transfers have roughly doubled since 1990, from ~$4,400 to ~$8,600 in 2016.
- noir-york 8y agoSo where is all the money going? The UK has a (diminshed) NHS and spends less as a % of GDP. I suspect that a big part of it is that money is being wasted (the Fed.Gov cannot negotiate drug prices!), and not reaching the intended beneficiaries. My perception is that there is an industrial-welfare complex that diverts the money.
- Wohlf 8y agoIt's going towards cost disease, waste, bureaucracy, nepotism, lawsuits, etc.
- noir-york 8y agoIt used to, and then Schröder passed the Hartz reforms and the German welfare state has never been the same since.
- bildung 8y agoOf course they still perform worse, a school cannot magically change the parents of those students into middle class parents. A better question would be: Is the performance gap between poor students and middle class students lower in Germany?
- nunya213 8y agoIndeed but they perform much better relative to the difference between poor and rich students in the US.